Live data from Hacker News

Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

reuters.com

151–160 of 637 posts

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#151

Watched an aljazira documentary about falling standards at a Boeing factory a couple of years ago and been waiting to see if something like this would happen. Now they're gonna sacrifice a lamb, keep same corporate struture and philosophy, keep on making billions, remember to appologise even more next time.

I'm not so sure about the "Making Billions" bit. They are going to have to either do a massive 11 figure write down or spread out their losses on the Max over the next 10+ years. Either one is a pretty bitter pill to swallow. I'm betting we'll see a huge write down when the new CEO takes over, that way they can push as much blame as possible on the old regime and move forward with a clean-ish slate.

Which is ironic given they chose a board member to be the new CEO. It's not new leadership, he was part of the original leadership team as a member of the board.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#152
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why on earth would the next CEO be incentivized to do anything other than wring all the money out of the company that they can? The punishments for failure are insignificant. They get to keep millions and millions of dollars even if they wreck the company.

Some people do get a sense of pride and fulfillment out of doing a good job that money can't provide.

We're talking about incentives. Sky-high executive compensation packages don't encourage people to do a better job — they insulate them from failure, thereby disincentivizing them and encouraging them to go down the path of short-termism.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#153
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The NYT story in particular was hard-hitting and well sourced. Gotta wonder if these stories influenced the board to act now. It's a bad look, because Boeing is consistently way too late to recognize what is obvious to those of us watching from home. I continue to be astounded that our most senior leaders will not act in the long-term best interest of the organizations they lead. It's been 37 years since the Tylenol…

The Tylenol crisis is basically the case study for how to handle a corporate crisis. If you get an MBA without having come across it, you should ask for your money back. > Why can't today's leaders think a little bigger, and optimize for the long term even if that has an immediate cost? I'm not sure it's so simple. At the head of the Boeing bureaucracy, Dennis Muilenberg likely was being fed a diet of wrong and horri…

No, it's not simple, and it's not easy. Doing the right thing when it involves immediate cost and disruption takes courage.

I'm sure in 1982, the Johnson & Johnson CEO was also "being fed a diet of wrong and horrible information from lower executives keen on deflecting blame so that they could keep their jobs".

That's how big organizations work.

But in 1982, J&J leadership could see beyond that, cut through the noise, push back on short-sighted recommendations, and do the right thing for the company in the long term.

My question is why we rarely see "enlightened self-interest" like this today.

From Boeing to Facebook, Wells Fargo to Uber, it's hard to think of companies that do the right thing in difficult situations, even when that would be in the company's own long-term best interest.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#154

Watched an aljazira documentary about falling standards at a Boeing factory a couple of years ago and been waiting to see if something like this would happen. Now they're gonna sacrifice a lamb, keep same corporate struture and philosophy, keep on making billions, remember to appologise even more next time.

Do you have a link to it? Or was it only shown on television? I'd like to watch it.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#155
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people do get a sense of pride and fulfillment out of doing a good job that money can't provide.

> Some people do get a sense of pride and fulfillment out of doing a good job. But a good job for a CEO is building shareholder value, which is now understood as "[wringing] all the money out of the company that they can [for the shareholders]." That's a different job than building an organization that consistently chooses safety over schedule and cost.

That's not a sound long-term plan.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#156
post #114

Boeing was still promising end of year FAA certification for 737 Max as recently as early December. Around that time, they had a spokesperson on CNBC who was asked directly how the outstanding steps (which indicated February at the earliest) aligned with their end of year statements and the position was essentially, 'we've been saying end of year and end of year could still happen.' When your brand is suffering a cri…

> 'we've been saying end of year and end of year could still happen.'

Deliberately false and misleading statements that should be prosecuted by the SEC.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#157
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s funny how people treats unions as panaceas to all problems. It’s strange to present them as some sort of solution in this case, where there was widespread engineering and management cultural issues, and would therefore somehow have prevented major air disasters. Workers rights and forcing higher wages might be great for the working poor and it might actually make economic sense in certain niche industries where…

Unions still make sense today. Without them labor conditions would likely go down quickly. There is plenty wrong with unions but to dispel the need for them without giving careful thought to their good sides is throwing out the baby with the bathwater.

There are a lot of good unions can do but I think they went way too far in their demands over the decades of their existence (like making it super hard to fire delinquent workers and hyper specialization where one guy does one job, and refuses to wear multiple hats like any modern business requires, because his union requires him only to do that one job).

It’s not like unions are bad or evil, this sort of scope creep and beaurucratic self destruction is common in countless organizations.

If unions were reformed, or we could get some form of union-lite where it really was just about wages and sane working hours/conditions then I’d be much more in support of them.

It’s just the disconnect between what it sounds like on paper (great for the working poor!) and what they actually do in practice with the myriad of negative side effects which heavily contributed to massive inefficiencies and making America (and other countries) less competitive... it’s just difficult to square the two.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#158

> Chairman David Calhoun will take over as CEO and president, effective Jan. 13, the company said, adding that a change in leadership was necessary to restore confidence in the company. If they wanted to restore my confidence, they’d have picked an engineer, not an accountant.

Someone like Dennis Muilenburg then? If the last one was an engineer, why would another engineer restore your confidence any more?

An engineering background is the bare-minimum requirement, not all engineers are equal capable (or capable at all).

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#160

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Someone like Dennis Muilenburg then? If the last one was an engineer, why would another engineer restore your confidence any more?

An engineering background is the bare-minimum requirement, not all engineers are equal capable (or capable at all).

[deleted]
Post reply on HN