Live data from Hacker News

TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

truepublica.org.uk

41–50 of 208 posts

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#41
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is really puzzling me is how the procedure for this got approved, and by whom. Who is telling MP's and MEP's that they have to follow these rules? And how are they bound by them?

The guys pushing ttip i guess They're probably allowed to do it however they please, after all they wrote the document and are free to "license" it however they want What puzzles me is that TTIP is even in consideration anymore with these measures and all the secret keeping in place. If it truly were that good for us WHY on earth would you take these measures?

Short answer: Two-level game theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-level_game_theory

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#42
post #35

Sometimes I just want to think those treaties' function is to curtail multinationals, so that countries can be able to effectively organize themselves against those corporations who have become hard to regulate in a context of globalization. So if you want to successfully do it, you have to keep as many people in the dark, since I also believe those big companies have a tremendous influence on politicians. Maybe it's…

It's very difficult to give you a clear reason on why X thing is bad because.. well, nobody have seen X.

But, if you are not very naive, you should be asking yourself why a free trade treaty is so important when we already have free trade. And if it's only a few changes to the current situation, why all the secret?

Anyway, the things that have been leaked don't sound very well.

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They should send someone in who has a photographic memory. In two hours he/she can browse those 600 pages, and later someone else can type them out. And this may all be done for a good hourly fee.

They should pass an emergency law that requires all documents containing suggested content for national legislation be published in full, made available to the public via government websites (or national equivalents). Wording not published could not be included in any legislation. Anything short of that makes a mockery of the idea that we have any sort of democracy. A democracy where the demos aren't allowed to read…

They should also be in a public revision control system.

I don’t just want to see the material, I want to see who added/removed what and when.

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#44
post #32
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wrong. UKIP and Labour hold the majority seats for the UK in the EUP and they're both against TTIP.

How would that stop the UK government from pushing this? The EUP does not control the UK government or the House of Commons.

@deif TTIP will have to be ratified by the individual national governments, either by voting on it in parliament or through direct popular vote.

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#45
post #35

Sometimes I just want to think those treaties' function is to curtail multinationals, so that countries can be able to effectively organize themselves against those corporations who have become hard to regulate in a context of globalization. So if you want to successfully do it, you have to keep as many people in the dark, since I also believe those big companies have a tremendous influence on politicians. Maybe it's…

Wish I could agree with your optimism.

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#46
post #17

Is this a reason to vote Brexit? I would like to be able to vote out any political party that is entering into such an agreement, but if it's the EU's bureaucracy itself I have no democratic way to do so. (I'm asking this sincerely. I don't yet know enough to be able to be for or against Brexit.)

Europe has a parliament that is elected by the people of Europe, including (as of now) the people of Britain. Without the approval of the EU parliament TTIP cannot become law.

Also, the EU Commission (that is the administrative body that you call the EU's bureaucracy) cannot take office or stay in office without the approval of the European parliament. The European parliament has kicked out a commission before so they are by no means a paper tiger.

The commission can do very little on its own other than managing things according to existing rules. Without the parliament and the European council (which comprises representatives of national governments), no substantive new regulations can be passed.

So yes you can vote them all out and no, the "EU's bureaucracy" cannot enter into such an agreement all by itself.

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#47
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is really puzzling me is how the procedure for this got approved, and by whom. Who is telling MP's and MEP's that they have to follow these rules? And how are they bound by them?

The guys pushing ttip i guess They're probably allowed to do it however they please, after all they wrote the document and are free to "license" it however they want What puzzles me is that TTIP is even in consideration anymore with these measures and all the secret keeping in place. If it truly were that good for us WHY on earth would you take these measures?

"coordination" is the argument for secrecy.

As there will be single-issue opponents in each of the parties, any multi-parties negotiation will fail if it happens in public.

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#48
post #35

Sometimes I just want to think those treaties' function is to curtail multinationals, so that countries can be able to effectively organize themselves against those corporations who have become hard to regulate in a context of globalization. So if you want to successfully do it, you have to keep as many people in the dark, since I also believe those big companies have a tremendous influence on politicians. Maybe it's…

They listed several concrete examples

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#49
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This kind of procedure is clearly there to fight democracy. I think the TTIP should not be adopted whatever its content, just because of this non democratic procedure. The people who have initiate this procedure should be investigated. Maybe a law should be adopted to punish these nasty people.

> Maybe a law should be adopted to punish these nasty people. I don't think you should punish people with ex post facto laws, and in many countries you can't.

TTIP may violate some of the principles behind our democracies. Laws already exist to cover for example treason...

Re: TTIP Enters New and Dangerous Stage as Democracy Is Dismantled in Secret

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They should send someone in who has a photographic memory. In two hours he/she can browse those 600 pages, and later someone else can type them out. And this may all be done for a good hourly fee.

They should pass an emergency law that requires all documents containing suggested content for national legislation be published in full, made available to the public via government websites (or national equivalents). Wording not published could not be included in any legislation. Anything short of that makes a mockery of the idea that we have any sort of democracy. A democracy where the demos aren't allowed to read…

> A democracy where the demos aren't allowed to read the treaties before they are ratified, what a ridiculous perversion of a notion that is.

That would be ridiculous, but TTIP will be published when people agree on what it should be, then it'll be voted on. See here: http://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/in-focus/ttip/about-ttip/pr...

When you think "X is ridiculous" consider that maybe X is not actually true.

Post reply on HN