Live data from Hacker News

True Name – Mastercard (2022)

mastercard.com

81–90 of 182 posts

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#82
post #5

>When Asher DiGiuseppe tried to make a purchase at his local Toronto liquor store, the clerk looked at him with suspicion and questioned his card, which was still printed with the name he had used before transitioning. >[...] New research by Mastercard across 16 countries in North America and Europe revealed that 59% of people who identity as nonbinary say they feel unsafe while shopping, and 57% say they think it’s…

Yes, it’s a serious issue.

Eons ago when I first started to transition I was prevented from making a purchase once because my card didn’t match my female me.

The clerk then seemingly took delight in increasing the volume of their voice when informing me.

The irony being that at work one our cute “pretty plastic people” girls used the male bosses CC all the time.

Should it matter? No, but until people evolve into human beings and leave their bigoted transphobic selves behind, anything like this can, and will, be used as a tool to embarrass and harass transgender people.

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#83
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been called by my name many times by store clerks after paying contactless, without having given my name, so I assume it does get surfaced to them on the billing UI. It's also fairly common (in my experience, here in southern California) for the name on the card to be automatically used as the name on your order for, e.g., calling out when it's ready to be picked up at the counter.

Interesting, is this some US thing? Because in Europe for VISA/Mastercard payments I'm quite sure the name of the card owner is never transmitted to the vendor. Not in the past, and not now. It would also be quite in conflict with data protection laws. Also it's a risk for stolen credit card information. I think the vendor doesn't even get the credit card number when processing a payment, otherwise shop clerks could…

>Interesting, is this some US thing? Because in Europe for VISA/Mastercard payments I'm quite sure the name of the card owner is never transmitted to the vendor

I was surprised too but apparently it's a field that exists on the magstripe itself. Presumably something similar exists on EMV (for chip/contactless) as well.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_card#Track_1

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Step 1. Go to google news or whatever news aggregation website you want. Step 2. Search for "transgender attack". Step 3. Take some time to digest the horrible news you're reading. Step 4. Try to figure out the common thread between these stories. The people in question usually get outed in public during some kind of ID check, and got jumped by some intolerant moron who witnessed it. This is happening. Today. Includi…

[flagged]

[flagged]

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#85

It seems like people in this thread are unaware of the very real threats, harassment, and assaults that happen as a trans person in public. Using a name that matches your gender identity is important for both psychological safety, as well as avoiding being outed and threatened by others in public. Laws in different states can make changing your legal name incredibly complicated and time consuming. Having an easy proc…

Seems like many are just feigning lack of awareness, imo. Casual observation shows a pattern of looking the other way when bad things are happening to people they don’t like.

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. Some of us like to imagine trans* people as those drag like personas, a clownish caricatures of their genders. This isn't the case though: most are just, you know, people. You wouldn't know they are trans*, except for their name. And unlike that Johnny Cash song, being a boy named Sue doesn't build character. It just makes your life miserable.

[flagged]

Imagine there’s a chance that you might be wrong.

How would you possibly know the false negatives (the ones you “missed”)?

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True, but does having another name on the credit card actually address this genuine problem? (I think people should be able to use their chosen name on their credit card; I think that adds comfort to their regular interactions and daily life; I just don’t think it will act as an Uno Reverse card against someone prone to bigotry against them.)

Yes. Some of us like to imagine trans* people as those drag like personas, a clownish caricatures of their genders. This isn't the case though: most are just, you know, people. You wouldn't know they are trans*, except for their name. And unlike that Johnny Cash song, being a boy named Sue doesn't build character. It just makes your life miserable.

[deleted]

Re: True Name – Mastercard (2022)

#90

> New research by Mastercard across 16 countries in North America and Europe revealed that 59% of people who identity as nonbinary say they feel unsafe while shopping We should do what we can to make life easier for everyone, but we should stop encouraging and accommodating this “everything makes me feel unsafe” attitude. It harms everyone when we redefine safety to include awkwardness or very minor psychological dis…

Why do you assume their use of the word "unsafe" was limited to awkwardness?

There is a growing group of people willing to confront anyone in public that is transgender, with a smaller (yet still growing) group who are emboldened enough to inflict physical harm.

Post reply on HN