Live data from Hacker News

Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

npr.org

241–250 of 722 posts

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#241

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you consider passing your diseases on to others to be among your various prerogatives?

Of course not. If I am sick I self-isolate.

Covid can be asymptomatic, and transmissible, that's the thing.

When you realize it's potentially already too late

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#242
post #233

I'm really upset with this decision. I have not gotten the vaccine as I prefer the known, extremely low risk of contacting COVID over the unknown longitudinal risk of the vaccine. My right to make these personal decisions regarding my bodily autonomy is extremely important to me. Under no circumstances will I yield that decision to my employer! Their demand only further reinforces my desire not to take the vaccine. W…

I hope you're also pro-abortion, but somehow I doubt it

I'm not sure how abortion relates to this.

But genetically-modified food could be. By living in the US I'm not sure how OP can avoid it, as it is not labeled. So there you go with a long term exposure with unknown effect.

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#243
post #236
post #179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a counter point to yours, just as valid, where folks don’t want to be around unvaccinated folks. Maybe they have an immunocompromised relative or child at home. Maybe they don’t feel safe with unvaccinated folks around. This is a game of odds. People keep acting like this is binary. You’re statistically more likely to have and spread covid without the vaccine. I would be delighted if my employer enforced thi…

Honestly, anyone who's genuinely at risk enough that they can't risk being exposed despite being vaccinated - as opposed to the people who were convinced they are because of stupid media culture war bullshit - probably shouldn't be working in an office, because at that point they're going to be at reasonably comparable risk from the common cold. Seriously. The other four endemic human coronaviruses, for example, are…

As I mentioned in my comment, many folks have families. We are not dealing with individuals when it comes to a pandemic. We are dealing with contagion amongst bubbles of people. Many people have vulnerable people in their bubbles at home and need to make a living.

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#244

I'm really upset with this decision. I have not gotten the vaccine as I prefer the known, extremely low risk of contacting COVID over the unknown longitudinal risk of the vaccine. My right to make these personal decisions regarding my bodily autonomy is extremely important to me. Under no circumstances will I yield that decision to my employer! Their demand only further reinforces my desire not to take the vaccine. W…

Are you factoring in risk to others? The aggregate risk of a poorly-vaccinated population is, presumably, still likely much higher than the "longitudinal risks" of vaccines? ie., it seems unlikely to me that vaccines will kill 100,000s (and, with covid continuing, 10s,000s+/yr). Even doing this based on individual preference alone, presumably you have preferences for the safety of (some) others; of your workplace; et…

Yes, of course I think about others. I would never go in with symptoms of any infectious disease. Were I asked to work in a building away from people that are high-risk or are regularly in contact with high-risk people I would easily oblige. There are multiple possible solutions that do not violate my bodily autonomy.

I agree with your assessment that major adverse effects are unlikely, but ultimately unknowns are impossible to quantify. I know the risk of COVID, I do not if I am being prescribed thalidomide.

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#245

I'm really upset with this decision. I have not gotten the vaccine as I prefer the known, extremely low risk of contacting COVID over the unknown longitudinal risk of the vaccine. My right to make these personal decisions regarding my bodily autonomy is extremely important to me. Under no circumstances will I yield that decision to my employer! Their demand only further reinforces my desire not to take the vaccine. W…

Man, I work in bioinformatics and study some aspects of the immunity. Like, on a low level, down to specific molecules. Am I qualified to make a decision whether I should get vaccinated? Hell no!

We’re talking about public health here, not just yours or mine. Something tells me we should have a bit of trust in people who studied epidemiology and vaccines all their lives. And the consensus in the scientific community is that herd immunity by vaccination is a way to go.

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#246

I'm really upset with this decision. I have not gotten the vaccine as I prefer the known, extremely low risk of contacting COVID over the unknown longitudinal risk of the vaccine. My right to make these personal decisions regarding my bodily autonomy is extremely important to me. Under no circumstances will I yield that decision to my employer! Their demand only further reinforces my desire not to take the vaccine. W…

We've had mandatory vaccinations for public schools for decades, and it's largely a settled issue. This is no different.

If people want to put others at risk of harm, employers are under no obligation to indulge them.

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#247

From the first point of the Nuremberg Code: 'The voluntary consent of the human subject is absolutely essential. This means that the person involved should have legal capacity to give consent; should be so situated as to be able to exercise free power of choice, without the intervention of any element of force, fraud, deceit, duress, overreaching, or other ulterior form of constraint or coercion; and should have suff…

Found Marjorie Taylor Greene!

Moved on from the Holocaust comparisons, at least.

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#248

I'm really upset with this decision. I have not gotten the vaccine as I prefer the known, extremely low risk of contacting COVID over the unknown longitudinal risk of the vaccine. My right to make these personal decisions regarding my bodily autonomy is extremely important to me. Under no circumstances will I yield that decision to my employer! Their demand only further reinforces my desire not to take the vaccine. W…

I understand and respect your comments about the relative risk for you personally. That's a personal judgement and your position on that does not seem unreasonable.

Vaccination also protects other people by reducing the spread in the population. By not being vaccinated, you will increase the chances of other people being infected.

How do you factor the risk to others into your decision?

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#249
post #233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hope you're also pro-abortion, but somehow I doubt it

I'm not sure how abortion relates to this. But genetically-modified food could be. By living in the US I'm not sure how OP can avoid it, as it is not labeled. So there you go with a long term exposure with unknown effect.

People having control over their own bodily functions is one of the main arguments of pro-abortion, right?

The counter argument being that when conception happens it's not just one person anymore, this has lots of levels of restriction over a person's body depending on when you consider this "conception" of a conscious being happens

Re: Google and Facebook mandate vaccines for employees at U.S. offices

#250

Today the entire state of New York had ZERO covid related deaths. Yet this week we saw NYC and State employees and now major private corporations mandate the vaccine. For the record I will never disclosure my health status so don’t assume one way or another.

Should they wait until after people start dying again to implement preventative measures or something?

This is exactly the kind of bizarrely short-sighted reasoning that results in pandemics exploding in the first place: "Things aren't bad yet, so why do we need to do anything??"

Post reply on HN