Live data from Hacker News

iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

techradar.com

321–330 of 1001 posts

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#321
post #236
post #143

I think the central question here is: .) whether you buy a phone as a piece of hardware and then own that hardware - which gives you certain rights regarding the usage of that owned hardware or .) whether you are just paying some sort of admission fee to a tightly controlled service, and are basically "lent" a piece of hardware that you have no ownership rights over. All the other stuff about walled gardens, monopoli…

Related question: what does the user want? I doubt a majority of users are against side loading.

I don’t think users really want to have to use 5 different app stores. I’ll probably opt to not buy an app if I first have to download another App Store app.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#322
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can do that already.

If you own a mac, run a specific software at least once a week, and limited to like 3 apps. For all practical purposes, this means “you can’t”.

Not only do you have to own a mac, you have to keep everything updated to the latest version. This is problematic, considering that the OS gets worse and worse with every release, and some things break with new versions.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#323

I think Apple has also done good things with their strict app store policies (from my consumer point of view). Apple has been for example putting limits on data collection and tracking. The main mechanism is to kick apps out from Apps store if they don't play by the rules. I'm worried that side loading will be a step back here. Strong players, like Facebook, may just take their app away from the official store and di…

> I don't have much choice - it's not like there would be five competing apps serving the same purpose (connecting to the people and communities on Facebook).

The same legislation that is requiring Apple to allow sideloading also requires other large players (like Meta) to open their communication platforms up to other service or application developers.

In this hypothetical case, there actually would be five competing apps, some even still distributed on the App Store.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can't the banks implement some measures so that only their own apps can do transactions?

Believe me they’re trying. They’re now mandating biometric authentication, and I don’t mean on device, I mean implemented by the banks app / backend. If you read the articles you’ll see. Each year the central banks up the ante on security protocols to implement to stop the fraud. I should know I used to work for a finance app here in Thailand. We have to go through strict security audits, and procedures that costs a…

I hate that baks require the phone app, where transactions don’t also require a computer: It enables racket where my aggressor can list my bank accounts; It also reduces the 2FA to 1FA (phone-only transactions with password + fingerprint + SMS only on the phone).

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#325

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Most of the cases are found to be on android devices. Do you have some relevant sources about banking fraud? Android devices make up more than 70% of Thailand's market share [0], so it's not a surprise. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/814490/market-share-mobi...

The Thai government's Ministry of Digital Economy & Society has made multiple public requests for iOS users[1], mentioning that they need to avoid specific iOS apps[1][2], as well. That means scam apps were being distributed via the App Store. Also, the government mentions that the scams affect users of both platforms, because the scams propagate via calls, web links and emails that ask for personal information[2]. […

Right, but for Apple to take down those apps, it's much easier than taking down some random link the fraudsters put up.

I'm not saying iOS is 100% bullet proof. I'm saying the problem is much more manageable without sideloading.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#326
post #253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No. Preventing people from doing something "for their own good" is never the right solution. Instead, we should strive to educate people on proper online safety measures so that they don't fall victim to fraudulent attempts.

> preventing people from doing something "for their own good" is never the right solution. https://www.osha.gov/etools/machine-guarding/presses/two-han... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockout%E2%80%93tagout > educate people on proper online safety measures so that they don't fall victim to fraudulent attempts. This is so inefficient and prone to failure. You think you're an expert, but my mom is not an expert. I don…

Your mum would be tech-savvy enough to enable "allow ipa from untrusted sources" buried deep in the settings? That's how it works on Android. I believe the main problem with android is, that there are tons of old devices not receiving any security updates.

It's close to impossible, that my mum figures out how to install an untrusted apk on her Samsung s22.

I guess what I want to say is: Having good security should not prevent you from installing custom software if you want to.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I absolutely disagree with your conclusion. It's like forbidding people from working on their own cars because some people are stupid and kill themselves through their work(and that kind of thing is neither rare nor unusual). And it's not like people with iOS are resistant to being scammed - there are hundreds of ways criminals can dupe you to sending them money, the invoice scam being the simplest example and it doe…

You should read this article[0]. It outlines clearly that victims are downloading .apk files [0] https://www.nationthailand.com/thailand/general/40024972 Also your comparison of people 'working on their own cars' is a bit off here. Most people buy cars to drive, and give the car to the mechanic to 'work on'. It's much much harder to repair your own car than to click a link that can scam you.

No one said anything about repairs - people are currently free to buy and fit their own wipers from 3rd parties because we have specific legislation that says manufacturers can't forbid 3rd parties from making spare parts. I don't see why the same shouldn't apply here.

>>You should read this article[0]. It outlines clearly that victims are downloading .apk files

I feel for the victims but I literally don't see how that's an argument against sideloading.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think it's ever better to have a device that doesn't ever allow sideloading apps, over one that lets you, the owner, decide whether or not to allow sideloading apps?

Not GP, and fully agree that having the option for side-loading would be a largely positive thing for users and the software community. But one counterargument goes like this: When you relax the rules, larger players will be able to leverage them against individual users. For example, Meta would be able to release MetaStore, the app with exclusive distribution rights to Meta apps. Now you need a facebook account to i…

Meta can currently gate WhatsApp behind logging in with a Facebook account, but they don't; it will alienate users who use it because it doesn't require a Facebook account

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#329
post #208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is naive. Apple doesn't protect you. The prime example is that apple gives apps unfettered access to network connections. And YOU are unable to block this in any meaningful way. What apple doesn't give you is the ability to manage your own phone. You cannot really manage what apps are doing yourself. You cannot even find out what apps are doing. And you definitely will not be able to manage apple apps, they get…

> The prime example is that apple gives apps unfettered access to network connections. (…) You cannot even find out what apps are doing. Settings -> Privacy & Security -> App Privacy Report It shows you per application what data they are accessing, which sensors they are accessing and which domains the app is contacting. It also reports when they were doing this and how often. You can even export this data as a JSON…

App Privacy Report lets you know if an app might have leaked your data, firewall can help you make sure it does not happen. Two different purposes.

Re: iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe

#330

[flagged]

sideloading != clicking a dodgy link

clicking a dodgy link can download an android installer file (.apk), but installing .apks from unknown sources has to be explicitly enabled in android security settings (twice in latest versions) following warnings about trusting the link source and possible damage

it's not as simple as downloading a dodgy .exe in Windows and clicking 'yes' on the UAC prompt

whereas sideloading is intended for developers when testing and debugging apps. this involves enabling Developer Mode in android security settings, connecting to your phone via USB, and issuing sideload commands from a console

Post reply on HN