Live data from Hacker News

Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

bbc.com

311–319 of 319 posts

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#311

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> First one is that up until 1989, Bulgaria was largely an agriculture state where did you get this nonsense? FYI, you've got 6 (SIX!) nuclear reactors build during those times 0 since 1990

What proportion of the GDP before 1990 was from power production then? Your argument is anecdotal. Those reactors were vanity projects, not big contributors to economy.

> Those reactors were vanity projects, not big contributors to economy.

Your argument is anecdotal.

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#312

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> First one is that up until 1989, Bulgaria was largely an agriculture state where did you get this nonsense? FYI, you've got 6 (SIX!) nuclear reactors build during those times 0 since 1990

Nuclear reactors contribute very little to the job market. We still export electricity to Romania and Greece afaik but still... As in most communist regimes go, few people were allowed to pursue the more prestigious careers, unless you were a guy who knows a guy. So whether you wanted something more or not, it boiled down to who you were. On top of that you couldn't pack your bag and move to a bigger city without a p…

> Nuclear reactors contribute very little to the job market.

that is not the point. Point is, it was contributing for years with good paying jobs, well-educated folks etc. Since 1990 - nothing.

> few people were allowed to pursue the more prestigious careers

Like gasp nuclear engineer? Yeah...

> On top of that you couldn't pack your bag and move to a bigger city without a permission of the authorities.

Really? It was that bad in Bulgaria? Definitely not like that in Soviet Russia

> As a result of all that and the appropriate weather conditions, agriculture was a safe bet for just about everyone.

Yeah, except those nuclear engineers

I bet they were dreaming at the reactor controls about moving to be a swine herders

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#313
post #310

Earlier quoted context omitted.

BG has problems, but it is not a kleptocracy.

For example, all infrastructure contracts are rewarded to a select few companies. These companies charge outrageous rates, building highways and bridges etc. at some of the highest rates per km in the EU, all the while these roads end up with significant technical problems just 2-3 years into exploitation, due to poor work and, more importantly, the use of lower quality than the spec materials (outright fraud), all t…

*rewarded = awarded

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#314

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plus EU taxes often cover healthcare so there's another huge chunk of change gone for US residents when comparing.

That's incorrect. Essentially all decent paying jobs in the US take care of most or all of the healthcare cost you're referring to. That is especially true for eg software developers who earn six figures at the median. To balance a proper comparison if you're going to include the EU taxes re healthcare, you would have to inflate US wages even higher to account for the benefit that employees receive (money that otherw…

My family healthcare coverage at my "decent paying job" at a software company in the US cost me about $13,000 out of pocket in 2018 including employee premium and medical cost before reaching deductible. I would certainly consider that to be an additional tax when comparing against the EU tax rates that include healthcare.

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#315

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I doubted that "many" expats give up their US citizenship so I tried to find some numbers. Found some secondary sources like: https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2018/05/14/fewer-ame... which states that, worldwide, just over 5,000 Americans renounced citizenship in 2017. There are also about 9 million Americans living abroad and ~1 million living in Europe. So, no, I don't think that even if all 5,000 were in Eu…

How many of these " ~1 million living in Europe" are with the US Armed Forces? (Be it as service member, spuse, family) Quick research: Kaiserslautern Military Community has ~50k people. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaiserslautern_Military_Comm... Now that's the largest, but by far not only location with US Military presence in Europe.

I'm curious, where are you heading with this counter argument? That perhaps, something like 900k Americans living in Europe are in the US Armed Forces, leaving 100k regular US citizens. So then, if all 5k of the US citizen renouncers worldwide are in Europe, then 5% of the remaining 100k _does_ count as "many"?

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#316

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have been to santorini this summer. It's an area which is not comparable to the rest of greece. A raxi to dea sunset during the afternoon can easily be 30 eur and we are talking about a distance of 7 km. Maybe off-season it's affordable. But combined with Mykonos it's an area where the term highway robbery comes ro mind.

