Live data from Hacker News

My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

9to5google.com

21–30 of 354 posts

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#21

That's quite a first sentence. I always felt that cases are expected and the design is based on letting the user decide what the case will be like.

I expect manufacturer to take care of the case, custom ones just makes the phone thicker/heavier, but who knows - maybe in the future we will be buying 'case-less/naked' phones and 3rd party cases depending on the protection level needed.

Thinking about, idea doesn't sound too bad.

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#22
post #17

If Google won't repair a manufacturing defect, consider a chargeback (assuming you bought it from Google). Services like American Express have purchase protection, but the limits I believe won't be enough to cover the Pixel. If you were sold a lemon and Google won't hash it out, go ahead and let the card company fight that battle for you. If enough people start doing this, you can bet Google will double down on custo…

Initiating a chargeback is tantamount to terminating your Google Account at a random time in the future when they find in your favor.

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#23
post #8

Waiting to see when this crops up here, and how it'll fly considering Consumer Rights [0]. It falls into minor, so Google will have to: * free repair, (with a repair notice describing the fault) * replacement (must be the same condition as the purchase, so no second hand!) * refund (the same amount you have already paid, provided in the same form as your original payment.) And of course, the kicker: > You are entitle…

You probably could mention where "here" is.

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#24
Customer service people aren't experts (even the higher level ones). They have scripts, list of defects and how to help you resolve them. This "bubble" is obviously something they have never seen before, unless a 1% of the phones start having this issue they will just blame you for it.

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#25
post #23
post #8

Waiting to see when this crops up here, and how it'll fly considering Consumer Rights [0]. It falls into minor, so Google will have to: * free repair, (with a repair notice describing the fault) * replacement (must be the same condition as the purchase, so no second hand!) * refund (the same amount you have already paid, provided in the same form as your original payment.) And of course, the kicker: > You are entitle…

You probably could mention where "here" is.

They did mention: .au

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#26
post #23
post #8

Waiting to see when this crops up here, and how it'll fly considering Consumer Rights [0]. It falls into minor, so Google will have to: * free repair, (with a repair notice describing the fault) * replacement (must be the same condition as the purchase, so no second hand!) * refund (the same amount you have already paid, provided in the same form as your original payment.) And of course, the kicker: > You are entitle…

You probably could mention where "here" is.

Australia, judging by TLD

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#27
post #7

That's quite a first sentence. I always felt that cases are expected and the design is based on letting the user decide what the case will be like.

I am in the same camp as him actually. I dislike using a case and prefer to use the phone as it was (afaik) intended to be used. Cases change the weight and feel of the device. I also would like to add that in all my years of smartphone usage (probably about 4 years, quite late adopter) I never broke my phone or screen.

I did break a phone scene once by dropping it. But, running the numbers replacing it was actually cheaper than buying a new case for every phone, so IMO they are simply not worth it.

A simple plastic screen protector might be, but those always get bubbles.

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#28
It's a persistent story: Google reliably has the worst customer support of any large company, to the point that Comcast or your local DMV starts to look good in comparison. It's impressive, in its own way.

And as long as their consumer facing products were things like free webapps, they could get away with it.

...but if they want to sell a premium-priced handset, they can't get away with it. It's a USD$750 phone, come on. Telling the user that it's probably just a non-existent screen protector?

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#29

And now, after the PR shitstorm for reaching HN's frontpage, all will be solved in a couple hours...

Kind of with you on that one, but if "United Breaks Guitars" is an indication, sometimes large corporations don't learn on the first go around.

Re: My Pixel has a manufacturing defect

#30
post #22
post #17

If Google won't repair a manufacturing defect, consider a chargeback (assuming you bought it from Google). Services like American Express have purchase protection, but the limits I believe won't be enough to cover the Pixel. If you were sold a lemon and Google won't hash it out, go ahead and let the card company fight that battle for you. If enough people start doing this, you can bet Google will double down on custo…

Initiating a chargeback is tantamount to terminating your Google Account at a random time in the future when they find in your favor.

...hmm, you're likely right, but I'm actually quite curious to see if anyone's willing to challenge that in court if it happens given that Google doesn't really give anyone an easy way to migrate an entire life to another service.
Post reply on HN