Live data from Hacker News

Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

pressprogress.ca

181–190 of 282 posts

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Every single time anyone posts anything that puts one nation in a bad light, someone comes in with this. Can we please not do this? Your nation will have its chance in the sun too. Hijacking threads like this to say, "well, what about your nation?" is childish to say the absolute least.

Well diplomacy is built on quid pro quos and whataboutism so I don’t know what’s childish in this, if anything this comment comes off as pretty naive and childish.

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#182
post #48

To those saying "But Bill C-18" - it's not the Canadian government taking things down. It's the Indian government, taking down articles and posts that accuse them of assassinating a Canadian citizen on Canadian soil. C-18 is a problem. We need to deal with it. That's not relevant to the issue at hand. And to those saying "Well he was a terrorist..." we, in Canada, have something called the Rule of Law. You have to pr…

[flagged]

Afghanistan being known the world over for its strong culture of the Rule of Law, impartial justice system, and willingness to extradite terrorists.

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#183
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Canada's single most deadly terrorist attack was the bombing of Air India Flight 182 by Sikh Khalistani separatists. 329 people were killed, including 268 Canadians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_India_Flight_182

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_attacks United State's single most deadly terrorist attack was the bombing of the World Trade Centers by Islamic separatists. 2996 people were killed Is your point all Muslims are terrorists?

No, but it would be similarly ridiculous if someone described Muslims as "some of the most peace loving people on planet earth" like the post above.

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#184

India’s government is apparently confidently enough in India’s global influence to be putting pressure on Canada and Facebook. Just thinking out loud, if some parts of India started breaking away from India, that could start a chain reaction. India has incredibly diverse sets of citizens, each with their own set of cultural identities and historical grievances. Maintaining national unity has been a struggle since Ind…

> suppression of separatists If true, this was a stupid move. They’ve martyred a separatist while bringing him and his cause international sympathy and attention. The assassins have carried out an action resembling an attack on a founding member of NATO and close ally of America’s. In North America. This is a line even the Soviets and Chinese respected. Not out of fear, but rational self interest. If true, New Delhi’…

> This is a line even the Soviets

The Soviets regularly murdered dissidents from the Soviet Union in western countries. That's like half the reason the KGB existed. You can read about it in The Sword and the Shield by Christopher Andrew and Vasili Mitrokhin, a book directly referencing KGB archives.

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#186
Ukrainians posting about war crimes and uploading photos of war - "oh, we don't want to see such sensitive content, it is unsettling, better block it, delete it and ban users with hundreds of thousands subs, just not to see it".

A. Few. Moments. Later... "why is Facebook blocking my posts?!"

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's exactly it, isn't it? Claiming you have rule of law while being unable to secure prosecutions makes it a farce.

The rule of law made it so you cannot run kangaroo courts when you just personally believe someone is guilty. If the process is failing to prosecute the guilty, the process should be updated with... more laws, which themselves are passed through representative democratic governance. If one outcome is unsatisfactory to you, you can vote for someone who will tear down the system, you can become a prosecutor, you can ru…

> representative democratic governance

It's questionable if that exists in Canada given the system that's currently in place.

Look at the results of the most recent federal election, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Canadian_federal_election

A party that received 32.62% of the popular vote got 160 seats in the House of Commons, while another party that received 33.74% of the vote got only 119 seats.

A party that received only 7.64% of the votes got 32 seats, while another party that received 17.82% of the vote got only 25 seats.

A party that received 2.33% of the votes got 2 seats, while another party that received 4.94% of the vote got no seats.

With a votes-to-seats situation like that, there are a lot of Canadians who don't have proper representation in the House of Commons, or in some cases, effectively none at all.

It's no surprise that the voter turnout wasn't even 63%; many Canadians are completely disillusioned with how the current system works, and don't feel that any of the parties can offer them meaningful representation.

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Ayman al-Zawahiri was killed by a US drone strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Ayman_al-Zawahiri

I don't think that the U.S. killing an Egyptian in Afghanistan makes it more OK for India to kill a Canadian in Canada (if that's in fact what they did).

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#189
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Facebook is in the advertising industry. One pair of eyeballs is not worth the same as every other pair, they're worth what they can spend. Canadians are, in global terms, fabulously wealthy.

There are probably 50 million people in India who are each worth more than the average Canadian. And another billion or so to boot.

I doubt it. You need to earn only around $300 a month or 25,000 Rupees to get into the top 10% of income earners in India.

https://www.ndtv.com/business/earning-rs-25-000-you-are-in-i...

https://competitiveness.in/the-state-of-inequality-in-india-....

Re: Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader

#190

Trudeau obviously grasping at the chance of winning over some Sikh votes. Whether the allegations are credible or not is irrelevant to him, and likely will not be found out until after elections anyway. On the other hand, Facebook is much more likely to err on the side of India given the much larger population and associated $ potential and THE BILL. Canada is not exactly an espionage expert relative to places like I…

The Canadian government worked with US intelligence on this matter:

https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/canada-worked-closely...

Post reply on HN