This is where I get conflicted with ad blockers, on the one hand most website ads are trash, on the other hand there is great content on YT and I want those creators to make enough to carry on to get to the level where they proper sponsors. But, YT is so egregious with its ad insertions at times that it drives me mad and I don’t trust the creators will get fairly compensated if I go to premium.
Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
21–30 of 168 posts
Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#22Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#23They're not actually ad blockers. They are javascript exploit protection. It just so happens a good fraction if not the majority of exploits come in through ad systems in general. It's a rare thing a website itself is going to attack you. It's always some code/media imported from a third party domain/ip. ie, ads.
Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#24Earlier quoted context omitted.
The creators get more money per view from a premium member than an ad-supported viewer. So not only does being a paying member give you a better experience, it puts more cash in the pocket of those you watch.
Not arguing for the sake of it but is that confirmed? I assume the more I watch the less each creator gets? No idea what the algorithm is they use to share the money out
Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#25Until YouTube starts injecting ads into the video stream (like Twitch), it's not going to be effective at all. There's no way to do a client-side anti-adblock and not have it bypassed. And TBH: since YouTube is not doing that, I think they might've decided the cost of that solution outweighs the projected revenue so they've chosen a cheaper solution. In Twitch's case, more of the audience might be techy, so ad inject…
It's much easier for anything non-live.
Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#26Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#27Is this with uBlock Origin or ABP?
Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#28As soon as I get that, I'll be having yt-dlp very handy.
While that works for now, if Google ever took interest in it I think it would be pretty straightforward to break any libraries like that. If you change either the endpoints or the model or etc with any reasonable frequency the library authors couldn't possibly keep up. Google can orchestrate their rollouts so their things always keep working while the library users are always in for a surprise. This is one of those t…
Re: Tell HN: "Ad blockers are not allowed on YouTube”
#29Youtube premium doesn't stop the adverts, you need sponsorblock for that.