Live data from Hacker News

Workman Keyboard Layout (2010)

workmanlayout.org

231–233 of 233 posts

Re: Workman Keyboard Layout (2010)

#231

One thing that often goes unmentioned when I see discussions about these sorts of alternate layouts is that, particularly for programmers, the keyboard isn’t just a simple device for entering text, it’s the mechanism through which we interact with our computing environment, and most tooling is either specifically or unintentionally designed to enhance the productivity of people typing in QWERTY. Whether it’s simple c…

That's one of the reasons I decided on Colemak years ago: zxcvbqw don't move, which is most hotkeys (undo, cut, copy, paste, etc), plus hkjl, for vim, is ATLEAST on one hand, but unfortunately it's all hit with the index finger.

Re: Workman Keyboard Layout (2010)

#232

I have done testing of my own on personalized keyboard lay-out by keylogging myself. My initial interest in keyboard layouts was piqued years ago with the CarpalX project [1], so I started keylogging myself in 2017. I am a researcher, programmer, sysadmin, and work in a multilingual environment (Python, English, Dutch, R, Java, French, Spanish), so I was expecting some interesting results. I put 3 years worth of keyl…

Thanks for sharing your stats. It's really neat to see that context. I've been using workman for a few years. I chose it over colemak and norman after trying them all and picking the one I enjoy the most.

I am not writing off Workman or CarpalX just yet. Will try them all three and settle on one. They're close enough in score.

Re: Workman Keyboard Layout (2010)

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Try ASDF versus FDSA on a QWERTY layout. ASDF feels much more natural, doesn't it? It doesn't for me. Is it significantly more difficult/awkward? Maybe I'm used to it from playing scales on piano?

Same, I can type FDSA 3x as fast than I can type ASDF with my left hand.

Weird. I think any stereotypical image of a person drumming on the table with boredom, their fingers roll from the pinkie to the index finger. Looking at gifs on Google Images, I couldn't find any going the other way.

That makes me think that an inward roll is much more natural. I can type ASDF almost as fast as I can type A by itself, quite literally. It's like a drumroll.

1. http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-wuJ87jox608/VEHZPg9Fo7I/AAAAAAAAGg... 2. https://i.pinimg.com/originals/a7/d9/52/a7d952cccac40f9949bf... 2. https://www.cinemacats.com/wp-content/uploads/gifs/finncatty... 3. https://66.media.tumblr.com/33c922620e578affa28ad2b15634c870...

Post reply on HN