Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 165 posts

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#61
post #31

Good? What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free". Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

Absolutely NOT! It's waaay better to have huge multinational corporation dictate what's right and what's wrong and what's good and what's bad! And they do it for you my friend! For FREE!

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#62
I'm pretty sure the reason I got the infamous 'shadow ban' on Youtube for my Google account (i.e. I can see my comments but nobody else can, and my upvotes/downvotes behave similarly) was that I made a lot of snarky comments about how many ads different kinds of content had per minute of viewing time. I'd also note in the comments when Youtube gave the 'log in to see this age-sensitive content' warning (which didn't show up when logged in).

They don't want anyone questioning their ad revenue model I guess, nor their algorithmic ranking system...

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#63
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The alternative I'd like is making common user expectations into formalized properties of the software, making them visible and searchable. Like how it lists "Offers in-app purchases" currently, it could also list "Ad-free", "Free", etc.

F-Droid does this already with its listing of 'anti-features' for each app.

Yes, what I've sometimes done is search F-Droid first, then find that same app on the iOS app store.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#64
post #61
post #31

Good? What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free". Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

Absolutely NOT! It's waaay better to have huge multinational corporation dictate what's right and what's wrong and what's good and what's bad! And they do it for you my friend! For FREE!

Well its their platform

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#65
post #31

Good? What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free". Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

> What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free".

That's what we have on Amazon now. Looks like every single product contain all the metadata in product title. SEO spam from top to the bottom of the search results page.

I hate it, but given how crappy filtering on both Amazon and Play store is, I still prefer to see more information about a product in the search result list than less, even if that means bloated titles.

On the other hand, if both Amazon and Play store had usable filtering, all these bloated names would not be needed.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#66
A bit of a tangent but I wish more than anything that App Store/Play Store allowed for more advanced search. Some of what I want I know will never come but I'd love to be able to filter out any games that have any type of coin/gem/currency for sale through IAP. Normally I have to rely on reddit posts or random blogs that I find with search terms like "$gameType game with no P2P/P2W" or "$gameType game with no IAP" but even that's not perfect. I'm perfectly fine paying for a game and I'm fine with the game having IAP for extra things like "No Ads", level packs, or similar but I despise games that have any sort of P2P/P2W, they always optimize for the wrong thing (making money > fun/interesting/etc).

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#69
post #31

Good? What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free". Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

> Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title. ???? Did I miss the part where Google announced they were adding searchable metadata at the same time they eliminated adding this info to the title? If not, seems like a clearly anti-consumer move.

Listings show whether they have ads, in-app purchases etc. on a separate screen

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#70

I'm actually glad to see editorializing disallowed in app titles. If everybody did it, the store would be a mess. I mean, it's already a mess, but even more so.

The problem (with both app stores) is there are really three types of apps: paid, free, requires subscription. Devs are having to use titles to make it clear which is which since the stores aren't letting them use categories. It's frustrating (for both user and developer) when a user downloads an app expecting it to be free only to find it won't work if you don't pay monthly.
Post reply on HN