Live data from Hacker News

Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

reuters.com

81–90 of 91 posts

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#81
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure. You are paying for the cheapest option and sacrifice in range. 99% of car usage for me would be short trips <30km.

But if you use your car so little why would you spend 20k on one of the worst car experience of modern history ? You have no perf, no comfort, no status

Because I really don't care about perf or status. If the comfort is good enough I'm fine with that. That's why I said none of the points you made are stuff I would care about.

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#82
post #78
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a (sub)urban vehicle, those sound perfectly in line with its role. Do you judge vans and other utility vehicles on their 0-100 kph too?

The 1.0l 3cyl shitbox my dad bought for 12k euros new a few years back accelerates 50% faster and tops out at 170kmh so yes sorry but this is just unacceptable at that price, it's borderline unsafe 20k is a lot of money to put in a car for most people in Europe, you can buy a decent used ice car and enough gas for the next 50 years if you exclusively use your car in an urban environment

You can't go to 125km/h in an urban environment anyways, so what difference does it make?

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not expensive. Even budget, non-electric, cars such as ford fiesta cost about 18K nowadays.

If you look at it that way, yes, it’s not expensive. I would say that the Fiesta is 10k too expensive.

I'm not saying that 18K is cheap for a fiesta. Just that a Tesla costing 40% more than one of the cheapest car available makes it quite a good deal.

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#84
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not talking about 10k bikes, but also not supermarket bikes. I said complexity and materials. An iPhone is extremely complex but it's only so cheap because electronics scale extremely well, probably only software does better. Logically there should be more bikes than cars so the economy of scale should be in their favor. Bike maintenance isn't cheap either. Cars need to go through much more certification etc. The…

You can buy a basic city bike for https://www.decathlon.fr/p/mp/moma-bikes/velo-trekking-hybri... > Logically there should be more bikes than cars There are twice as many cars than bikes in France from what I can find online, not sure about the rest of the world.

> You can buy a basic city bike for Fair point but what I meant in my initial post is even a top of the line Trek Slash doesn't have a quarter of the technology included in the lowest end Fiat Panda. Even the best e-bikes are still quite simple compared to a car.

And I say that as a bike nerd.

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#85
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not talking about 10k bikes, but also not supermarket bikes. I said complexity and materials. An iPhone is extremely complex but it's only so cheap because electronics scale extremely well, probably only software does better. Logically there should be more bikes than cars so the economy of scale should be in their favor. Bike maintenance isn't cheap either. Cars need to go through much more certification etc. The…

You can buy a basic city bike for https://www.decathlon.fr/p/mp/moma-bikes/velo-trekking-hybri... > Logically there should be more bikes than cars There are twice as many cars than bikes in France from what I can find online, not sure about the rest of the world.

>You can buy a basic city bike for A supermarket bike, not suitable if you're a bit serious and many repair shops will refuse to repair them because it's not worth it. For a decent bike you'd probably paying at least 3-4x more.

>There are twice as many cars than bikes in France from what I can find online, not sure about the rest of the world.

Google tells me worldwide daily production of bikes is 300.000 and cars 100.000. (IMO It would really be sad if it was otherwise)

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#86
post #82
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The 1.0l 3cyl shitbox my dad bought for 12k euros new a few years back accelerates 50% faster and tops out at 170kmh so yes sorry but this is just unacceptable at that price, it's borderline unsafe 20k is a lot of money to put in a car for most people in Europe, you can buy a decent used ice car and enough gas for the next 50 years if you exclusively use your car in an urban environment

You can't go to 125km/h in an urban environment anyways, so what difference does it make?

But you usually aren't even driving in an urban environments. We have public transport for that. Three car really doesn't fit the market much

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#87
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was marketed as a $35,000 car, and never sold as such. First editions were all more expensive (long range or dual motor, I forget which)

They did. Then they stopped. https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/16/21569524/tesla-model-3-3... The model 3 is still the 7th most sold car in 2022. Is a car company not allowed to raise prices? Like what standard are you holding tesla to? If they can sell a tesla for $42k, why sell it for $35k? Because Elon said so in 2015? That's ridiculous, its just not how markets or companies work. And they DID sell it for $35,000,…

They sold it for a few days at that price a few years after the car launched. I tried to buy one for that price. They said no.

Of course they can raise prices, but they can also lie about what price the car will be sold at in the future.

I later bought one for more than 35k.

There are no mental gymnastics. Musk said I could buy one at a specific price. Tesla would not sell it to me at that price.

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#88
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can't go to 125km/h in an urban environment anyways, so what difference does it make?

But you usually aren't even driving in an urban environments. We have public transport for that. Three car really doesn't fit the market much

It fits the niche of people having to commute by car but not on the highway. Considering it's among the best selling models of EVs in France, obviously that niche exists.

https://www.autojournal.fr/economie/voitures-electriques-neu...

Re: Tesla to build 25,000-euro car at German plant

#89
post #45
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a 17-y.o. blog post. Musk has very much changed since then. And where does the Cybertruck fall into that master plan?

I'm sure he has, but are you saying that back then, he did not say he would stop making more affordable cars and more recently has has said he will stop?

He did made Twitter less affordable.
Post reply on HN