Live data from Hacker News

They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

youtube.com

701–710 of 795 posts

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#701

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen another channel do this too, Corridor Digital. They're creating their own video platform, though it seems to be more so to get away from the traditional Hollywood model, but I guess that also has the benefit of not being beholden to the whims of YouTube. I wonder what the internet would look like if everyone did something like this rather than having all their content hosted on a central platform. What woul…

Won't this approach eventually lead to what happened with blogging? 10-15 years ago we all had our own wordpress/static/ghost blogs hosted on our own domains, and then Blogger, Medium and Substack entered the space with the added benefits of discoverability and a very significant chunk of the self-hosted blogs moved to those platforms. I feel that with YouTube we just skipped that initial self-hosted step and immedia…

There used to be self-hosted video content on the web as well. It’s just that it isn’t very memorable due to the technical limitations of the time before YouTube and other platforms took it over.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#702

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this is a good analogy for software. To the typical user, some software is easy and sensical, while other is obtuse and requires significant jiggering just to do the thing it was ostensibly designed to do.

There is a difference, however. The connectors that require a lot of force for insertion and removal have some true advantages, they are usually the simplest, cheapest and generally reliable components. Almost nothing can go wrong with a simple wire terminal, it's just a piece of rectangular or round metal. Although it can be difficult to disconnect for servicing, but you're only expected to do that once per year. On…

Yes, a shell script, but for the sake of the discussion, you must imagine that to the average user, invoking a shell script is “the same” as navigating through a few settings menus and clicking some checkboxes they don’t understand: that is to say, when the UX is sufficiently lacking, users often enter “well I don’t really know what I’m doing just push through” mode.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#703
post #197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Off-topic, but this might be a good opportunity to address this: Do people find "?" as being aggressive? I think questions generally, tend to be aggressive (which is why deflecting back at your opponent is common in online arguments), and I'm having a hard time seeing how a question mark does more than just attempt to annoy the other person. I'm curious what others think, I may be too sensitive.

Hard to know. I read it as, "huh?" or "what?" or even maybe, "who are you kidding?" and for all of those determining offense level comes with context. In this context, the person replying clearly sees it as a bullet and puts some detail on why out there. Frankly, that kind of thing is as offensive as we all might think it is. Almost any offensive thing is. Context matters.

Yep, that's how I intended it, effectively the same as "What?" with the implied offense level being no larger or smaller than the offense inherent in expressing surprise at someone else's opinion. That level is not zero, but it falls well within the bounds of civil discourse, especially given the lack of elaboration in the original position and the fact that I invested seventeen times its length on explaining my own -- only to not receive a followup from the original poster.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#704
When creators opt for the easy-mode discoverability and pre-built audiences on YouTube, they're also opting for the severe limitations on their freedom to produce the content they want to that Google has every right to dictate.

The solution here isn't to appeal to Google to change their ways, it's for more creators to pick competing platforms or go the self-hosted/decentralized route. I think it's still an option for higher effort content, using YouTube as more of a teaser platform to drive viewers to their actual website. It will definitely result in significantly slower growth and less eyeballs, but with the ability to still make money off platforms like Patreon (which most YouTubers say is their primary source of income these days anyway), the trade off of being in complete control of your own content seems like it should be worth it.

Thinking about it, I suppose it's possible that more creators actually are doing this and I just haven't seen them because they're harder to find.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#705

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This strategy will fail pretty badly if you're on someone else's computer using Windows or DOS, where 'del' is the delete command.

Does `del -rf /` do a lot on Windows?

I doubt it, but `del *` should do the same thing on both systems.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#706
post #138

The real question (not my own): Why hasn't youtube built any tooling for creators? Not a single editing tool, let alone a whole suite. You're expected to show up with your already polished in Adobe mp4. They could own a huge chunk of that market, yet seemingly willingly choose not to.

YouTube does have editing tooling for creators, at least it did the last time I uploaded something.

On mobile?

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#707
post #704

When creators opt for the easy-mode discoverability and pre-built audiences on YouTube, they're also opting for the severe limitations on their freedom to produce the content they want to that Google has every right to dictate. The solution here isn't to appeal to Google to change their ways, it's for more creators to pick competing platforms or go the self-hosted/decentralized route. I think it's still an option for…

That's my stance as well. I'm usually all for bashing Google and other GAFAs, but here the service they offer is pretty incredible and I can't imagine any serious competition managing to offer the same features with the same conditions.

They're hosting petabytes upon petabytes of videos, transcoded to work anywhere, forever, for free. And you can even get a share of the ad revenue. I can't imagine how I would even begin to develop a competing website, I'd be drowned in hosting fees before I even make a dent in Youtube's user share.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#708
post #647

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think if you watch OPs video you would agree that in this case YouTubes systems is also broken. It’s kind of ridiculous that YouTube accept claims against an entire video without _any_ evidence, or even a description of what copyrighted material is being infringed on. Instead it seems that YouTube will simply let someone claim that a video has copyrighted content without explanation (and in violation of the DMCA),…

Americans have setup the DMCA law in a way that content must be taken off without evidence (with widespread support on HN no less), so this one really isn't on YouTube.

If you read the DMCA you would know that at a minimum a DMCA notice needs to describe the copyrighted work being infringed upon (i.e. explain what has been stolen).

You can’t just go and claim that a video or other content infringes on a copyright somewhere. You must state which copyright is being infringed upon.

> (ii) Identification of the copyrighted work claimed to have been infringed, or, if multiple copyrighted works at a single online site are covered by a single notification, a representative list of such works at that site. [1]

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/512

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#709

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think so too. If they were not a monopoly they'd have content creators fleeing the platform for how they handle these type of situations but for many youtube provides a decent source of income. Content creators respected their part of the bargain and worked hard to build their channels and Google benefitted quite well. But they're not only not equal, one zero power and the other one has all of it.

There have been attempts to fight the Youtube/Google platform, Patreon in a way is fighting against the Youtube ad revenue as a channels main source of income, so channels can survive on their own. Linus tech tips is creating their own video platform called Float-plane aiming to also do the same.

A music educator/vloger Adam Neely has been promoting two more platforms: Skillshare (https://www.skillshare.com/) and Nebula (https://watchnebula.com/), they seem like a good idea for educational and creative content but nowhere near YT omnipresence. A bunch of popular youtubers are present there though.

Re: They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]

#710

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If all speech has consequences, and there's nothing wrong with putting consequences to speech, what's wrong with the government doing so?

Well you can't reasonably opt-in or opt-out of a government, and you can't do much to change it if your saying you want a change lands you in jail for criminal speech. You can't freely associate to spread your message or convince others. If on the other hand, the government protects your speech from its own intervention, and you have a popular view that is unwelcome on some website like twitter, you're still able to…

But is there anything morally wrong with it? Does it inhibit freedom of speech to execute people for criticizing the government? If so, how?
Post reply on HN