Live data from Hacker News

Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

theregister.com

381–390 of 541 posts

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#381

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The only reason they have leverage is the law that gives Postnord a monopoly on delivering license plates Is that a law or an exclusive contract between the government and PostNord, given after bidding and a tender process as they call it in Europe and Asian countries? I think it's a contract, and contracts have exclusions in cases of forces majeures like strikes. Since the Transport Agency is required by law to pr…

> contracts have exclusions in cases of forces majeures like strikes Tesla can't call force majeure on a contract it isn't party to. If the Swedish government wanted to break the strike, it can--trivially. There is simply zero political will to do so.

Yes, Tesla can do exactly that. It's a standard clause in Nordic contracts. They're not liable if they have had even remotely competent council do their contracts.

My Visa card has a clause that the bank isn't liable if it stops working due to industrial action.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#382

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> contracts have exclusions in cases of forces majeures like strikes Tesla can't call force majeure on a contract it isn't party to. If the Swedish government wanted to break the strike, it can--trivially. There is simply zero political will to do so.

The Swedish Transport Agency is required by law to provide plates. If it cannot fulfil its duties because of a force majeur event then it would be expected to explore alternatives like allowing plates to be picked up at the factory, which is not forbidden by law. It might be forbidden by the contract with PostNord, but PostNord is undergoing a force majeure so it cannot object to it. > If the Swedish government wante…

The Swedish Transport Agency has already done their job. The plates are in transit.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#383
post #232

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In exchange the large employers force every employee to sign up for union membership. Sometimes the company itself signs the employee to the union, without any consent from the individual. This is not the case in Sweden. Maybe in the US?

I know for a matter of fact that it is the case in Sweden with some employers. They'll sign you up for the union without your consent and without informing you. Then the union in their turn will sign you up with insurance companies and other third parties without consent of information. Just a bill suddenly arriving in your mail that you have to pay.

Complete fabrication without any basis in reality.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#384

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are increasing the pressure on a company which is not treating their workers well and fairly. These workers are friends, wives, husbands, relatives… It’s more than justified.

You're missing the point. I'm not debating the validity of whether people should leave Tesla and go work somewhere else. I'm saying that it's not a strike if you're just refusing service to a customer. A strike - whether because of your circumstances or another's - is you downing tools and stopping working.

> I'm saying that it's not a strike if you're just refusing service to a customer.

> is you downing tools and stopping working.

These aren't exclusive, it's just they've downed tools and stopped working for the customer the strike is against. People don't join unions for their employer, they join unions for their industry. Therefore a union can strike against an employer while maintaining working for those not breaking collective agreements.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#385
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If union membership is really the way of life in Sweden, is there anything preventing the government from a legislative solution? Nordic countries actually have relatively weak labour laws. What might be handled in legislation in US (e.g. minimum wage), is handled in collective bargaining agreements, that are negotiated between trade unions and employers' associations. And the trade unions and the employers' associ…

It's a very sweet deal for the unions and for large employers. The unions make sure to collectively "bargain" each year for extremely low pay raises and even for nominal pay cuts for their members. In exchange the large employers force every employee to sign up for union membership. Sometimes the company itself signs the employee to the union, without any consent from the individual. In exchange the unions get to col…

This was a thing in Denmark probably 20 years ago, now it's no longer legal to demand union membership for employees. But there was one incident 4 years ago where union members at Kastrup Airport tried to bully a coworker to join them. They even went on strikes three times because of this, with zero effect. Can't tell if the bullying is widespread though.

https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/3fer-bag-trusler-og-boelleme...

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#386
post #383

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know for a matter of fact that it is the case in Sweden with some employers. They'll sign you up for the union without your consent and without informing you. Then the union in their turn will sign you up with insurance companies and other third parties without consent of information. Just a bill suddenly arriving in your mail that you have to pay.

Complete fabrication without any basis in reality.

Just read the other comments of this account.

Just making up anti-union statements all over the place.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#387

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's just one company that doesn't play ball so a full strike wouldn't be appropriate reaction, especially as employers' organization apparently isn't a participant here. Say, striking dockworkers can paralyze the whole economy, all sectors. It's not a step to be taken lightly.

It's not just one company "not playing ball". Spotify, with ten times as many affected employees in Sweden, also doesn't have an agreement. > It's not a step to be taken lightly. Well, there's no balancing downside to doing it this way. Workers still get paid. So they can do this pretty lightly, assuming their employers allow them to just discriminate against certain customers.

The unions don't go after companies that provide better than CBA to all employees. I don't know if that's the case with Spotify though.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would classify striking and not delivering to a specific entity as different things. The latter is more easily able to be used for extortion. Similar to cops deciding not to police a region populated by a certain tribe. Or, in the same vein, over policing a certain region/tribe.

> Similar to cops deciding not to police a region populated by a certain tribe. Or, in the same vein, over policing a certain region/tribe. You should have gone with firefighters. Cops famously never act in solidarity with other workers. In fact, they actively work against workers' rights. Cops "over policing", or more accurately, "targeting", most certainly violates certain fundamental rights. A mailman not deliveri…

Sure, use firefighters not putting out certain fires.

I would classify use of infrastructure as a right. Like if a toll booth operator refused to take money from certain people.

Also, in this case, it sounds like the workers are also not allowing anyone else to deliver the packages, so it is not just "a mailman not delivering packages to some company offices".

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#389

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't know why this was downvoted.. This is not Postnord's decision, it's the workers, and the same workers at UPS or any other postal delivery service could do the same.

In theory that would not absolve the government from providing core services. For example, teachers can go on strike but children are guaranteed a primary education. It'd be the government's responsibility, not the individual citizen or business, to ensure core services enshrined in law are properly staffed.

Yea.. And a car is a privilege, so not even remotely comparable.

Re: Swedish Tesla strike goes international as Norwegian and Danish unions join in

#390

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would classify striking and not delivering to a specific entity as different things. The latter is more easily able to be used for extortion. Similar to cops deciding not to police a region populated by a certain tribe. Or, in the same vein, over policing a certain region/tribe.

Well, your classification truly does not matter in the slightest. This is legal in the Nordics. You know how you make it illegal? By signing the CBA, which if you're already providing better terms, doesn't change anything.

Almost all of the comments on this forum, or any online forum do not matter in the slightest. But perhaps we can use forums to discuss ideas.
Post reply on HN