Live data from Hacker News

Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

kevinslin.com

191–200 of 394 posts

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#191

It's not much better if you end up being a GCP customer. My company has gone through 4 reps in 3 years. Every time we get a new GCP rep they just want to talk to us about "expanding our use of GCP offerings". The only thing they want to talk about is starting to use BigQuery - not my business at all. I signed up for a Google Cloud Security summit, and afterwards a sales rep reached out me. It was obvious from the sta…

These guys must be commission based

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#192

From personal experience in multiple startups I can confirm that with regards to customer service and sales processes AWS is light years ahead of GCP. That said I have heard even better stories about Azure actually - apparently it is yet in another league of its own in terms of perks and actual service game.

[deleted]

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#193
We spend 100s of 1000’s of dollars a month on AWS. Our rep tried getting me to upgrade to paid support, and I said there was no way I was going to do that. I’m already paying AWS millions a year and will be giving them more and more business as Loom continues to skyrocket in usage. No way I’m paying for support at that scale. It’s a bogus model to charge your customers more when they’re continuing to accelerate in growth and pay you more money. I expect to get more support and attention over time automatically because I’m simply paying much more and my need for support hasn’t proportionally gone up in the least.

That was it. Other than that one conversation, my experience with AWS has been _absolutely stellar_ every step of the way. We’ve struck deals with them for several products and have felt like they were fair for both parties. Instead of continuing to focus on getting me to pay for support, they focused on areas where we’d want to rely on other AWS products and have come back with some amazing suggestions. I am extremely impressed with the teams I’ve worked with at AWS - it seems like they really understand the customer, and that incentivizes me to stay and use even more managed services when the unit economics work out for us.

For GCP I’ve had reps reach out. I tell them there’s no way we’ll go multi-cloud because it doesn’t make sense for our business goals and detracts from them. They respond as if they never even heard what I said. I get that you have to be persistent as a sales person, but the response wasn’t even talking about how _part_ of our infra would be worth hosting with them. There’s no conversation - it’s just what GCP wants me to do for them.

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#194

From personal experience in multiple startups I can confirm that with regards to customer service and sales processes AWS is light years ahead of GCP. That said I have heard even better stories about Azure actually - apparently it is yet in another league of its own in terms of perks and actual service game.

Most people on here dislike Azure because they don't buy into the Microsoft ecosystem, which is absolutely understandable, but if you do buy into the ecosystem, Azures really pretty great.

AAD ties everything together (this is a pro or a con depending on whether you use it), meaning you get secure SSO (including biometric security) for everything from device provisioning to machine identity (through service principals), and then Microsoft 365 E3 and E5 licenses offer every internal business tool you'll probably ever need in one place.

Azure basically only works if you go all in.

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#195
post #79

It's not much better if you end up being a GCP customer. My company has gone through 4 reps in 3 years. Every time we get a new GCP rep they just want to talk to us about "expanding our use of GCP offerings". The only thing they want to talk about is starting to use BigQuery - not my business at all. I signed up for a Google Cloud Security summit, and afterwards a sales rep reached out me. It was obvious from the sta…

I've had the same experience with GCP account reps. They always go missing and someone new emails us about how they are taking over 6 months later. Every call we have had with them has not resulted in anything meaningful. Our biggest issue is how their "highly available" Cloud SQL goes down every couple months for maintenance, not how we can use BigQuery.

Same here. I have sent my GCP rep 5-10 follow up emails by now and still no response. It really feels like I have no one to talk to over there and I'm spending thousands per month.

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When was the last time a landlord reduced your rent? You always can drive cost concessions from sales, especially for base workloads where you have time flexibility. For a big company, cloud rarely saves money for many categories of expense. In a normal market, it is almost always faster time to market to rent, and always cheaper TCO to own.

> When was the last time a landlord reduced your rent? This is a different market and one which is ultimately constrained by the availability of land. Notably, cloud prices do fall especially relative to the compute power. Specifically I remember when Fargate moved to firecracker and prices fell by like 40% or something similarly considerable. Maybe managing your own internal cloud is indeed cheaper (especially if yo…

Maybe cars or trucks are a better example. The ROI of buying, leasing or renting a vehicle varies and the optimal answer depends on the scenario!

It’s always better for you as a person to rent box truck to move. If you’re a company that needs a truck 3-5 times a month, there’s a probability that leasing may make more sense.

I’d say that businesses that suck at managing on-prem will not magically get competent in a public cloud.

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#197
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How!? I am a VC backed startup, just went through the same grief described in the original linked post. I like Firebase, but the moment the utility runs out we're heading back to AWS.

> I like Firebase, but the moment the utility runs out we're heading back to AWS. Just from a technical perspective I'd advise to avoid the firebase databases like the plague.

Why's that? I haven't looked into it but thought I might someday.

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#198
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

GCP loses more than a billion a quarter: https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2021/02/02/googl...

Non-AMP link: https://techcrunch.com/2021/02/02/google-cloud-lost-5-6b-in-...

Isn’t it neat how if you Google something and share the link you find, you end up directing people to Google’s AMP service!

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I like Firebase, but the moment the utility runs out we're heading back to AWS. Just from a technical perspective I'd advise to avoid the firebase databases like the plague.

It's not too bad if you use the firebase store. But yeah using the firebase realtime db for anything that requires relationships/indexing can be kinda cumbersome.

> It's not too bad if you use the firebase store

I've built a prototype on top of it and it's fairly rudimentary but you can make it work. My biggest concern is that there are no case studies I can find of people using it past the prototype stage and how the pricing/scalability works out at that point.

Re: Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison

#200
post #164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This has also been my experience. When we first launched on GCP, there was no question that it was the way to go (frankly, because of BigQuery). Working with AWS, when we launched, was going to cost us significantly more up-front, before we had even brought on our first customer. Fast forward 5 years... AWS has closed the gap in every way that matters. I still, frankly, trust Google's Security more than Amazon's, but…

(I work at AWS) > I still, frankly, trust Google's Security more than Amazon's If you have the time, could you expand on this? While I'm not directly involved in security at AWS, I'd be down to forward your thoughts to people who do.

Thoughtful features like supporting UEFI Secure Boot with vTPM attestation. This allows building setups where even a full GCP account compromise can be mitigated.

Integration with our org GSuite (this alone is a massive plus).

Post reply on HN