Live data from Hacker News

I can no longer recommend MailChimp

grahamcluley.com

91–100 of 150 posts

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#91
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That should be a minimal number of cases, reduced further by having a big clear one click unsubscribe option. It always amazes me the business that make unsubscribing difficult. That is the real way to get placed in spam.

Does anyone trust the unsubscribe link in apparent spam, though?

I'm pretty sure clicking the unsubscribe button says "hey, this email address you obtained is real and active!"

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#92
post #20

That is not problem of Mailchimp, it's problem of culture and "best practices". It's really annoying and it became annoying long before this change. I receive lots of such emails not only from Mailchimp. At least Mailchimp has one-click unsubscribing, most custom-built mailing list systems don't have it, requiring to log in or just not working. The problem with Mailchimp is: - Spam filters work mediocre, despite AI h…

> most custom-built mailing list systems don't have it, requiring to log in or just not working Does this violate CAN-SPAM? https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/can... > You can’t ... make the recipient take any step other than sending a reply email or visiting a single page on an Internet website as a condition for honoring an opt-out request

"if people start to complain about it, we'll just say we didn't know and that we're sorry"

-- my former boss

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#93
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blacklisting would be pretty irresponsible, greylisting maybe.

On my servers, they are already greylisted (almost everyone is, by default). Greylisting works very well against most spammers, hijacked PCs, etc. (I use "spamd" [0] from OpenBSD, which also makes blacklisting very easy, FWIW). In MailChimp's case, the only thing that greylisting would accomplish is delaying the amount of time I wait to get their spam^We-mails. [0]: https://man.openbsd.org/spamd.8

Wrong terminology, my bad. I meant adding a rule for MailChimp origin emails that increases spam score but doesn't necessarily doom the message alone. Dropping their mail altogether would definitely cause some legitimate messages to be lost.

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#94
post #87
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

New domains are cheap. You don't spam from mybiz.com You spam from mybizmail.com, mybizmarketing.com, mybizoffers.com, etc.

Is that really the problem though? Most of the junk that makes it into my mailbox are from real businesses that probably stands to go bankrupt if they had to change their domain name. But they all have to spam because that's what the market does now to win.

Facebook notifications come from facebookmail.com, CarMax spams from email-carmax.com. AT&T uses att-mail.com. And so on.

They don't all do it, but many do.

And if they burn their main domain, it's an easy option.

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#95
post #32

From MailChimp's second post[1]: > More and more business owners are bringing up double opt-in. What they’ve been saying is that double opt-in is not an easy journey for their customers. Some go so far as to say that double opt-in is “broken.” I would go so far as to say if customers cannot be bothered clicking one confirmation link in an email, they didn't really care about your newsletters. [1] https://blog.mailchi…

If it isn't confirmed opt-in, it's also possible your subscribers didn't even sign themselves up. Side note: Anyone who calls it double opt-in has a whiff of 'spammer' to them even if they're not. Confirmed opt-in is a more accurate term as without that confirmation click in the initial email, there's a chance the subscriber didn't sign themself up. There are quite a few 'email bomb' services that will sign a target…

This, and typos from people who can't quite spell their email address. We don't call username + password "double login" and username without password "single login" for the same reason.

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup, the "Spam" button is a true signal. A company I worked for had problems with the number of times people hit 'spam' on the emails (not even a newsletter, but transactional emails), and AWS SimpleEmailService put us on probation. I got to write a worker task that would consume the queue of "someone marked you as spam" from SES and remove them from our email list.

Forgive the naivety, can you explain a little? From what I understand from this: You sent emails from AWS to subscribers. Some recipients hit the spam button in Gmail. You received a message for every email that had been flagged as spam, including the recipient details. Is that correct? What exactly happens when I hit the spam button in Gmail?

Gmail parses the email for an unsubscribe link and asks if you want to unsubscribe. If you say yes, it follows the link for you.

See this: https://lifehacker.com/5319723/gmail-offers-to-automatically...

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#97
post #10

Is this going to affect MailChimp's deliverability? It seems like it would, my understanding is the reason most relays and blacklists are so lenient with MailChimp is exactly because of their double opt-in policy. Looks like they're ultimately throwing their long-term business under the bus for a short burst of extra cash.

Absolutely it will. If you use MailChimp and care about deliverability, I would recommend you begin looking at alternatives (if you haven't already).

I suggest the same dirt will attach to one's reputation if using Mandrill or Tinyletter, both of which are Mailchimp subsidiaries and share outbound address ranges.

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Facebook themselves require you to log in to unsubscribe from emails. If you've disabled or deleted your account, you still get spammed daily, and there's quite literally zero way to unsubscribe.

If you’re on Gmail, you should mark it as spam, that’s what it is. You’ll also end up blocking that address. If you run your own email server, black hole the Facebook.com domain.

I think most of Facebook's email comes from facebookmail.com.

Re: I can no longer recommend MailChimp

#100

What reliable service should one use then? MailChimp is still pretty much the go-to option for me

SendGrid for transactional email, https://myemma.com/ for newsletters (although I don't think Emma do double-opt-in by default).

We've seen problems from time to time with sendgrid and mailgun IPs getting blacklisted. Moved to Postmark, who are super-strict about transactional email only, and we've not had trouble since.

I've been recommending Postmark for transactional email and one of the others for newsletters.

Post reply on HN