Live data from Hacker News

Why the Luddites Matter

librarianshipwreck.wordpress.com

91–100 of 131 posts

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#91

Luddites are just people disempowered by automation and capitalism: if its cheaper to use machines than people, automation makes people effectively jobless - and if automation touches multiple sectors of economy it multiplies the effect by squeezing out people from multiple sides, reducing the labor demand significantly. If there are no alternative sources of income(welfare, UBI) that correct this, expect many more "…

I think this is where the moral issue pops up. Is handing out bread and circus a meaningful response to taking away people’s agency?

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#93

> you do not have to let a tech company screaming “technological progress” in your face turn you into a paragon of passivity This was the article's highlight for me. As a senior programmer I found myself saying "no" to more and more tech nowadays -- smart speakers are and will always be not welcome in my house, I carefully study mobile app permissions and deny everything but the absolutely necessary minimum (on my mo…

Depending on who you are concerned about with regards to protecting your wifi, hiding your SSID will mostly only annoy legitimate users. The most basic script kiddie tools for breaking your wifi encryption will easily detect hidden SSIDs. Even Windows informs you that a hidden wifi network is available, it calls it "Other Network."

I didn't know the details, thank you! Appreciate the clarifications.

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#94
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am never gonna give WiFi access to my TV. Ditto. My so-called "smart" TV gets HDMI inputs and that's it. An external device connects to the Internet for Netflix etc and if that device ever displeases me or becomes truly obsolete, it can be swapped out for another. But it is extremely difficult to buy a non-smart-TV above a certain size these days. All I wanted was a high quality screen and some inputs - I don't bel…

I'm not even convinced of the usefulness of extremely large screens. You end up having to sit progressively further away from them the bigger they are, which probably requires progressively larger rooms to put the TV in.

That's subjective though, I think we can all agree.

I have a pretty decent Philips 58" TV and to be fair, watching it from the bed (2.5 - 3.0 meters) it does seem small to me.

However, if I am to buy a gaming console and sit like 1.5 meters away from the TV then it seems to be plenty enough, even a bit bigger than needed.

I will probably settle for 65" in the next 1-2 years or, if I want to spend a lot of money, 75". But that's because I plan on having a 40+ square meters (131 sq. ft.) living room.

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#95
post #86

> you do not have to let a tech company screaming “technological progress” in your face turn you into a paragon of passivity This was the article's highlight for me. As a senior programmer I found myself saying "no" to more and more tech nowadays -- smart speakers are and will always be not welcome in my house, I carefully study mobile app permissions and deny everything but the absolutely necessary minimum (on my mo…

If your access point doesn't advertise your SSID, your clients will. It's a bit counterintuitive, but in practice hiding your SSID does the opposite of what it says.

Could you please expand on that with an example? I am yet to read anything on hidden SSIDs, I'll appreciate the human explanation.

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#96
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

By the way, HDMI supports an Ethernet channel. Depeding on your setup, it may be possible for the TV to get online without a Wifi password or any cables other than power+HDMI.

This happened to a friend with a Samsung TV. One of his devices relayed Ethernet via HDMI to the Samsung and suddenly it started a firmware upgrade.

Pretty valuable feedback! I will just make sure to use an HDMI cable supporting older version of the standard. That should do the trick.

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#97
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Over time, and over lots of fighting. It didn't look like it when it's your boss that started to suppress your wages thanks to a new machine. Yes, the industrial revolution enabled increased wages and living standards. But for them to actually happen, and trickle down to workers, people had to fight hard. The modern working standards are literally written in tears and blood of our forefathers.

Technically, (somewhat) increased living standards are a inevitable consequence of significant production improvements in a not-completely-disfunctional economy. That doesn't really help in the short term though. Also: > literally written in tears and blood figuratively ; tears and blood make shit writing materials.

You must have not gotten the memo about the word "literally"

http://blog.nawaz.org/posts/2012/Aug/merriam-webster-is-roll...

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#98
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If your access point doesn't advertise your SSID, your clients will. It's a bit counterintuitive, but in practice hiding your SSID does the opposite of what it says.

Could you please expand on that with an example? I am yet to read anything on hidden SSIDs, I'll appreciate the human explanation.

https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/networking/2008/02/08/no...

tl;dr from the article:

> If the network name of a wireless network (SSID) is not broadcast, the clients must search for it with probe requests. So if you have one AP and 100 wireless devices, you partially limit exposure of the network name with one device while causing 100 devices to expose it instead.

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#99
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you please expand on that with an example? I am yet to read anything on hidden SSIDs, I'll appreciate the human explanation.

https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/networking/2008/02/08/no... tl;dr from the article: > If the network name of a wireless network (SSID) is not broadcast, the clients must search for it with probe requests. So if you have one AP and 100 wireless devices, you partially limit exposure of the network name with one device while causing 100 devices to expose it instead.

Thank you.

Re: Why the Luddites Matter

#100

> you do not have to let a tech company screaming “technological progress” in your face turn you into a paragon of passivity This was the article's highlight for me. As a senior programmer I found myself saying "no" to more and more tech nowadays -- smart speakers are and will always be not welcome in my house, I carefully study mobile app permissions and deny everything but the absolutely necessary minimum (on my mo…

I get where you're coming from but to say that computers and phones aren't used to improve people's lives is ridiculous.

GPS in my pocket. Internet connected calorie counting app. Streaming whatever show I want on demand instead of watching the one show that's on. Paying $120 dollars a year to listen to whatever music I want to. A calendar that's on all my devices that my wife can add things on. A speaker that can stream my music straight from the internet by itself.

Those are just the things I can think off of the top of my head.

Post reply on HN