Live data from Hacker News

New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

nytimes.com

541–550 of 1001 posts

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#541
post #508

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do we frequently go after the drops that cause a lot of headache and inconvenience, then?

Because we have to go after all drops

How about we go after the coal power plants first? Or allow nuclear reactors on shipping vessels? Both of those will have 1000x more benefit than paper straws and electric stoves, whose benefits are questionable at best. There's plenty of lower-hanging fruit to go after.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#542
post #445

This regulation feels quite frustrating to me, and several comments in this thread illustrate why. This change is being promoted as a critical step in the fight against climate change. (See most news articles over the past two years covering this.) But when you dig into the details, it seems like the regulation may not have much effect on climate change at all. When you point this out to advocates, you'll get an enti…

I _rent_ a home, as do a full half of new york state residents. I'd love an electric stove. Every rental I've ever lived in has a gas stove and no fume hood. The full half of new yorkers who rent - almost 20 million people - mostly get whatever theirlandlord picked. So when I read posts like this, decrying government overreach, I wonder if you've ever been poor? Have you ever lived here? Do you know what youre talkin…

Thanks for speaking out, not in NYC but I feel just the same. People love to think freedom is whatever an industry is telling them it is in ads. Health and environmental issues, and social issues for us plebs, only advance with hard won legislation.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#543

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Conservative media bubble told their flock that 87,000 IRS federal agents were being hired to come to everyone's houses Did they actually say that, cause that sounds pretty hyperbolic to what their narrative actually was, which is that 87k agents were being hired which would effectively be targeting middle class and small businesses, instead of big corps. I have friends who were were wrongfully audited, and it’s a…

I was being hyperbolic. I didn't pay attention to the 87k news, since Fox News and Ted Cruz talked about it I assumed it was meaningless distraction.

> I was being hyperbolic

Yes. You and the people you are criticizing.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#544
post #521
post #445

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I _rent_ a home, as do a full half of new york state residents. I'd love an electric stove. Every rental I've ever lived in has a gas stove and no fume hood. The full half of new yorkers who rent - almost 20 million people - mostly get whatever theirlandlord picked. So when I read posts like this, decrying government overreach, I wonder if you've ever been poor? Have you ever lived here? Do you know what youre talkin…

I also _rent_. I hate food cooked on electric stoves, so when I was looking to rent, anything that dint have gas stove was automatic non-starter for me. This whole argument that “you oppose a forced choice so you must hate poor people” is just a straw-man. Just because you prefer things one way doesn’t mean govt has a business telling me how I should cook my food.

I suspect you're conflating resistance cooktops (the kind with coils that heat up) and induction cooktops (which use EM fields to transfer energy directly into the pan). Resistance cooktops are slow and weak, but induction cooktops are just plain better than gas (faster to heat across the entire temperature range, better temperature control) in pretty much every case except when needing a pan that doesn't fit the induction plate (like a round-bottom wok).

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#545
post #503

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The alternatives to gas are so good these days that there's no way I'd pay to connect any new house to gas.

Gas alliances are significantly cheaper to run. Also perform better. Gas dryers are awesome compared to electric for example. Plus electric goes out often. Gas doesn’t.

This simply isn’t true any more.

The price of gas is going up, and the price of electricity is plummeting thanks to renewables.

Also, the efficiency of electric ranges has doubled in recent years. Heatpumps are something like 3-10x more efficient than older systems.

Our electric dryer greatly outperforms any old gas dryers we had, and it wasn’t significantly more expensive.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#546

This regulation feels quite frustrating to me, and several comments in this thread illustrate why. This change is being promoted as a critical step in the fight against climate change. (See most news articles over the past two years covering this.) But when you dig into the details, it seems like the regulation may not have much effect on climate change at all. When you point this out to advocates, you'll get an enti…

About the argument over climate change : The thing is that although stoves don't represent much not in proportion to total consumption of gas, it acts as foot in the door for the gas industry.

That's a fine strategy, but practically speaking, if you're looking for a foot in the door, I'd start with something that doesn't anger more than half of your constituency.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#547

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have never seen an actual fume hood in any residential home in my life (close to 800 homes across the South and New England. I have seen plenty of faux hoods that do absolutely nothing. Maybe it's something they only add in luxury homes.

I find this very shocking NY allows that. I'm in CA and I've never seen a gas stove that didn't have a fume hood. In fact a lot of electric stoves here have fume hoods. I would assume we have a regulation about it here but I've never looked it up.

I've lived in several places in the US, and every residential range hood I've seen vents back into the living space.

I would believe it's different in CA, though. CA's public health regulations are famously stricter than elsewhere in the country.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#548
post #503

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The alternatives to gas are so good these days that there's no way I'd pay to connect any new house to gas.

Gas alliances are significantly cheaper to run. Also perform better. Gas dryers are awesome compared to electric for example. Plus electric goes out often. Gas doesn’t.

Stoves aren’t particularly expensive to run, but gas stoves are hilariously inefficient and induction is nearly 100% efficient. And gas stoves plus the heat loss due to required ventilation in a cold climate are even worse.

Gas heat and hot water may be cheaper or more expensive than heat pumps depending on utility rates and climate. Too bad residential gas-fires cogeneration isn’t really a thing.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#549

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As California has shown multiple times, dependence on electricity alone can be disastrous.

California's strategy for electricity is non-existent. We have been perpetually at peak electricity use since 25+ years since I came here. Meanwhile electricity use from EVs has soared, and we don't have enough electricity for everything. AND we attempted to shut down nuclear power plants but that appears to be on hold for now. Plus, I'm paying over $0.50/kWh when I hit Tier 3, which I hit after 2 charges of my EV. E…

What's the rooftop solar situation where you're at? I live in Oregon and maybe a fifth of the houses in my neighborhood have rooftop solar. A friend of mine in California mentioned that their rooftop solar setup fully covered all their usage and had them selling about 30% of their power generation back to the grid. Seems like an obvious win in California.

Re: New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings

#550
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most people around here buy enough battery or generators to keep the power on. PG&E is way below one nine of availability this year, but the outlets inside our house are at 6 nines followed by an eight. Granted, once the propane rationing started, a few of our neighbors lost power for extended periods of time (weeks). The phone company doesn’t maintain internet if the power is out, but there is starlink, and fiber co…

> PG&E is way below one nine of availability this year You’ve been without utility power for two full weeks in 2023?!

It’s becoming more and more common, especially in places with older homes which the East Coast is full of. There are many, many millions of home with 100A or even 50A service. That was standard until the 80’s and 90’s. The grid was built to support that.

But now a lot more people run AC and electric car charging, among other things like induction ranges. The infrastructure is struggling to keep up. A lot of it is super old and it’s not uncommon to come across 50 year old transformers, etc.

Brownouts and blackouts have become rather common.

But the gas always works. Where I live a lot of people have installed natural gas generators.

Post reply on HN