Live data from Hacker News

How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

newyorker.com

41–50 of 181 posts

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#41
post #22

Is it really that popular? I've never met a single polyamorous person in my entire life, they just seem very vocal on the internet.

Statistically, you've met many. So either they just didn't feel the need to bring it up, or they felt a specific need to avoid the subject in front of you.

Based on what statistics?

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#42

It isn't. I don't know of a single couple in my personal life or extended group of friends that went poly and remained a couple past 5 years. They all eventually split up. Why get married if you're going to be polyamorous. Seems like a bit of a hassle to tie yourself up legally and financially when you've otherwise thrown all other parts of the relationship to the wind.

Your anecdote is in the basis correct. Very few relationships which start closed and go to open/poly survive as you do not have the required communication skills or emotional intelligence to make it work. This is usually developed over several failed relationships, similar to monogamy. I suspect relationships that start out polyamarous have a similar failure rate to nonmonogamy. Also, it is advisable to find local poly meetups to get social support and hear about what works. I've been polyamorous for around a decade and I don't date anyone that is just learning the ropes. It is too much of a risk to my existing relationships. Some of the skill sets required are covered in the book Polysecure. Trying to become poly to save your relationship is almost certainly going to fail. Do some marriage counseling first and then consider it if you have an emotionally secure base, but be aware it still likely will blow up.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#43
post #22

Is it really that popular? I've never met a single polyamorous person in my entire life, they just seem very vocal on the internet.

Statistically, you've met many. So either they just didn't feel the need to bring it up, or they felt a specific need to avoid the subject in front of you.

What statistic? A national one? Because the variation from place to place would be drastic, like comparing rural to urban, and the various politics and cultures that have more hold over different cities. I wouldn't say that a national statistic could say much about one single place or person's experience.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#44

Is it really that popular? I've never met a single polyamorous person in my entire life, they just seem very vocal on the internet.

It’s popular compared to 20-30 years ago. I have a number of friends who are poly, one of my siblings was for a few years before meeting a partner who wasn’t.

But folks may not mention it to you until you’re at a certain level of friendship. I remember a couple I knew who disclosed after a few months.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#45

I wonder how middle-aged couples deal with the sexual desires. Numerous reports, let alone anecdotes and shows, mentioned that couples with each other for many years lost sexual desire towards each other, while their libido still flowed free. To quote one of such publications: "Sexual arousal and desire appear to decrease in response to partner familiarity and increase in response to partner novelty". I guess it's a…

I've always found this really sad to think about. I'm attracted to my partner and I'd like to stay this way indefinitely, but I'm also aware my own biology isn't on my side. I really hope we figure out ways (medicine? mind tricks? fork in the brain?) to keep the candle burning in the long term.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#46

Because the author got the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon.

The data suggests it truly is more popular. The Gallup poll below shows that the percent of people who find it "acceptable" has tripled since 2000. The generational data, which admittedly would be more useful if it was over time, still shows younger generations are more into it. https://news.gallup.com/opinion/polling-matters/313112/under... https://sexualalpha.com/polyamory-statistics/ What data or info do you have…

Because this isn't new fangled, it goes back to the dawn of civilization and in many instances it's standard practice.

I oppose the "become" part because no, it wasn't HBO that changed this needle, it's religion.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygyny

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#47
post #35
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nah, we'll just use the existing spouse_id field in the records to set up a circular linked list through the polycule. A conventional two-person marriage is just a special case of that anyway.

Linked lists can only have two neighbours, a polycule can be arbitrarily complex. (Depending on the purpose for which the data is being used, it may even be directional — e.g. for STD tracking, it does actually matter if someone has a cuckoldry kink).

What I'm hearing is I'll finally have a reason to learn graph databases if polyamory becomes mainstream.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#48
post #7

If I felt secure in a relationship, having a partner that wants to experiment with others/date others wouldn’t really bother me. Everyone likes a little novelty from time to time.

If you felt secure in the relationship you probably wouldn't feel the need. The desire for novelty comes from bored or unfulfilled from your current relationship, which would contest the "security" of the relationship if it is impossible to live without it.

I have access to far more food than I can physically (let alone healthily) eat.

That I am clearly fulfilled with my existing diet doesn't stop me from trying new things on the menu, nor new restaurants with entirely new menus.

And the desire to try new things doesn't imply that the absence of them is "impossible to live without" — even back out of metaphor land and back to human sexuality, lot of gay people used to live straight lives.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#49
post #7

If I felt secure in a relationship, having a partner that wants to experiment with others/date others wouldn’t really bother me. Everyone likes a little novelty from time to time.

You might find it difficult to stay secure when your partner says you’re no longer good enough.

Of course, some people don’t seem to mind this much. Or maybe this fancy new Bay Area “polyamory” memeplex works really well. I find it hard to imagine any amount of coping strategies could dull the pain for me.

Re: How Did Polyamory Become So Popular?

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think this anecdote nullifies the question. A thing being popular doesn't necessarily mean it is a successful approach.

The question is a lie at face value. Polyamory isn't popular at all. It's just not as much of a taboo as it used to be. There's a giant difference between "what would your opinion of someone be if they were in an open relationship" and "would YOU want an open relationship?" The first has nothing to do with you personally past your opinion of how you would relate to someone else.

Well, you've beaten me here. It would probably serve me better to read the article before posting.

But it's Christmas, and there is gin, so I hope I have your forgiveness.

Post reply on HN