Live data from Hacker News

Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

journals.plos.org

31–40 of 91 posts

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#31
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just because you don't make it in university doesn't mean you can't do some amazing things. I failed my oral exams in the Math Ph. D. Instead of retaking them, I left with a Master's, made a lot of money and started my own company which now has over 4 million users. Also, forget about the peak, if you build value for yourself, you'll have more every year. If you're building value for others and earning money, then in…

In fact, if money is what you're after you are probably better of getting the degree and then leaving academics, I don't know many people who stayed in the academic circuit and ended up being well off.

In academia, only those who get tenured professorships are sitting pretty. And they get to sit pretty for decades. Everyone else has to hustle to get their crumbs. I know people who are teaching adjuncts and they get paid crumbs ( $2 or $3K PER SEMESTER ). This is at a highly competitive university where tuition + board is $80K. I could not believe it.

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#32
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It almost sounds like people try harder and harder to keep up with societal expectations of continued "sharpness"... until they hit some age where cultural norms say they aren't expected to be sharp any more. And then they stop trying, which causes an outsized decline as their lowered expectations of their own capability, feeds into lowered capability, which feeds back into further-lowered expectations.

could be, I really don't know. I can imagine perfectly benign scenarios too; if our long-term memory grows with time, maybe there's just more possible connections/associations to filter out with time too, so that decision just becomes harder, with only the deeper old age being simply tissue decline, the exhaustion of cognitive reserves etc. Somewhat relatedly, I think I heard on some old Skeptic's guide to the univer…

Is it possible to get a link to that episode?

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#33
Ok, comments on fig. 2.

The 95% confidence intervals are plotted, but clearly the distribution of their subjects seems to sample heavily near where they find their peak (~25 to 40 ish), and correspondingly, the drop offs are away from that area...

Seems fishy to me.

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In fact, if money is what you're after you are probably better of getting the degree and then leaving academics, I don't know many people who stayed in the academic circuit and ended up being well off.

In academia, only those who get tenured professorships are sitting pretty. And they get to sit pretty for decades. Everyone else has to hustle to get their crumbs. I know people who are teaching adjuncts and they get paid crumbs ( $2 or $3K PER SEMESTER ). This is at a highly competitive university where tuition + board is $80K. I could not believe it.

3K per semester with an advanced degree? That's insane. You earn more being a graduate student. Is that a non-STEM field? A regular job would be a much better option.

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#35
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

could be, I really don't know. I can imagine perfectly benign scenarios too; if our long-term memory grows with time, maybe there's just more possible connections/associations to filter out with time too, so that decision just becomes harder, with only the deeper old age being simply tissue decline, the exhaustion of cognitive reserves etc. Somewhat relatedly, I think I heard on some old Skeptic's guide to the univer…

Is it possible to get a link to that episode?

ah, I'm sorry but I really don't remember. this was some years back.

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#36
post #26

yeah, but apparently barely declines untill say 60+. Speed suffers however. "The adult years were remarkable in that complexity remained at a high level for a protracted period, in spite of a slow decrease of speed during the same period. This suggest that during the adult period, people tend to invest more and more computational time to achieve a stable level of output complexity. Later in life (>70), however, speed…

It almost sounds like people try harder and harder to keep up with societal expectations of continued "sharpness"... until they hit some age where cultural norms say they aren't expected to be sharp any more. And then they stop trying, which causes an outsized decline as their lowered expectations of their own capability, feeds into lowered capability, which feeds back into further-lowered expectations.

[deleted]

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#37
post #3

I'm 20 years old in my first year of university, and I'm probably going to fail the final exams next week. I don't think I'll be having the chance to take advantage of this peak.

When I was in first year (a long time ago), the computer science department was quite new. This meant that courses were held in various different places -- engineering, science, math, etc. Unfortunately, this ultimately meant that I had to pass by the campus pub between every class, with predictable results (drinking age where I lived was 18). Whether you pass or whether you fail will not have as big an impact as you…

This is fantastic advice and very well written to boot. I think you could expand on this thought in a blog post or short story. I know I'd read it.

Re: Human behavioral complexity peaks at age 25: study

#40
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just because you don't make it in university doesn't mean you can't do some amazing things. I failed my oral exams in the Math Ph. D. Instead of retaking them, I left with a Master's, made a lot of money and started my own company which now has over 4 million users. Also, forget about the peak, if you build value for yourself, you'll have more every year. If you're building value for others and earning money, then in…

What? What does you comment have to do with the topic? It seems like you got offended by the title, which has nothing to do with what you wrote. You seem to have a chip on your shoulder about being a failure at math ( or failing to get a PhD ).

You are wrong :)
Post reply on HN