about time
YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
611–620 of 881 posts
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#612Last weekend a group of friends and I sat by the lake. One had a guitar, and we were all singing off-key to old classics and dancing to salsa and reggaeton. We were doing it together, and it was great. Much more fun than listening alone or caring about the authenticity of the music or not. It was the participation, not the product, that was the key. Something went wrong with music and culture in recent times. Partici…
[deleted]
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#613Earlier quoted context omitted.
Haha, I get it. Just took him as an example because, in my experience, he is a famous pianist people recognise even if they don't listen to that kind of music. Maybe Vladimir Horowitz would be a better example.
I think the average person has no idea who either of those people are. I think Liszt or Rachmaninov would be better reference points.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#614Earlier quoted context omitted.
Just re-upload it. AI generated work cant be copyrighted.
Even if the courts won't uphold the copyright, that doesn't prevent people from claiming your videos and initiating YouTube's copyright process against you. This is a recurring problem for people who upload their own original performances of public-domain compositions, particularly solo piano.
What if you claim it first against them? You wouldn't be punished for a false claim, since they're not.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#615Earlier quoted context omitted.
>we need to stop filming people As live music enjoyer and person that was commonly around safe spaces in the techno scene I cant agree more. Fuck filming people.
It's not even just music anymore. I love motor racing, but at the last meeting I went to, sat in the stands at an iconic first corner, tense with anticipation as the race started... Everyone around me sat there holding their phones up, filming it. I couldn't even see properly because of the forest of arms. People don't just... experience... something now. What's even more ridiculous is that this wasn't a small race -…
Phoning like that damages their brains for sure.
Hope there will be research.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#616Earlier quoted context omitted.
I was in a park today, and I watched a man play a saxaphone. Other people had stopped to listen to him play. It occurred to me that we appreciate this kind of public performance, but we get annoyed if someone plays their boombox too loud in public. I tend to agree with you about participation, but I feel like there is a note unsung here.
> I tend to agree with you about participation, but I feel like there is a note unsung here. I think we value _effort_.
And skill. Using AI is basically zero effort and tends to produce half-assed output. It's no wonder people are put off by it.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#617Earlier quoted context omitted.
Maybe this is were we will end up, society combined of individualistic, self-centered, non-empathetic, sociopaths. But can it be still called society?
My point was narrower. When I write the lyrics, choose the melody, and use AI to help turn it into a polished arrangement, the result has personal meaning to me. It reflects my memories, taste, and emotional state. That does not make it superior to other music. It just makes it personal. I can resonates with songs made by other people if it align with my current emotional state. I just don't spent time actively explo…
Yes, I understand what you are writing about. But to be true, I am not sure if this is right thing to do. After all it seems like you are closing yourself in a bubble of your own experiences and emotions. Will you be able to talk to other people and relate to their own emotions and experiences if you will be only ever thinking about your own?
What I really like when I was young, was to talk to my friends about what we find in Diablo II. Or how I like or dislike some band.
Can you talk about your own AI generated music with your friends if this is some intimate?
But this is just my take on that, mate. You do you.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#618Earlier quoted context omitted.
What is the problem if somebody doesn’t seek the deep meaning or anything and enjoys whatever she enjoys? Plenty of artists plain suck and discovery is a problem that requires time and effort. If somebody makes decision to like what they like (and made, to some extent) that’s their choice.
Yeah people seem to forget that before AI music, there was already a huge amount of "slop" music out there - background music, muzak, mood music. Hell, Spotify was put in the spotlight not that long ago for commissioning music to mix into their own most popular mixes (the casual background listening ones), so that they own the rights themselves and don't need to pay artists as much. A lot of music is for mass consump…
None of that is what I would call slop music. All of that is real music for real people with real use case.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#619Hopefully this will also include human-generated content with AI scripts, which are not that hard to detect but require a certain amount of wasted time listening to the slop before I skip the video.
Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
#620I'm curious where the line is.. several ambiguous but common scenarios: - Occasional AI b-roll during explainer videos - AI generated backing track (music) - AI generated shots sprinkled in a short film - Showing examples of AI video as an AI capability update or commentary
More scenarios: - AI generated VFX on top of non-AI video - AI upscaling of low res footage - AI frame interpolation for synthetic slow-mo - Modified / composited AI video - Footage created by "Extend Scene" features in Premiere Pro and others - Word correction from tools like Descript - AI relighting or colorization - Reaction video to a video containing AI-generated content And in general, what amount of combinatio…
All of them in any amount and yes, your specific 3 seconds should be labeled as being AI generated in your video (or description) and your entire video should be labeled as made using AI by youtube.
A 30 minute speech by a president where I use AI to change 3 seconds in order to make that person say something they never did should also get the label. The label shouldn't be about how much AI was used, but that it was used at all.