Live data from Hacker News

ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

torrentfreak.com

61–70 of 86 posts

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#61
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do those sites actually show you content while they install your malware? I've never seen them do the former - only the latter, and that plenty.

Yes, and they don't install malware. (At least, they've never infected me. But it's not like the media center PC is an unpatched Windows using IE and no adblocker. That'd be the honeypot (if I had one).)

Now I think about it, I haven't looked at them since Flash was a thing. Maybe they've improved in the interim.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Has anything close popped back up yet? There was stuff that I couldn't even buy if I wanted to.

Yes actually: redacted.ch is the continuation of it. Quite a large community at the moment. I would however say that the original torrents that were uploaded when they first re-opened it (it was called Pass The Headphones) a lot of the torrents were junk, but the moderators have done a wonderful job allowing torrents to be "trumped".

Definitely would be interested in an invite. Alternately, some information on where any former what people should be looking for more info.

Any observations you have about their apparent opsec would also be interesting.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#63

I was about to add them to our tracker list. :( https://github.com/sergiotapia/magnetissimo There's something really sad when these sites die, a part of my teenage life is gone for good. I felt the same way when Demonoid shut down. Can these sites skate the legality line by offering only magnet links? Why are their costs so high if they can just host magnet links and cache the site with Varnish or something similar?

You may want to remove EZTV from your support, it was subject to a hijack and unless that's changed (?) it probably shouldn't be trusted.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes actually: redacted.ch is the continuation of it. Quite a large community at the moment. I would however say that the original torrents that were uploaded when they first re-opened it (it was called Pass The Headphones) a lot of the torrents were junk, but the moderators have done a wonderful job allowing torrents to be "trumped".

Definitely would be interested in an invite. Alternately, some information on where any former what people should be looking for more info. Any observations you have about their apparent opsec would also be interesting.

Sorry no invites to give, unfortunately. I used what.cd briefly, but I received an invite from an admin who is a good friend of mine growing up, and he's fairly high up the chain. There's definitely the same level of love and care put into the site as before.

Of course, like what, it's really hard to get your ratio up without uploading your own albums, or trumping others. They do however give freeleech tokens every so often.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#65

I was about to add them to our tracker list. :( https://github.com/sergiotapia/magnetissimo There's something really sad when these sites die, a part of my teenage life is gone for good. I felt the same way when Demonoid shut down. Can these sites skate the legality line by offering only magnet links? Why are their costs so high if they can just host magnet links and cache the site with Varnish or something similar?

>Why are their costs so high if they can just host magnet links and cache the site with Varnish or something similar? Just from personal experience, but here is my view of it. A good search engine for millions of torrents costs several hundred a month. Scrapers to keep torrent seeders / leechers up to date cost another fifty to hundred (depending on how up to date you want your torrents). Now add in a few website ser…

Also, accepting donations and sponsorships opens you up to being sued for profitting from copyright infringement.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#66
post #47
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pretty much all torrent index that have closed ? They were in a very similar position (no content is hosted, but they help piracy) and we can see where that lead them. Your idea is probably even harder to defend, because you'd be sending the webtorrent code directly along the list of torrents, instead of having to copy-paste a link in another application. As a user, it feels like I'm just clicking on a button to down…

At some point I hope the media conglomerates sue Google and lose. Long has it been the case where I can search "watch x [for free|online]" and Google will helpfully point me to a site where I can do just that, no need to install torrent software or anything. The difference from a torrent/magnet link hosting site may just be one of broad vs specific searching purpose but is that enough to continuously keep Google clea…

That's because the facts have shown us that when it's about IP, it doesn't matter whether you're right or wrong:

- either you have no money at all, and you'll probably get a pass

- or you have some money, and you'll get sued until all that money goes into the rights-holders' pockets or your lawyers' pockets, whichever comes first

- or you have a fricking huge amount of money, so much that you can withstand any amount of trial thrown at you and probably come out victorious in the long run

It's an attrition fight, and Google is the clear dominant fighter in the arena

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Why are their costs so high if they can just host magnet links and cache the site with Varnish or something similar? Just from personal experience, but here is my view of it. A good search engine for millions of torrents costs several hundred a month. Scrapers to keep torrent seeders / leechers up to date cost another fifty to hundred (depending on how up to date you want your torrents). Now add in a few website ser…

Also, accepting donations and sponsorships opens you up to being sued for profitting from copyright infringement.

Bitcoin donations was how I handled it at the time. A little more anonymous especially if you pay for anonymous hosting with bitcoin.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also, accepting donations and sponsorships opens you up to being sued for profitting from copyright infringement.

Bitcoin donations was how I handled it at the time. A little more anonymous especially if you pay for anonymous hosting with bitcoin.

IANAL but purposefully hiding the transactions may just open you up to other legal issues.

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Has anything close popped back up yet? There was stuff that I couldn't even buy if I wanted to.

Yes actually: redacted.ch is the continuation of it. Quite a large community at the moment. I would however say that the original torrents that were uploaded when they first re-opened it (it was called Pass The Headphones) a lot of the torrents were junk, but the moderators have done a wonderful job allowing torrents to be "trumped".

Also throwing in my hat in hopes for an invite

Re: ExtraTorrent Shuts Down for Good

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bitcoin donations was how I handled it at the time. A little more anonymous especially if you pay for anonymous hosting with bitcoin.

IANAL but purposefully hiding the transactions may just open you up to other legal issues.

Good to know (think about). Luckily, the site is no longer in operation.

EDIT: clarification

Post reply on HN