Live data from Hacker News

The .feedback scam

everythingsysadmin.com

121–130 of 171 posts

Re: The .feedback scam

#121

They also own .sucks... of which they were charging $2500 per domain. I don't know why these manipulative TLDs are allowable without considerable regulation. This latest example seems to be more directly extortion, and is likely illegal in many places.

Yeah, this whole TLD expansion program seems like it was extremely poorly handled by ICANN. I think it was a good idea to expand TLDs beyond the country codes and the original ones (TLDs like .travel or .nyc are genuinely useful), but approving TLDs that could be used for defamation (like .sucks) or scams like this is clearly a huge mistake. Also, putting it in the hands of private companies that can charge extortionate rates for domains is just terrible.

Re: The .feedback scam

#123
post #23
post #7

Ick. In a way, it is a sort of corporate version of those mugshot sites. I understand a lot of other scams. (Not condone, but I see the attraction of running it.) This one just seems like a lot of work to put into something that I really don't see the targeted companies choosing to go along with. Seems like borrowing a ton of grief - at the very least, they'll be hearing from a bunch of crabby lawyers.

$600 is less than the cost of lawyer time for a worthwhile response, so they may well collect more than we would like to think...

> $600 is less than the cost of lawyer time for a worthwhile response

I'd love to see NewEgg get involved in this. They have a history of going after patent and other legal trolls for the sole purpose of discouraging that type of behaviour. [0]

Sadly, it seems no one has bothered to register newegg.feedback...

[0] https://blog.newegg.com/newegg-vs-patent-trolls-when-we-win-...

Re: The .feedback scam

#124
If you click through "Claim this site" there doesn't seem to be anything in the form of verification, seems that just anyone can claim them. The price for SO was $750 though, not $600.

Re: The .feedback scam

#127
post #62

Go to http://feedback.feedback/ and write a sternly-worded review, that'll teach'em.

Also feeedback.feedback (3 e's) is still available to register for free. Someone should squat it and extort the .feedback owners to get it back.

Re: The .feedback scam

#128
> If they do discover it, they are given a choice: Pay $20/month to receive the feedback, or pay $600/year to take the web site down.

Corporate-driven lawsuit for trademark violation?

Re: The .feedback scam

#129

They also own .sucks... of which they were charging $2500 per domain. I don't know why these manipulative TLDs are allowable without considerable regulation. This latest example seems to be more directly extortion, and is likely illegal in many places.

Anyone got $200 to spend on a good joke? http://i.imgur.com/lhbIhML.jpg

Re: The .feedback scam

#130
Couldn't companies do a class-action on the fact that they pre-registered domains with trademarks belonging to other companies but not giving those domains to those companies?

There's precedent for getting a domain based on trademark from someone else.

Post reply on HN