Live data from Hacker News

China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

globaltimes.cn

61–70 of 192 posts

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#61
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's because DB is really bad. Everyone in Europe knows how bad DB is. It has nothing to do with high speed trains.

I didn’t know that. But then again, I only moved to Berlin late last year and I came from the UK, which is much much worse.

True

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#63
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's because DB is really bad. Everyone in Europe knows how bad DB is. It has nothing to do with high speed trains.

I didn’t know that. But then again, I only moved to Berlin late last year and I came from the UK, which is much much worse.

I still cannot believe how bad British trains are. They seem to ignore that functioning train systems exist, and just do it their own (broken) way.

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#64
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah definitively, the US is no angel that's for sure but its still aligned with democratic values (at least for now).

Democratic values? As in, the one who receives the most votes will win the election?

Few western countries have a majority votes takes all system, that does not necessarily make them undemocratic. Both Spain and Norway that I know we'll have proportional systems where the number of votes are not necessarily aligned with the number of seats in parliament. A vote in one region might be worth more than another.

Proportional systems are designed from what I understand to balance the power between the populous cities and the country side.

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#65
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The maglev they built 17 years ago for a billion dollars? China has been using maglevs for a long time. The low-medium maglevs seem quite useful too: https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/china-driverless-maglev-t... Someday they’ll probably replace their 19,000 miles (soon 25,000) of high-speed rail with maglevs. In the United States, people couldn’t be convinced to build high-speed rail and now the land is expensive.

> Someday they’ll probably replace their 19,000 miles (soon 25,000) of high-speed rail with maglevs. Not necessarily and definitely not soon. Maglev isn't strictly better (unless it's also suitable for cargo trains or China doesn't use their high-speed rail for cargo at all -- not even at night). Replacing high-speed rail by maglev means that you're basically replacing high-speed rail with somewhat higher-speed rail…

HSR on the coast are dedicated passenger lines

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#66
post #29

The cabin is interesting. There doesn't seem to be much visibility through the windows. I guess at such speeds the driver can only rely on information feeds from far up ahead, and there's little advantage to being able to see with the naked eye. Large windows would probably make it less safe in the event of flying debris too. It makes me wonder why not get rid of them all together and make the cabin like a tank. To g…

That's a good point, wonder if they can even open the side windows to look out?

I think the windows on trains generally serve to give situational awareness at the station, once you are up to speed reacting to unexpected impediments isn't so time critical since the train isn't likely to stop fast enough anyway.

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#68

Just 3 km/h less than Japan’s current prototype (but approaching production) system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L0_Series

Interesting that there are plans to run this between Washington DC and Baltimore and finish it in the same year Tokyo-Nagoya is finished. Probably won't happen, but still.

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#69
post #6

In three years they developed the technology needed, more likely just ripped off the tech from Siemens on the Shanghai line.

I will not bring up any names here. But I know there is a project between CRRC, Siemens and a university in Germany to transfer the knowledge from Siemens to China and update e.g. the controller algorithms Edit: so all the rumors about stealing are not true. The knowledge is handed over

It looks like the German maglev project shut down a few years ago because of lack of interest. I wouldn't be surprised if they were selling off whatever they had.

Re: China unveils 600 kph maglev train prototype

#70

Naive, irrelevant question. Is kph the correct way to signal "kilometers per hour" in English? I think I have seen this before in videogames maybe. Is it an US-only thing?

Either "kph" or "kmph" is a casual, sloppy, but common way, along with abbreviations like "gms" (grams) or "mts" (metres). None of these are unusual in the UK. The correct way is km/h, or (occasionally, for mathematicians or scientists) km·h⁻¹ or km h⁻¹.

I have never seen 'mts' used before, why would you, when 'm' is both more concise, and more correct?

I may have seen 'gms', but I can't think when.

I have seen kmph before, but not for several years.

'Kph' it's definitely current in spoken language, but increasingly rare in written form.

Post reply on HN