Live data from Hacker News

MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

origin-discussions2-us-dr-prz.apple.com

391–400 of 588 posts

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#391

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Both of your examples are software related. In my experience, anything hardware related Apple tends to shift the blame to the consumer. I wonder how much of their profits are based on repairs.

Who knows if it’s true but apple has publicly stated they lose money on repairs. https://www.engadget.com/2019-11-21-apple-repair-costs.html

Well, repair is included in the hefty price tag. Anything else about this is just noise.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#392

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You only hear about it because it’s Apple and they have like 6 SKUs of products that they sell millions of. When the batteries bulge or screens fail on some random Dell made by a subcontractor in Vietnam, nobody cares as they have like 80 models of laptop for every market segment. The bullshit thing in my mind is that Apple took away the ability for store staff to make discretionary calls to bypass stuff like this an…

They pretend that because have only 6 SKUs is because they have “high quality” premium products. But the high quality part lacks credibility. For only 6 SKUs, they should be able to perform better quality control & testing than this.

It’s a double edged sword. Their economies of scale are insane. But when shit goes wrong, it’s really bad.

A significant part of my business is sourcing lots and lots of computers. We’re assholes to our suppliers, and I can say that generally the parts that are the most reliable are devices that straddle the business and consumer space. Volume drives success, at a threshold price.

iPhones and Samsung Galaxies are almost problem free. Desktops are generally problem free until ~30 months. Laptops have higher failure rates, and cheaper device categories fail more than pricey devices. Last time I looked, MacBooks were among the most reliable, consistent with my experience.

Places like Gartner and IDC have this data. Usually you can find references to it online.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#393
post #206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would it? Seriously a large proportion even of the users bitten by this will still run to buy the next shiny apple device they release and then there is the other part of the users who are not affected and will blame the affected users for doing something wrong, because apple can't be in the wrong. I never understood the personal attachment and identification that some brands elicit it people (but credit to Apple…

I don’t know that its what Apple does right but that the broader PC market continues to shoot itself in the foot. Little things like pre-installed bloatware and the inability to figure out smooth trackpad scrolling (still!) keep me firmly on Apple devices. And more recently, the M1 platform is remarkable, so I tip my hat to them for that and doing the basic stuff right (mostly—there have been blemishes obviously).

What floors me is I've had several hilariously cheap Chromebooks and they all have better trackpads than every single PC I've owned. How!?

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#394

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's an ongoing joke in the military, MIL-SPEC just means it's a piece of crap that's going to break pretty soon. From an engineering point of view, I'd like to believe that using all MIL-SPEC components which are rated to last longer and in harsher environments would amount to a more reliable product. But maybe a product is more than the sum of its parts, and it's possible a company can build a more reliable prod…

MIL-SPEC just means it conforms to a spec. Whether that means "rugged" or just "standardized" really depends on why and when the spec was written. I've managed production of a number of "MIL-SPEC" parts over the years. Usually it just meant documentation and traceability.

and that is just the kind of assurance some consumers are willing to pay for.. with sophistication in manufacturing quality can be made to be varied from batch to batch. Sometimes they don't even bother, ie. I no longer trust board revision from gigabyte, same rev diff layout diff components are far too common. not sure how it's economical, but the fact that it IS economical tells me something is way off.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#395

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Both of your examples are software related. In my experience, anything hardware related Apple tends to shift the blame to the consumer. I wonder how much of their profits are based on repairs.

Anyone who's read my comments knows I don't usually have the patience to be charming or whatever. I had a battery start bulging with a polycarbonate MacBook and they just gave me a battery off the shelf no questions asked. There was some other underlying problem, and I eventually scrapped it. Its replacement eventually heated up the charging cable enough that the insulation browned and flaked away (computer side so i…

>The problem as I see it is that Apple is relying almost entirely on the discretion of their retail staff instead of having a formal policy in place.

So, I worked behind the genius Bar about a decade ago, and can tell you that at least as of then (say iPhone 3g through 6 era) this was definitely not the case. There’s a policy for everything.

The issue is that you’re an individual, dealing with another individual who is acting as the intermediary between you and an extraordinarily large and complex logistics and record-keeping system.

If you left feeling taken care of and treated fairly, from apple’s POV that’s a successful interaction. But the procedure for getting there may deliberately not be customer-facing; that doesn’t mean the procedure doesn’t exist.

I can answer questions if people are interested, with the caveat that my info is (thankfully) not fresh.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#396

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then why hasn’t it happened for other macbooks? The corners of my 2012 are noticeably deformed from impacts and the screen is fine

Is the screen more slammable (for lack of a better word)? My HP has these two rubber stoppers that prevent the Screen from slamming the keyboard.

Macs have always had that, but the newer ones have this issue where the screen hits the keyboard. Never happened with the older fatter models from a decade ago.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#397
post #299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I bought a Framework laptop, new screen is cheap and very very easy to swap in yourself.

Framework is my dream machine, still waiting for an Australia launch. Also hoping we'll see them execute on some additional keyboard layouts (or someone will) - avoiding Mac-like keyboards is one of my primary desires laptop wise.

I'd love a split, ortholinear, semi-ergonomic keyboard for a laptop but know it'll never happen on a mass-market device. The framework has the best change of making it possible because they couldd just sell that keyboard to those who want it without needing them to sell the rest of the laptop as part of the package. Still not likely to happen, but I can dream...

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#398

What's with all the comments on that Apple thread where people are saying "I didn't have a grain of cereal, rice, etc between the screen"? Are Macbook screens that fragile now?

Many laptop screens are that fragile. We repair computers and it’s quite common to see a broken screen because someone closed something inside the clamshell accidentally. I’ve seen everything from pencils, pens, erasers, paper with staples, paper clips…

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#399
post #306
post #228

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bad advice, IME. First Intel Mac, first iPhone, first Apple Watch… for that matter, second Mac ever, and, however you want to rank it, an Apple ][. I don’t regret any of them (my mother paid for the early Apple and Mac, but I know she didn’t regret the either).

Just one of many examples in my 20+ years of using Apple computers and hardware, personally and professionally, for my company employees. First Cinema Display 30". In my country of origin, at the time, the cost was comparable to a second hand good car. Only 5 displays were sold, 4 of them for a local telecommunication provider for their luxury offices. One for me. The screen was unevenly lit and on white/gray backgro…

I guess it depends on your country?

Where I am, you could return an Apple product whether you had AppleCare or not. I returned three 2009 iMacs before getting an OK one, never had AppleCare.

You might get “lucky” sometimes but generally insurance is sold at a profit, so if it’s something you can afford to self-insure (and it’s legal), you’re usually better off with that in the long run. AppleCare isn’t bad, though, IMO.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#400

I can say without a doubt, the Mac minis are really good though. It should be illegal to sell a desktop computer with a hard drive that can never be replaced. All hard drives go bad eventually, and while my 2012 Mac mini allowed me to keep swapping out the hard drive. Which made it a great computer up until I kind of retired it when I bought a new m1 Mac mini. The current m1 Mac minis are all guaranteed to die within…

It's so ironic that this is the end game for a company that thought they were saving the earth by making you buy a charger for you cell phone separately
Post reply on HN