Live data from Hacker News

New logo

slackhq.com

111–120 of 259 posts

Re: New logo

#113
Ignoring the actual shape/design - they went from 11 colors to 4 (+1 if you consider the text itself). This isn't much of an improvement because printing any swag/tshirts will require a full 4up press (or four spots, depending on how they choose inks) - which is still quite expensive.

The old ChallengePost logo used 4+ colors, which meant every shirt we printed came at a $2-5 premium over a single color.

When we rebranded to Devpost, we came up with a 2 color design (so we could do spot colors), which was an improvement - but I still wish we had gotten down to 1 color.

Re: New logo

#114

This feels so generic. I get the problem they're referencing with too many colors and not working in all contexts. But the human mind being what it is, I never had a problem connecting "rainbow-colored #" with "Slack". This...this is just some kind of blob. I couldn't tell this apart from a big pharma company, or some kind of conglomerate that makes everything from toasters to jet planes. I'm reminded of the Philip M…

going through a "rebrand" is not something most companies undertake lightly.

> I'm reminded of the Philip Morris rebrand to Altria

IIRC that rebrand was done to distance the company from cancerous associations with the name "Philip Morris", whereas the only reason I can think of for Slack to do this now is to give them a quick short-term publicity boost to make them more relevant to "retail investors" -- that is, this corroborates rumors of a public offering later this year, and imho means that it's going to happen sooner rather than later.

Re: New logo

#115
post #64
post #17

More interesting for the HN crowd I think is the article from the actual design company that did the redesign: https://www.pentagram.com/work/slack

What do you think it cost to get this slack logo designed from a company that prestigious? I see they also did rolls royce

And ABB— that logo has been burned into my brain

Re: New logo

#116
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>[warning: cannot be unseen] Everyone, please look at the FedEx logo. notice the arrow between the E and x? You're welcome.

I'm hoping the difference is that Fedex actually meant to do that ;)

It is [1]

> If you put a lower-case "x" to the right of a capital "E" (Ex) you can begin to see a hint of an arrow, though it is clumsy and extremely abstract. I thought that, if I could develop this concept of an "arrow" it could be promoted as a symbol for speed and precision, both FedEx communicative attributes. [...] Once I decided to refine the concept of the embedded arrow, I found that, to make the arrow more legitimate and identifiable, one needed to actually reconstruct the letterforms in order to make the arrow happen.

[1] http://www.thesneeze.com/secrets-of-the-fedex-logo/

Re: New logo

#117
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you think it cost to get this slack logo designed from a company that prestigious? I see they also did rolls royce

Anywhere from $100k to $1m; their partner Michael Beirut was involved, so I would guess it's on the higher end of the scale.

A partner is involved in every Pentagram engagement though. Pentagram is not really like a huge Landor-esque firm, it's basically a series of small design consultancies each led by a partner that are loosely tied together. So anything that Pentagram is gonna do, at least one of the partners has to get behind it.

In some ways I guess that makes it very loosely like a VC fund.

Re: New logo

#118
Microsoft is red-green-blue-yellow

Google is red-green-blue-yellow

Now Slack is red-green-blue-yellow

Who is next?

Re: New logo

#120

[warning: cannot be unseen] There is a swastika hiding in the negative space in the middle of the logo.

It's a swastikoid, like the Sun Microsystems logo (also Columbia Sportsware Company)! https://latticelabyrinths.wordpress.com/ https://goodlogo.com/extended.info/sun-microsystems-logo-238... https://goodlogo.com/extended.info/columbia-sportswear-logo-...

Here, perhaps, it can be christened "the slackstika".
Post reply on HN