Isn't the weather extremely bikeable? or are the roads super dangerous for that?

The roads are indeed super dangerous in my opinion (I rented a scooter once and truly feared for my life when huge buses lost their patience and overtook me during switchbacks, after that experience only cars!) and additionally you really need to be in amazing shape to bike there - steep climbs everywhere, under a hot sun.

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#317
post #80

A side effect of a stagnant economy and population shrinkage is that Bulgarian property is really cheap. You can purchase a modern flat starting around $15,000 (or rent for really cheap) in a ski community with a very strong remote worker presence (Bansko). If you do this right, you can also become a resident and benefit from a flat 10% income tax which is lowest in the EU. No affiliation; I just find this type of ar…

I have a company in Bulgaria while working remotely for a high-salary EU country, and it's almost shocking to realise how much you spend on taxes in most European countries when you see the difference in your bank account. It's quite a good deal if you want to be a digital nomad since it's an EU country and you can get a really small apartment for almost nothing to use as your official address while travelling. (You'…

What's the best way to contact you?

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#318

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nuclear reactors contribute very little to the job market. We still export electricity to Romania and Greece afaik but still... As in most communist regimes go, few people were allowed to pursue the more prestigious careers, unless you were a guy who knows a guy. So whether you wanted something more or not, it boiled down to who you were. On top of that you couldn't pack your bag and move to a bigger city without a p…

> Nuclear reactors contribute very little to the job market. that is not the point. Point is, it was contributing for years with good paying jobs, well-educated folks etc. Since 1990 - nothing. > few people were allowed to pursue the more prestigious careers Like gasp nuclear engineer? Yeah... > On top of that you couldn't pack your bag and move to a bigger city without a permission of the authorities. Really? It was…

> that is not the point. Point is, it was contributing for years with good paying jobs, well-educated folks etc. Since 1990 - nothing.

Providing say 1000 good paying jobs... In the same way Chernobyl did, and look at how well that ended. Since 1990 - a large number of mid sized software companies have shown up, each of which has employed more than that.

> Like gasp nuclear engineer? Yeah...

Let me think of how many nuclear engineers there are among me, my family or anyone I've ever known... Hmmm... It appears none.

> Really? It was that bad in Bulgaria? Definitely not like that in Soviet Russia

Well there were always gulags.

> Yeah, except those nuclear engineers > I bet they were dreaming at the reactor controls about moving to be a swine herders

Yes, out of 8M population that's 0.0125%, 99% of which were closely related to the communist party. Great job, we created a prosperous c̶o̶u̶n̶t̶r̶y̶ communism.

Re: Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country

#319

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Nuclear reactors contribute very little to the job market. that is not the point. Point is, it was contributing for years with good paying jobs, well-educated folks etc. Since 1990 - nothing. > few people were allowed to pursue the more prestigious careers Like gasp nuclear engineer? Yeah... > On top of that you couldn't pack your bag and move to a bigger city without a permission of the authorities. Really? It was…

> that is not the point. Point is, it was contributing for years with good paying jobs, well-educated folks etc. Since 1990 - nothing. Providing say 1000 good paying jobs... In the same way Chernobyl did, and look at how well that ended. Since 1990 - a large number of mid sized software companies have shown up, each of which has employed more than that. > Like gasp nuclear engineer? Yeah... Let me think of how many n…

> Providing say 1000 good paying jobs...

per reactor, and those jobs are basically for 50-60 years. And each job creates 3-4 jobs in surrounding area - teachers, salesmen, construction, ...

> Let me think of how many nuclear engineers there are among me, my family or anyone I've ever known... Hmmm... It appears none.

and how many, say, swine herders are among your family or people you know? Thousands?

> Yes, out of 8M population that's 0.0125%, 99% of which were closely related to the communist party.

number should be higher, but, again, this is not the point. People RIGHT NOW (communism is gone for 30 years already) are leaving Bulgaria in droves - no jobs, no future

Post reply on HN