Live data from Hacker News

I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

drewdevault.com

231–240 of 892 posts

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How so? (genuine question from a desktop user using wayland right now)

Does taking a screenshot work for you?

Not the OP, but I'm on Fedora 33, using Gnome with Wayland (the default) and I have no issues taking screenshots (using PrtScn or Ctl-PrtScn or Shift-Ctl-PrtScn)

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#232

Well I wish I could use it, but it simply does not let me run any Steam games at this point.

Why not? I use Steam under Wayland all the time. (Although it uses XWayland, but it is seamless for me). In fact I prefer it because a lot of games try to do stupid things under X like change the resolution or always put themselves on my "first" monitor (and often mess up mouse inputs if they are moved). Under Wayland they behave much better.

The only thing that I can imagine that you are talking about is lack of proprietary driver support but that doesn't really seem related to Steam.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#233
post #163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm beating a dead horse at this point, but there's no such thing as "switching to Wayland". What most people mean when they "switch to Wayland" is that they're switching from Gnome on X11 to a "pure Gnome" stack that uses Wayland and a bunch of other Freedesktop standards for interopability. There is absolutely no code from the "Wayland project" running there, because the Wayland implementation is Gnome's own (it's…

Why does this distinction matter? Gnome on X works perfectly fine, Gnome on Wayland does not. Why does it matter it to state that Wayland is a protocol, not the implementation?

Because if what's bothering you is the implementation and not the protocol, you should be talking about fixing the implementation instead of diverting attention to the protocol? I might not understand your question here.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#234

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How so? (genuine question from a desktop user using wayland right now)

Does taking a screenshot work for you?

Been rocking wayland for over a year now, screenshots have always worked for me.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#235
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "well you don't need that anyway!" Something similar used to frustrate me no end when asking the Python community for help trying to solve a problem. Regularly someone would comment, "Why would you want to do that?". I wouldn't be asking if I didn't have a need to do it! It's bizarre that some people can't see beyond the end of their own nose and imagine different use cases to their own.

As an amateur developer, I've often found that "Why would you want to do that?" is followed by an explanation of a much better way that I hadn't even thought of. Sometimes it's asshole-behaviour, but it's often people sharing the benefit of their experience; my thinking has gone awry at some point several steps back and they want to make life easier for me.

> As an amateur developer, I've often found that "Why would you want to do that?" is followed by an explanation of a much better way that I hadn't even thought of.

Unfortunately in my experience it is often followed by an explanation of why what I'm trying to do isn't what I should want to do, as though I am not aware of my own goals and constraints.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#236
I still have mouse and keyboard issues under wayland + gnome. This bug causes the ui to drop mouse and keyboard input events whenever the rendering takes too long to complete

Issue tracking: https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=745032

https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-shell/-/issues/749

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#237

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I can certainly understand the frustration at having to deal with a community that gets annoyed at anything that changes simply because they're already so used to the garbage pile they have that they now hold the delusion that it's actually not garbage. It's not just the FOSS community, look at how non technical people react every time gmail, outlook or excel makes a tiny change to the UI (not to mention big ones).…

well yeah, i just got used to it working a certain way, now i gotta figure it out again. fucking nerds acting like it,s no big deal when shit i use every day is all changed up. do you have any idea how much cognitive load that is for the average user to figure out new ui? and usually for no good reason, just to change shit up so someone can get credit for a project. don,t blame the users for software being shit. it,s…

The reverse is also true. Don't blame people maintaining software for changing your routine. You make a lot of assumptions there but the reality is often much more nuanced. Everything changes, all the time, that's a rule that is true for absolutely everything in life.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#238

I'm really tired of this Wayland horseshit. If there was an actual reason for users to use it, fine, but instead it breaks forwarding and vnc and xclip, and for what exactly? Why should I upgrade?

If nothing else, because X.Org is effectively no longer maintained. Redhat announced in 2019 that they are basically the only ones who even try to do any maintenance and they do not expect there to be a 1.21 release. In fact no one seems to want to manage a 1.21 release.

Wayland still have bugs, but as Drew DeVault writes: They are fixable and importantly there are people willing to work on Wayland.

One of the more pressing issue currently is the Nvidia drivers, but that's not the fault of the Wayland developers. Users need to complain to Nvidia about that.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#239

> In the case of Wayland, the “vague authority” are a bunch of volunteers who have devoted tens of thousands of hours of their free time towards making free shit for you. That does not mean anyone is under an obligation to like it. > Maybe Wayland doesn’t work for your precious use-case. More likely, it does work, and you swallowed some propaganda based on an assumption which might have been correct 7 years ago. If y…

> I can certainly understand the frustration at having to deal with a community that gets annoyed at anything that changes simply because they're already so used to the garbage pile they have that they now hold the delusion that it's actually not garbage. It's not just the FOSS community, look at how non technical people react every time gmail, outlook or excel makes a tiny change to the UI (not to mention big ones).…

> It's not just the FOSS community, look at how non technical people react every time gmail, outlook or excel makes a tiny change to the UI (not to mention big ones). It really makes people angry when things don't work the same anymore, let alone when it doesn't even work anymore for their use case.

Like you note, this isn't a problem unique to Linux/"free Unixy OSes". In some ways Linux is actually worse than others, consider Gnome/Gtk Updates for example. Or how things like having a library to read a particular image format are quite normal around here; except that library has like half a dozen incompatible but actively used versions and around 1000 released versions. The Linux environment is very volatile and everything constantly changes and breaks. Modern applications bitrot exceptionally fast in Linux, while the community points to "but look this Xchess binary from 1992 still works". That's neat but covers few real use cases. The same community is then bewildered that both people and enterprises opt for distributions which move at a glacial pace and only releases updated software once every five years or so.

Re: I'm tired of this anti-Wayland horseshit

#240
post #14

I’m using a Dell UP2718Q (3840x2160, 144dpi, 60Hz) and a Fujitsu Siemens P17-2 (1024x1280, 96dpi, 75Hz) side by side, and without Wayland this setup isn’t even possible to get working properly. Sadly, KDE still doesn’t support it nicely under Wayland (so I moved to Ubuntu Budgie), but under X11 it’s entirely impossible to run it properly, as except for Qt nothing supports mixed DPI, or mixed refresh rates properly. O…

This is definitely not entirely true of x11. I have mixed DPI (which, admittedly, does work for shit, but can be hacked around by using a wrapper script to launch things with different DPIs) and mixed refresh rates. The mixed refresh rates work perfectly, zero issues (as configured via nvidia drivers, admittedly annoying for other reasons). That said I would use wayland if nvidia wasn't busy fucking everything up.

> but can be hacked around by using a wrapper script to launch things with different DPIs

I have firefox windows on both monitors, and like to drag tabs over from one to the other.

Under X11, doing so is either impossible, or requires restarting firefox, which really isn’t something I’d wanna do.

There was an old XUL extension for firefox to parse QT_SCREEN_SCALE_FACTORS and apply it instead, but that’s long gone. And normal Gtk apps never worked properly.

Post reply on HN