Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

github.com

181–190 of 238 posts

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#181
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> For many graphics professionals, that's like asking if you'd consider replacing C++ with Rust. So, that's a yes?

Imagine if no C++ compiler existed for your operating system. Even if most of the code you write is Rust, would you be able to use this operating system?

I don't understand this analogy because every tool touted as a photoshop replacement supports PSD.

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#182

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The day Proton or WINE can run the whole Adobe suite of products is the day I will probably switch to using Linux full time.

Would you consider replacing the Adobe suite with other products?

Maybe one day Okular will finally enter the 21st century and start supporting signing pdfs with digital cert signatures and become a viable replacement.

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, that scheme would be too hard to contain so the three letter agencies are blatant about it. They just let tech companies develop these things and know they'll have access to the data anyway. For every real user that finds a tool slurping up data to be useful, there are 100 law enforcement agents also saying it's useful so everyone should hop on the bandwagon.

It's not possible for you to know how hard to contain it is. The commonality of strange beliefs like this makes me seriously wonder if there is an initiative on social media to teach this form of thinking as being correct, because it is certainly the default. Try defecting from the game for a month and watch the other players from the sidelines, and see if you don't see what I'm talking about.

Generally the more people you tell, the harder it is to keep a secret. I don't what makes that a "strange belief" but okay.

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#184
post #170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In addition to making sure that the EAC runtime is installed, try setting the compatibility command to: SDL_VIDEODRIVER=windows,x11 %command% This is a typical problem with EAC.

Every thread that starts with "Linux gaming is basically 100% ready now" progresses into hacks like this :)

To be fair, every thread that starts with "Win 11 can still be debloated" progresses into registry hacks too :)

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#185
post #100

So glad I switched to Linux and got away from this garbage. Now I have to convince my employer to also allow Linux on their workstations. Windows 7 was the last good OS from MSFT but even that had a bit of telemetry.

I recently made the switch to linux full time as well. Even small things, like my computer taking three seconds from clicking Shutdown to turning off, is such a relief compared to Win11.

The year of linux on desktop, everyone!

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From my experience, it's still not a 100% replacement. For example, there are no drivers for a pretty common steering wheel (Logitech G923). There is a driver for an older version of the wheel that kind of works, but no TRUEFORCE support. And even then, you have to mess with some low level details to make it work, send magic values to the hardware on plugging it in. I also noticed that games from Steam end up taking…

> For example, there are no drivers for a pretty common steering wheel (Logitech G923). This is a nice, specific detail. Most of these comments are very vague. > There is a driver for an older version of the wheel that kind of works Do you mean an out of tree driver? Would you test this and post back? The 6.3 kernel they mentioned 3 months ago is very old and likely a forked kernel. https://www.reddit.com/r/linux_gam…

I think the point OP was trying to make is that there's still a large amount of programs and devices that don't work on wine. Probably for at least as many people that "everything just works" for, the opposite is true in my experience.

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#187

For those who don't know, Microsoft Recall is a system that screenshots what you do every few seconds, and uses OpenAI's vision api to allow search on eveything you did in the past. There's an article from Sep 27th where they promise you'll be able to uninstall Recall: https://www.theverge.com/2024/9/27/24255721/microsoft-window... , not sure what that means for this explorer.exe dependency.

Windows Recall doesn’t use OpenAI or any online API. The indexing and OCR is done by a local model, in a Secure Enclave powered by VBS and encrypted with the system TPM. AKA: a virtualization-separated process with storage inaccessible to the OS (all lookup etc. is done over RPC).

Source: https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2024/09/27/updat...

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not directed at you but I find it funny that people (rightfully!) complain about Microsoft spyware and then run some dubious scripts from who-knows-where. With the added side effects that these scripts always disable/remove waaaay too much and break the install which then lead to users cursing Microsoft for things that the user has broken without knowing.

key difference being - copilot and recall were added to my operating system without my consent - microsoft did not ask before they added these things, via windows update. those dubious scripts from who-knows-where are run by me, with intent and with my consent, having passed whatever my own personal review process might be for that particular script. If I try something and it turns out bad, that's on me, and I'm okay…

>If I try something and it turns out bad, that's on me, and I'm okay with that

That's ok, I'm critizing those that run these scripts without checking (and understanding!) them and then blame Microsoft when things go south (think of the "stick in own bicycle" meme). This is not a defense of Microsoft, they are also to blame that users feel the need to run these scripts because dubious stuff like Recall gets added and/or automatically activated without asking.

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Epic bought them, moved it to the Epic Store which has no Linux support. Makes sense to drop it.

supporting Epic is one of the most shooting-yourself-in-the-foot moves you can make as a gamer.

you could say the same about any corporation

Re: Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency

#190
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not directed at you but I find it funny that people (rightfully!) complain about Microsoft spyware and then run some dubious scripts from who-knows-where. With the added side effects that these scripts always disable/remove waaaay too much and break the install which then lead to users cursing Microsoft for things that the user has broken without knowing.

What would get disabled that "breaks the install"

I don't have a list but over the years I've seen a lot of people that had problems after running these. This was also prevalent for earlier Windows versions and especially by "gamers" who thought they could squeeze more FPS out of their machines. Failing Windows updates come to mind, especially major Win10 & Win11 updates.
Post reply on HN