Live data from Hacker News

Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

forum.f-droid.org

101–110 of 199 posts

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#101

F-Droid are in the FA stage of FAFO. If they don't reverse this, they will find themselves in the FO stage. Anyone can hold the opinion that "religion or its texts are ruinous" but you can never apply it in practice in a liberal democracy (even in secular states) simply because religious and expression rights are legally protected. Don't moral police people especially on something that is as controversial as this.

[dead]

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#102
It's a bit jarring how obtuse a lot of people are in that thread, since two things can be true:

- Religious books are not for kids

- They aren't primarily written to be violent

Instead it's more like a Mexican stand off, whoever first tries to be reasonable gets shot.

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#103
This seems reasonable. The content includes themes (death, rape, violence, etc) that are generally considered NSFW by most modern day rating agencies. Just because cultures have historically seeded the texts for a long period of time doesn't make them SFW. If ESRB/MPAA had to rate a modern reboot, I don't think it would get a T/PG-13.

Personally, I wouldn't want my kids exposed to this kind of material without at least having a chance to talk to them about it first. Would you want your child getting sucked into something like Scientology without your knowledge?

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#104
post #66
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

F-Droid is no longer accepting "NSFW" apps (as they dubiously define them) and will eventually remove them from the repo. This tag is only a stopgap until they figure out how to move them out of the F-Droid repo.

https://gitlab.com/fdroid/admin/-/issues/252 Was not aware of this and it does put the flagging in a different light.

Honestly, that feels like someone doing malicious compliance to jam up the nsfw ban. Of course by most standards that include written content the bible, quran etc. (and plenty of popular media series like a song of ice and fire) are nsfw, but the people pushing for age restriction/nsfw bans would usually strongly feel "except those ones" and by applying the label you force them to either explain or codify the double standard.

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#106

F-Droid are in the FA stage of FAFO. If they don't reverse this, they will find themselves in the FO stage. Anyone can hold the opinion that "religion or its texts are ruinous" but you can never apply it in practice in a liberal democracy (even in secular states) simply because religious and expression rights are legally protected. Don't moral police people especially on something that is as controversial as this.

Or this could be the FO itself. Both the threshold for NSFW as well as anti-puritanism sentiment has crept up so high that it has reached "religion is a cancer" stage.

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#107
I think there's a large cultural bias at play here. Different nations have different relationships to religion. As a french person, the decision to mark religious content as NSFW seems totally normal to me, but I also know that french people are (often too) fierce atheists.

I also understand things are different in many places, but I think the argument is too heated right now, maybe everyone needs to take a step back and think in a more "international" way?

Someone in the linked thread suggested a new tag altogether for religious content, that might be a sound decision.

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#108

Freedom of religion is a fundamental right. Tagging a religious book or a reader of such as "NSFW" means, declaring it as "not normal". Declaring something, which is a fundamental right, as not normal, is discrimination.

Religion is not normal and I don't want it, so well done.

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#109

Freedom of religion is a fundamental right. Tagging a religious book or a reader of such as "NSFW" means, declaring it as "not normal". Declaring something, which is a fundamental right, as not normal, is discrimination.

But religions are only normal once they have numbers, theres no judgement on the content. These cults just have to survive and thrive long enough to become normalised.

Re: Bible and Quran apps flagged NSFW by F-Droid

#110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "Then shall he say also unto them on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels". -- Matthew 25:41 That's supposed to be a quote from Jesus, personally. In fact he's talking about himself saying that in the future. See that word "everlasting"? Other translations use "eternal". It's permanent Hell. It's really, really clear. He doesn't have to talk much abo…

Yes, I don't disagree with you here. In my opinion this doesn't describe anything happening in this world, so it is not relevant, whether to label it NSFW, and it isn't encouraging you to be violent in this world.

subjecting people to eternal punishment for a fleeting crime and dehumanising some people is okay?
Post reply on HN