Live data from Hacker News

School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

york.ac.uk

571–580 of 706 posts

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#571

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

some types of content are indisputably disturbing for kids, like violence, war footage, sexualized content (esp. a sexualized female image targeting male kids & teens), etc

So outlaw Betty Boop and Jessica Rabbit? Will dating before 21 without a religious chaperone be OK?

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#572

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I definitely agree. If my kid went to school in south side chicago I’d get bored getting texts 291 times per day, yea

I think you've missed my point. Yes, I want to know these things happen. No, they are not such an emergency that my kid needs to be taking time from class to text me about it. Most schools in areas with lots of crime or gang activity have metal detectors and other security at the doors. Violence is happening off hours, or between gang members either off campus (but close enough to warrant bringing people inside) or a…

this is a good thing I can talk to my kid about… there’s this Earth and on this Earth there is this Country where based on number of people that live there vast majority will not experience being gunned down in what should be 2nd safest place you can be. no other country on Earth has these issues, even ones that are 5x+ size of this one. But you know, statistically speaking you should technically be OK…

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#573
post #459

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's nothing. This study is narrow and shows no changes in cognitive capability, only sleep. A huge longitudinal study has shown screen time has minimal effect on cognitive ability or behavior of kids: https://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/news-events/no-evidence-screen-time... There are far worse things in modern culture that are stressing out kids out.

Do you suppose that study is the final word on topic? Replication is an important part of the scientific process, as are converging lines of evidence.

The study I linked covered 12000 kids across demographics. You can dig through studies all you want there is scant evidence to implicate screen time for anything. And yet parents are so utterly convinced.

We are ignoring the obvious which is that children's anxiety and depression is caused by the same things as adults.

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#574

Lifetime mobile phone abstinent human here. Sleep and mood (thumbs up) Waiting for everyone else to stop using the cursed devices and start to enjoy real life allowing themselves to be fully immersed in it for the first time(shrug) "Fully immersive" games are sought after but from my point of view people that use mobile phones have never been fully immersed in their physical reality before (its pretty sick bruh, ther…

Good for you, but you are implicitly engaging in the naturalist fallacy. Phones are objects. Social media and gambling-like games that exploit the limbic system. If you want to regulate those that would be a good start.

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#575

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please keep in mind, these lists are usually completely arbitrary and have very loose definitions of "school shootings", based around the usual theatrics of security and terror theater. Some examples that have been on these lists in the past: - A school resource officers firearm that accidentally went off when a child hugged around his waist. No injuries (there are other questions, but doesn't qualify in the same way…

>> Please keep in mind, these lists are usually completely arbitrary and have very loose definitions of "school shootings" While I get your point, I think when you have to be concerned about how 'school shooting' is defined your country has a big problem.

Their point is how much media hysteria hypes things up, and people from other countries accepting that distorted view of the country as normal here.

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#576

Disclosure: I work for a social media company. However I live in the UK. Most schools in the UK ban phones in school. The difference here is that in this study phones were taken away for 21 days, even after school. They lost access to the phone completely during that time. I am less convinced that we should wholesale ban phones for kids, because in the UK at least, there is no longer any culture of letting kids go ou…

[flagged]

The idea that parent control is censorship is very funny. Kid’s brains shouldn’t be exposed to addictive and exploitative content.

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#577

Disclosure: I work for a social media company. However I live in the UK. Most schools in the UK ban phones in school. The difference here is that in this study phones were taken away for 21 days, even after school. They lost access to the phone completely during that time. I am less convinced that we should wholesale ban phones for kids, because in the UK at least, there is no longer any culture of letting kids go ou…

> there is no longer any culture of letting kids go out and socialise.

Could this have died due to tech?

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#578

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

some types of content are indisputably disturbing for kids, like violence, war footage, sexualized content (esp. a sexualized female image targeting male kids & teens), etc

We can recruit them to fight in a war, but it might be disturbing to show them what they signed up for.

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#579

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Non of that paper stuff! Stone tablets only.

No. Paper and handwriting is great.

For a subset of the population who are manually adept. Excluding modalities from school isn't productive.

Re: School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study

#580

Earlier quoted context omitted.

you can accomplish a whole lot of the same keeping the phone and deleting all social media apps and accounts (what I did). I still use my phone as a map and camera and many other things … my screentime went from 7+ hours to hardly ever over 40 minutes daily

That's not the point. The focus here is on removing the smartphone out of the system, not removing features from the smartphone.

that is actually not the focus. phones in it of themselves are not actually a problem, what we do with them is. you get phone companies to provide under-16 phones which have ability to call, text, use Map and limited browser capacity and not a single soul would complain about kids having phones on them. not a single soul might be a stretch as of course there’ll always be someone but you get my point…
Post reply on HN