Live data from Hacker News

Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

edri.org

31–40 of 55 posts

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#31
So much ignorance in this thread.

Quite staggering considering this is HN.

If you're upset by security vs privacy at airports - don't Google how cell phones and credit cards work...

..and for the love of sanity - don't ask yourself how often you did not bring a phone and only used cash during a trip abroad.

Good luck. Make sure you take your meds.

..if by any chance you DO want to educate yourself - the reality is - removal of airport security only benefits criminals and mad people looking to hurt you.

Privacy battles are fought elsewhere.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#32
post #26
post #25

It's interesting how we can all have such opposit judgments while sharing roughly the same education/experiences, and that it usually falls into a 50/50 share. I think an automated system to identify criminals in the most likely 'points of exit' is quite remarkable. I know that throughout history government have not really been so gentle, but that's an anoher topic -we get the governments we deserve. On the other han…

I travelled from Australia to Malaysia to Canada (with a stopover in Dubai), and all the time I had 2 1/2 bottles of water (probably 1.5 litres) in my carry-on bag that I had forgotten. Something about a 46-hour journey, perhaps. I went through 8 security gates, and no one ever stopped or questioned me about the water. And when I found it at my destination, I threw it out.

Weren't you thirsty, mate?

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#33
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I travelled from Australia to Malaysia to Canada (with a stopover in Dubai), and all the time I had 2 1/2 bottles of water (probably 1.5 litres) in my carry-on bag that I had forgotten. Something about a 46-hour journey, perhaps. I went through 8 security gates, and no one ever stopped or questioned me about the water. And when I found it at my destination, I threw it out.

Airports in UK have started lifting the fluid limits, the new X-ray machines are much better at determining the contents. So as airports upgrade those rules may finally be getting obsoleted.

Can't happen soon enough. My wife tried to bring home a nice little bottle of scotch from Edinburgh and security confiscated because they could not convince themselves that 10 dL They did offer to ship the bottle to us at our expense, but the shipping fee was over a hundred pounds and it was cheaper to buy a much larger bottle of the same stuff from an importer.

I hope some day we can dispense with the security theater.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#34
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I travelled from Australia to Malaysia to Canada (with a stopover in Dubai), and all the time I had 2 1/2 bottles of water (probably 1.5 litres) in my carry-on bag that I had forgotten. Something about a 46-hour journey, perhaps. I went through 8 security gates, and no one ever stopped or questioned me about the water. And when I found it at my destination, I threw it out.

Airports in UK have started lifting the fluid limits, the new X-ray machines are much better at determining the contents. So as airports upgrade those rules may finally be getting obsoleted.

That is good news!

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#35
post #31

So much ignorance in this thread. Quite staggering considering this is HN. If you're upset by security vs privacy at airports - don't Google how cell phones and credit cards work... ..and for the love of sanity - don't ask yourself how often you did not bring a phone and only used cash during a trip abroad. Good luck. Make sure you take your meds. ..if by any chance you DO want to educate yourself - the reality is -…

great example, there are like 50% of people that share yours point of view on the subject (cameras not bad), and another 50% who have the strict opposit opinion (cameras not good).

And each is usually hard to convince otherwise, and many judge the opposit group.

Me I dont care, I just want cheaper bottles of water in airport.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#36
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Last time I came into the USA from Europe they never checked my passport. They know who is on each arriving flight and match faces to passport records.

I thought that’s Global Entry which requires going through an in person interview process and paying an application fee (if I remember correctly)?

I just have a normal US passport.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#37
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is being in an airport actually considered private? It's a public space, and you must show ID to gain access to the secured area. Additionally, you are subjected to baggage and carry-on inspection, as well as body inspection and metal detection, etc. There are cameras everywhere, monitoring and recording everything. Presumably this system was designed to recognize individuals that may be traveling under false-identit…

> Additionally, you are subjected to baggage and carry-on inspection, as well as body inspection and metal detection, etc. There are cameras everywhere, monitoring and recording everything Well, yeah, all of that presents a privacy problem. Automation is taking it a step further, but if I had my way boarding a plane would be like boarding a train or bus. I could concede a fast-moving checkpoint that does some best-ef…

>Securing the cockpit doors on planes is a good idea though.

Unless your pilot is having a particularly bad day.

I did recently see a video of a pilot that proposed to his girlfriend as she boarded his plane.

I bet all the passengers were thinking "Please, please say 'yes'", and were overly-happy both for the newly-engaged couple, and more for themselves that she did.

No, I don't have an answer to the door problem.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#38
post #35
post #31

So much ignorance in this thread. Quite staggering considering this is HN. If you're upset by security vs privacy at airports - don't Google how cell phones and credit cards work... ..and for the love of sanity - don't ask yourself how often you did not bring a phone and only used cash during a trip abroad. Good luck. Make sure you take your meds. ..if by any chance you DO want to educate yourself - the reality is -…

great example, there are like 50% of people that share yours point of view on the subject (cameras not bad), and another 50% who have the strict opposit opinion (cameras not good). And each is usually hard to convince otherwise, and many judge the opposit group. Me I dont care, I just want cheaper bottles of water in airport.

It's not cameras not good, it's face recognition not good. Because face recognition not good.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#39
post #35
post #31

So much ignorance in this thread. Quite staggering considering this is HN. If you're upset by security vs privacy at airports - don't Google how cell phones and credit cards work... ..and for the love of sanity - don't ask yourself how often you did not bring a phone and only used cash during a trip abroad. Good luck. Make sure you take your meds. ..if by any chance you DO want to educate yourself - the reality is -…

great example, there are like 50% of people that share yours point of view on the subject (cameras not bad), and another 50% who have the strict opposit opinion (cameras not good). And each is usually hard to convince otherwise, and many judge the opposit group. Me I dont care, I just want cheaper bottles of water in airport.

Cameras are mostly a threat to people that have to use burner phones and crypto at work.

If you want privacy, close your bank account, throw away your phone, use cash, don't own property, quit your day job etc etc

Worrying about cameras is naive at best.

Re: Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

#40
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

great example, there are like 50% of people that share yours point of view on the subject (cameras not bad), and another 50% who have the strict opposit opinion (cameras not good). And each is usually hard to convince otherwise, and many judge the opposit group. Me I dont care, I just want cheaper bottles of water in airport.

It's not cameras not good, it's face recognition not good. Because face recognition not good.

Face rec can be problematic if used with bad imagery and without proper oversight - agree.

Like all powerful tools it has to be used responsibly.

My point is merely that we are all tracked by other means that affect our life in much deeper and profound ways.

..like for example purchase history, cell phone location, internet use etc bought and sold by private corporations, with little to no oversight.

Post reply on HN