Earlier quoted context omitted.
I am using "democracy" as a synonym for "liberal democracy." If you tell me about a country that: - Has a beautiful founding document that ensures what we'd recognize as basic rights of all citizens - Has a well-designed federal system that empowers individuals and lower-level governments at the expense of the federal, - Has hundreds of thousands of enslaved people who form the foundation of their economy and are ind…
>If you would, that's fine; you wouldn't be objectively wrong. I call the US a Constitutional Republic, where the representatives are elected through various implementations of the democratic process. Otherwise, I'm just highlighting the fact that the "inventors" of democracy had slaves just the same as the US (among other limitations on who had voting rights) at the time of the Revolutionary War/Independence. In som…
Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
341–348 of 348 posts
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#342Earlier quoted context omitted.
I am using "democracy" as a synonym for "liberal democracy." If you tell me about a country that: - Has a beautiful founding document that ensures what we'd recognize as basic rights of all citizens - Has a well-designed federal system that empowers individuals and lower-level governments at the expense of the federal, - Has hundreds of thousands of enslaved people who form the foundation of their economy and are ind…
>If you would, that's fine; you wouldn't be objectively wrong. I call the US a Constitutional Republic, where the representatives are elected through various implementations of the democratic process. Otherwise, I'm just highlighting the fact that the "inventors" of democracy had slaves just the same as the US (among other limitations on who had voting rights) at the time of the Revolutionary War/Independence. In som…
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#343Earlier quoted context omitted.
In a failed state scenario, as you mentioned, what's the recourse of the people?
Well, sadly, it's of course violence. The basic contract of government is you give up some liberty for safety (Hobbes), i.e. you don't go around robbing people, and the government will see that no one else goes around robbing you. But this sort of first form of government was inflexible, and if you wanted to change it you basically had to kill the people in charge. The chief innovation of liberal government was "self…
Obviously it's and absolute last ditch, not taken lightly and very undesirable. But, to have the option, is true sovereignty to me.
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#344Earlier quoted context omitted.
I think this is best workaround/outcome for both parties. With protesters not backing down, Beijing can now declare Lam has gone rogue and save its face. Cracking down on protesters definitely was not working. With international media presence they cannot crack down on protesters Tiananmen square style.
Western media was present for that
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#345Earlier quoted context omitted.
Well, sadly, it's of course violence. The basic contract of government is you give up some liberty for safety (Hobbes), i.e. you don't go around robbing people, and the government will see that no one else goes around robbing you. But this sort of first form of government was inflexible, and if you wanted to change it you basically had to kill the people in charge. The chief innovation of liberal government was "self…
Exactly. Hence, to me, the 2nd Amendment of US Constitution. Obviously it's and absolute last ditch, not taken lightly and very undesirable. But, to have the option, is true sovereignty to me.
Basically, the idea that 2A would let us protect any semblance of our current way if life is fantasy. The most you could hope for is to join a resistance and dig in for a generations long, probably species destroying authoritarian regime to run its course.
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#346Earlier quoted context omitted.
I think “human consciousness” is perhaps a poor way to describe the core idea. When you put on a glove you stop thinking about your hand as the flesh inside the glove, but rather as including this new exoskeleton. Technology gets integrated in a similar fashion. “I will call you back” is arguably not just a linguistic shortcut for “I will initiate the process that starts a phone call.” Rather it’s an inclusion of tec…
Are you, by any chance, a Scott McCloud fan? http://vickyteinaki.com/2014/uploads/phenomenology.png
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#347Earlier quoted context omitted.
> the drastic shift we have undergone as a human consciousness I don't really know what this means, but if you think that the inherent nature of the human soul has changed in the last few decades, think again... If tomorrow there was a catastrophic event such as a worldwide nuclear fallout, humans would be at each other's throats in the blink of an eye. The only thing really keeping us together are institutions and c…
I think “human consciousness” is perhaps a poor way to describe the core idea. When you put on a glove you stop thinking about your hand as the flesh inside the glove, but rather as including this new exoskeleton. Technology gets integrated in a similar fashion. “I will call you back” is arguably not just a linguistic shortcut for “I will initiate the process that starts a phone call.” Rather it’s an inclusion of tec…
Re: Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradition bill
#348Earlier quoted context omitted.
Exactly. Hence, to me, the 2nd Amendment of US Constitution. Obviously it's and absolute last ditch, not taken lightly and very undesirable. But, to have the option, is true sovereignty to me.
I mean, I guess the argument here is "well, if the gov't goes crazy we still have weapons because 2A let us amass them". But in reality, the US government is unimaginably powerful. Like they could easily take control of all energy producing facilities everywhere, every major city, port, road, railroad, airport, hospital, etc. There are probably close to a million law enforcement officials in the US. And all that's to…