Live data from Hacker News

Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

nytimes.com

91–100 of 149 posts

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#91
post #5

The recall report: https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/rcl/2023/RCLRPT-23V838-8276.PDF This recall is specifically targeted at the system that monitors if the driver is paying attention.

So when is Toyota (the only other system I have experience with) going to be recalled? Their system is worse than Tesla's and will just randomly disable itself with zero alerts.

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#92
post #65
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you a new Tesla owner? > I got a software update that seemed to add auto steer to my non-autopilot model y. All (edit: new since 2019) Teslas come with autopilot. “Full self driving” is an add on. > I tried it a few times on the highway but it seemed erratic (switching off randomly and dangerously engaging regenerative brakes in the fast lane) “Switching off” usually means that it can’t identify the lane it’s sup…

I've been driving an M3 since 2020 and have put 40k miles on it, mostly over road trips throughout California and the western half of the US. Phantom braking has always been a bit of an issue -- when I first got the car, I just wouldn't use cruise control in heavy traffic, but felt ok using it once out of a city. In the past year or so, it's been so bad I'm scared to use it at all, and I've filed multiple complaints…

That's weird, I've had a Model 3 since 2018 and it definitely used to have some issues with phantom braking, but for the last ~year it seems to be totally fixed (at least for highway driving, still sometimes gets confused on surface roads). Even in the past though I never had anything close to what you're describing where the car slams on the brakes every 10 minutes in good conditions.

Are you running an old software version? You might try bringing it in for service because what you're describing definitely doesn't seem right.

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#93
post #2

Note: “tesla recalls” == “tesla pushes OTA software update (just like any regular OTA update)”

> The update will add new, more prominent visual alerts and checks for the Autosteer function, which is part of Autopilot. Nothing was actually broken but regulators just insist on more alerts and Tesla just implemented those and is rolling them out with a routine software update. But that's a less dramatic headline. Actual recalls are less frequent unless there is a hardware problem like the wheels falling of a toyo…

This is a very biased reading of things.

"Tesla recall: nothing actually broken"

"Other manufacturer recalls: wheels falling off"

If I look at the recalls for my cars, they're far more mundane. "A passenger detection module may not detect a passenger. The vehicle will automatically deploy air bags in that seat position". "The passenger side camera may get foggy in cold weather".

And I don't think throwing shade at Toyota there helps a lot. Perhaps remember that Tesla has shipped vehicles with missing brake pads, unglued windshields, etc.

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#95
post #2

Note: “tesla recalls” == “tesla pushes OTA software update (just like any regular OTA update)”

You clearly don't know what recall means as your statement is completely wrong. The recall is not equivalent to how it's resolved. You could turn that into an arrow instead. I.e. due to the recall, Tesla is pushing an ota that will address the safety concerns.

To help you better understand in the future:

> A recall is issued when a manufacturer or NHTSA determines that a vehicle, equipment, car seat, or tire creates an unreasonable safety risk or fails to meet minimum safety standards.

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The NYT is more than capable of making a clear headline. These are not stupid people. But they do have goals.

The headline is perfectly clear and is not using language in a new way. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) issues recalls for safety related issues. The way the manufacture resolves the issues can differ.

Sure, you're technically correct, but when the average person reads "recall" they typically assume something very different. Doubly so since this isn't even a bug fix, just a new requirement to add additional safety checks above and beyond the ones already there.

There's no reason the headline couldn't have read something like "Tesla Issues Software Update at Request of NHTSA", which would be less likely to confuse the average reader, but also less attention-grabbing.

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#97
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I commented on a post on X stating about the recall. I said that it's an OTA. But many people said technically it's a recall.

Is it? I don't see android "recalling" android devices every update.

Yes, it is. A recall is about the fact that there are unsafe devices, not about how they get fixed.

> A recall is issued when a manufacturer or NHTSA determines that a vehicle, equipment, car seat, or tire creates an unreasonable safety risk or fails to meet minimum safety standards

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> and then this term will no longer be usable for clickbait article titles. It's not clickbait, that's ridiculous. The essence of the article is the results of the investigation. NHSTA has a process, they investigated and issued a recall. The fact that it can be fixed OTA doesn't change the intent of what's happening. I mean, at what point does the first comment stop being, "It's not a recall!" Who cares. I'm more in…

NHSTA needs to reevaluate the usage of “recall” in situations where nothing is being physically recalled to the manufacturer’s facilities. It is only confusing people. There are much clearer ways to phrase what has occurred like “Regulators force Tesla to issue mandatory OTA update to address issues with auto pilot”

Sorry, but do all teslas have starlink or whatever satellite provided connections? Are all cars connected to the internet? Until that happens, I want a recall that _can_ be fixed by an OTA update called a recall.

Because for sure my parents' next car will have OTA capacity, but also be disconnected by my dad. If it needs a software update, that vehicle will be driven to a garage. If you don't issue a recall anymore, it'll be dangerous.

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#99
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The headline is perfectly clear and is not using language in a new way. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) issues recalls for safety related issues. The way the manufacture resolves the issues can differ.

Sure, you're technically correct, but when the average person reads "recall" they typically assume something very different. Doubly so since this isn't even a bug fix, just a new requirement to add additional safety checks above and beyond the ones already there. There's no reason the headline couldn't have read something like "Tesla Issues Software Update at Request of NHTSA", which would be less likely to confuse t…

In the old days, recalls meant the car had to go back to the dealer for a fix. Then "recall" got a legal meaning, and as we moved to cars that could be updated at home, the term stuck because it is now enshrined in official regulation. It is just anachronistic terminology now like "hang up the phone."

Re: Tesla Recalls 2M Vehicles over Autopilot Software Issue

#100
post #34
post #2

Note: “tesla recalls” == “tesla pushes OTA software update (just like any regular OTA update)”

Just because a manufacturer applies a fix OTA doesn’t make it not a recall. Recall is just a term. Regulators issue the recall. How the manufacturer performs the fix can vary.

I think the difference is with any other manufacturer an announced recall means you are scheduling a service appointment with the dealership, taking time off work, finding a babysitter, doing the rental agreement paperwork if it is a lengthy fix, etc...

With Tesla no action on your end is required. The car will download the fix and apply it automatically.

Post reply on HN