Live data from Hacker News

Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

wired.co.uk

111–120 of 195 posts

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#111

A lot of the reason for these design trends is that no one has the courage to think differently, so you get huge numbers of companies all looking virtually identical. It's a bit like 'nobody gets fired for buying IBM/McKinsey' etc...no one challenges product managers and marketing when yet another adobe illustrator generated Memphis style brand identity & UI is unveiled, complete with multi cultural inclusive visual…

...no one has the courage to think differently...

Almost no ordinary company wants to present themselves as wholly bizarre and strange. Many companies want to present themselves as basically normal but with a few interesting quirks and affections. Getting that balance right is hard, so you get the system that the article describes; it lets a variety of organizations appear slightly different in more or less the same way.

People manage "coolness" effectively for upward mobility integrate the unusual into something that's mostly mainstream - have a leather jacket or a quirky haircut or whatever. I'll spend time at industrial music festivals where no one expects to get but that's a decision and not the sort that anyone should expect a business to make.

(also, you'd do well to avoid the multiculturalism issue)

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#112

A lot of the reason for these design trends is that no one has the courage to think differently, so you get huge numbers of companies all looking virtually identical. It's a bit like 'nobody gets fired for buying IBM/McKinsey' etc...no one challenges product managers and marketing when yet another adobe illustrator generated Memphis style brand identity & UI is unveiled, complete with multi cultural inclusive visual…

>with multi cultural inclusive visual banality Lumping in cultural inclusivity with your critique is quite revealing. There's nothing in the article or about this style of illustration that hints at cultural values, why include it in the tirade?

Anti-racism is on trend this year.

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#113
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

reminds me of the now-infamous Pepsi "Breathtaking" design document https://www.goldennumber.net/wp-content/uploads/pepsi-arnell...

This document is insane. It feels like everyone involved in the production of it is so utterly disconnected from reality. That first page “Trajectory of innovation” with the pseudograph is an utterly hilarious distillation of the madness yet to come. The deeper I read into the document the worse it got. Golden ratio, Patterns being found where there were none to begin with (“perimeter oscillations”), Pepsi Energy fie…

[deleted]

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#114

Trends are trendy, film at 11.

So maybe one tenth of one percent of marketing people have an original idea in their heads. This is nothing new.

I think that's probably a bit harsh. Marketing is hard. Try coming up with a new idea for a car advertisement. What can you do that already hasn't been done?

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#115
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's so inoffensive that it has become offensive to me, with an "evil megacorp" association.

There used to be true artistry and celebration of beauty in corporate advertising. Look at the works of Toulouse-Lautrec or Alphonse Mucha. But no college kid is going to be putting up posters of these misshapen flat people in their college dorm.

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/fe/a1/24/fea1247eb6d9d47c6997...

I... guess "celebration of beauty" is a good description, but let's be honest: it's insulting and artistically lazy.

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#116
post #101

> multi cultural inclusive visual banality > It lets companies look diverse > Not sure what skin color to use? Make them blue Seeing cartoon SVGs of brown people really hits a nerve for some people. IMO if you walk around the Bay Area the racial distribution is more or less the same as these graphics, so there's really nothing to complain about in that regard. Go buy Russian software if you don't like it.

It’s a valid observation. Don’t you think it’s a bit cynical and calculated to include “diversity” on every single advertising graphic?

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#117

Find it weird how similar this is to 90s era software box art, things like Adobe Acrobat 5.0 [1] [1] https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/adobe/images/d/da/Adobe_Ac...

Working link: https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/adobe/images/d/da/Adobe_Ac...

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#118

A lot of the reason for these design trends is that no one has the courage to think differently, so you get huge numbers of companies all looking virtually identical. It's a bit like 'nobody gets fired for buying IBM/McKinsey' etc...no one challenges product managers and marketing when yet another adobe illustrator generated Memphis style brand identity & UI is unveiled, complete with multi cultural inclusive visual…

>with multi cultural inclusive visual banality Lumping in cultural inclusivity with your critique is quite revealing. There's nothing in the article or about this style of illustration that hints at cultural values, why include it in the tirade?

I see representation as a positive thing, but it's definitely part of the style.

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#119
post #97
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This document is insane. It feels like everyone involved in the production of it is so utterly disconnected from reality. That first page “Trajectory of innovation” with the pseudograph is an utterly hilarious distillation of the madness yet to come. The deeper I read into the document the worse it got. Golden ratio, Patterns being found where there were none to begin with (“perimeter oscillations”), Pepsi Energy fie…

> What learning can be taken from this? That being stupidly outrageous is a great marketing strategy considering we're still all discussing a branding document from 2009. The gravitational pull of Pepsi is real! :)

Holy shit, I think you're right.

Re: Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis

#120
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>with multi cultural inclusive visual banality Lumping in cultural inclusivity with your critique is quite revealing. There's nothing in the article or about this style of illustration that hints at cultural values, why include it in the tirade?

Anti-racism is on trend this year.

I think it'll stay for next year too, considering how many years anti-racism has been on trend.
Post reply on HN