Live data from Hacker News

Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

economist.com

31–40 of 217 posts

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#31
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whether or not marriage as an institution is biased against males or females (honestly, it seems to be biased against both) I am always astounded by people who see no value whatsoever in marriage. America is practically founded on capitalism. How can you understand specialization & its benefits, and not see how marriage (well, used to) makes use of it? Yes, if marriage was just about pretending "True Love is real, an…

I don't think that marriage in USA is biased against anyone. But the divorce is HEAVILY biased agains men. For example, more than 70% of divorces are initiated by women, while they also get the custody of the children 90% of the time. When it comes for child support, it's even worse. If in a family the husband begins to get a lower salary due to the state of the economy, then everybody should/will spend less. But if…

Marriage itself can be quite biased against males in the states. I have a friend who's wife successfully divorced him because she was not being "sexually satisfied". If a male tried to do the same, people would scream "domestic rape". Expectations of each sex, viewed through the lense of the courts, are very uneven.

And of course after the divorce the situation only becomes more dire.

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#32
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now hold on there. Just because the employed member of the family puts in 60+ hours per week at the office doesn't mean they should do any less work around the house...

Whaaat? So are you basically saying that one shold do half of the house chores no matter how much he/she works at their job? If one spouse is unemployed, and the other spouse works 60 hrs you consider it fair only when each does 50% of the house work?

[deleted]

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#33

Good for them. More people need to reject this archaic sexist tradition. Legal enforcement of the fantasy notion of "true love for life" is damn near barbaric. If you and your partner can swing it, more power to you, but social pressure on others to place themselves into legally binding situations revolving around this notion is something that need to die. In the west (at least the states) these are legally binding a…

Whether or not marriage as an institution is biased against males or females (honestly, it seems to be biased against both) I am always astounded by people who see no value whatsoever in marriage. America is practically founded on capitalism. How can you understand specialization & its benefits, and not see how marriage (well, used to) makes use of it? Yes, if marriage was just about pretending "True Love is real, an…

I love children, but as a specie, we've secured our dominant position on this planet a long time ago. There's over 7 billion of us now. If children isn't your thing, why bring some into the world, and risk neglecting them?

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#34
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now hold on there. Just because the employed member of the family puts in 60+ hours per week at the office doesn't mean they should do any less work around the house...

Whaaat? So are you basically saying that one shold do half of the house chores no matter how much he/she works at their job? If one spouse is unemployed, and the other spouse works 60 hrs you consider it fair only when each does 50% of the house work?

Sorry, but sarcasm doesn't really work over the web.

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is an unrelated topic.

Let me clarify- you are saying that children are unrelated to marriage?

You know full well what I am saying. The concept of legally binding marriage and a "loving and positive environment" are fundamentally unrelated.

Little Johnny doesn't know or care if the government sanctions his parental figures' relationship. In fact, the only case in which Little Johnny might become aware of the governments involvement is when the resulting legal/social/economic pressure causes a dramatic deterioration of this "loving and positive environment".

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#36
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whether or not marriage as an institution is biased against males or females (honestly, it seems to be biased against both) I am always astounded by people who see no value whatsoever in marriage. America is practically founded on capitalism. How can you understand specialization & its benefits, and not see how marriage (well, used to) makes use of it? Yes, if marriage was just about pretending "True Love is real, an…

I don't think that marriage in USA is biased against anyone. But the divorce is HEAVILY biased agains men. For example, more than 70% of divorces are initiated by women, while they also get the custody of the children 90% of the time. When it comes for child support, it's even worse. If in a family the husband begins to get a lower salary due to the state of the economy, then everybody should/will spend less. But if…

please cite your sources

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#37
Yes, an aging population might be worrisome on the surface, but I find overpopulation more worrying. Therefore, I am happy that people in really populated countries are having less babies overall!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hM1x4RljmnE

Longer (but more boring) version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-QA2rkpBSY&feature=relat...

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#38
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whether or not marriage as an institution is biased against males or females (honestly, it seems to be biased against both) I am always astounded by people who see no value whatsoever in marriage. America is practically founded on capitalism. How can you understand specialization & its benefits, and not see how marriage (well, used to) makes use of it? Yes, if marriage was just about pretending "True Love is real, an…

"But as I have come to see it, it is more about facing the world as a "team". In larger groups (that is to say, extended family, all composed of marriage links), perhaps even as a "tribe"... think about that." I agree! Why do those links have to be marital? I'm not sure they have to be. Which is why the we need to be more open.

because, marital/blood link are more stronger than open/causal links.

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#39
Is it really the women who are avoiding marriage?

Do this experiment: go to a newspaper stand and look for magazines about weddings. Look for books about marriage. I have never ever seen one addressed to men (there are ones which seem to be, but on a quick glance I actually think they were written to feed the women's ego), which means IMHO that men wouldn't spend money on subjects like these. Meanwhile you sholdn't be surprised to find at least half a dozen for women. So I really really doubt that men are more willing to marry EITHER.

I would actually dare to say that men were (and still are) the ones who don't really care about marriage.

Re: Women are rejecting marriage in Asia. The social implications are serious.

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let me clarify- you are saying that children are unrelated to marriage?

You know full well what I am saying. The concept of legally binding marriage and a "loving and positive environment" are fundamentally unrelated. Little Johnny doesn't know or care if the government sanctions his parental figures' relationship. In fact , the only case in which Little Johnny might become aware of the governments involvement is when the resulting legal/social/economic pressure causes a dramatic deterio…

I suggest you extrapolate just a tad more next time. I may have a good guess at what you are saying, but that doesn't mean you don't need to say it.
Post reply on HN