Live data from Hacker News

VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

vcmi.eu

11–20 of 90 posts

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#11
I still spend inordinate amounts of time playing Heroes 3. It’s been a strong procrastination feeder over the decades, but it also gave me a lot of fun!

I mostly play HotA in HD Mod these days, but I had used VCMI on Android (with SoD). It’s been a bit rough – the client-server thing that it does would have connection issues, the mechanics differed in subtle ways, etc. But I’m also super grateful that it exists.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#12
post #5

Pro players use HoMM3 HD Mod + HotA addon, which are closed source improvements of the original binaries with solid support for multiplayer action. It has lobby with ladder ratings, simultaneous turns, etc.

Ditto. Just don't confuse it with official Heroes® of Might & Magic® III - HD Edition which is a blatant hackjob/cashgrab from Ubisoft with blurry textures.

I think you are a little bit biased here. Heroes® of Might & Magic® III - HD Edition from ubisoft has one major issue, it's lacking expansions. But the graphics itself is imo better than in hd mod. https://www.gamersgate.com/media/products/product/14687141/s... https://i.imgur.com/i1DNqNp.png The second one is a pic from hd mod. The first one is hd edition.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#13
Off topic, I wanted to compare it to the original, wanted to run that in Boxer.app[1] and realized that this software is now unmaintained.

That’s unfortunate, it was a nice product with good UX. Also, unapologetically skeuomorphic, like many apps of that era.

[1]: http://boxerapp.com/

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ditto. Just don't confuse it with official Heroes® of Might & Magic® III - HD Edition which is a blatant hackjob/cashgrab from Ubisoft with blurry textures.

I think you are a little bit biased here. Heroes® of Might & Magic® III - HD Edition from ubisoft has one major issue, it's lacking expansions. But the graphics itself is imo better than in hd mod. https://www.gamersgate.com/media/products/product/14687141/s... https://i.imgur.com/i1DNqNp.png The second one is a pic from hd mod. The first one is hd edition.

The texture complaint is specifically around the character portraits if I recall correctly.

The lack of expansions is the real killer imo, so many “basic” things were actually added in expansions.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#15
post #10

Back in the day, since I used Linux exclusively, a demo of Might and Magic III (ported by Loki software) was one of the very few games I had. I resorted to figuring out the save file format in order to play as the other towns on the demo map.

Loki software did some serious good. Any idea what they've become ?

Well, I know that one of them, Sam Lantinga, went on to be a lead dev on World of Warcraft and is now with Valve. His SDL library was originally developed for Loki, I think.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#16
My personal ranking puts HD Mod above VCMI (currently) but VCMI has some features that HD Mod will likely never enable - because they’re fundamentally game changing.

https://sites.google.com/site/heroes3hd/

HD Mod also works with Horn of the Abyss https://heroes3wog.net/horn-of-the-abyss-download/ which is an (pretty successful) attempt to build an unofficial expansion to H3 that has the feel of H3. Anyone who played Wake of the Gods will know it felt quite “unH3” at points.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#17

It must feel great to devote yourself to a passion project and it turns out to actually work and people use it. I assume this is a passion project because I can't imagine getting funds for a project like this, specially when it might conflict with upstream licenses. In any case congratulations to the developers.

There’s a few games out there that have absolutely immense fandoms in places unexpected - Heroes III is absolutely HUGE in countries east of the old iron curtain, partially probably because it runs well on older computers but also because it’s one of the best games ever made.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#18
post #6

Heroes II was my personal favorite

There's fheroes2 for that, an open-source port which mirrors most of the features of HoMM3's HD Mod.

It also brings “backwards” some of the QoL features of H3 which helps me, because starting on H3 means H2/1 always feel too Down Grady.

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#19
post #13

Off topic, I wanted to compare it to the original, wanted to run that in Boxer.app[1] and realized that this software is now unmaintained. That’s unfortunate, it was a nice product with good UX. Also, unapologetically skeuomorphic, like many apps of that era. [1]: http://boxerapp.com/

Dos won't cut it for H3; it's wine territory

and wine is a pain to use on mac, as Apple killed it with the move to Catalina

Re: VCMI: Open-Source Engine for Heroes of Might and Magic III

#20
post #13

Off topic, I wanted to compare it to the original, wanted to run that in Boxer.app[1] and realized that this software is now unmaintained. That’s unfortunate, it was a nice product with good UX. Also, unapologetically skeuomorphic, like many apps of that era. [1]: http://boxerapp.com/

[deleted]
Post reply on HN