Live data from Hacker News

Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 69 posts

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#51

I'm only 23 years old, and I hail from the East Coast of Canada. I've never heard anyone pronounce it "Jif", but I had read on reddit that some people have had the opposite experience, never hearing the "Giff" pronunciation.

I only know one guy who says giff. I've always said jif, and frankly probably the rest of my circles were influenced by my pronunciation until lately.

The giff guy won't budge.

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#55

"They are wrong. It is a soft ‘G,’ pronounced ‘jif.’ End of story.": http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/21/an-honor-for-the-cr...

Most linguists would agree that it is logically contradictory to state that the majority of speakers pronounce a word incorrectly, because the correct pronunciation is determined by observing how people actually say a word, and not how one very special person thinks other people should pronounce it.

Isn't prescriptivism vs. descriptivism actually a very old divide among linguists?

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#56
This question always reminded me of the discussion we used to have in the early Quake scene; hard G or J for the word gib. Hard G always made more sense to me, but then I heard someone from id software explain that it should be a J, since the root of the word was "giblets".

Even knowing I'm not saying it the same was as the person who coined the phrase couldn't make me change. hard G gib just sounded more correct!

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#57
post #12

In France, G and J have the opposite sound: J sounds like G, and G like J. Makes sense? ;-) As such, everybody pronounces it "JIF" here. And it seems to go in the author's direction, so it's fine.

Is that "JIF" meant to be pronounced in English or French, then? ;)

"jee-f" :)

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#58
post #39
post #12

In France, G and J have the opposite sound: J sounds like G, and G like J. Makes sense? ;-) As such, everybody pronounces it "JIF" here. And it seems to go in the author's direction, so it's fine.

I'm French and I never heard someone pronouncing it "JIF".

Well then I guess even us do have different pronunciations. I'm from Lyon and everyone I know, be it friends, family or colleagues, say "jee-f".

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#59
post #32

There are a lot of examples in linguistics where the "correct" pronunciation of a word is not the common pronunciation, and so the common pronunciation becomes the correct one. I've heard maybe one in every twenty people pronunce it as "jif", and when they do so it's not because it seems like it's the natural pronunciation, it's because they once read it was the correct was to pronounce it and want to hammer that fac…

I mean, I can only speak from personal experience, but I always call gif, jif, and it has nothing to do with whether its correct pronunciation or not. I just read it like that and could care less about the facts

> could care less

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=om7O0MFkmpw

Re: Poll: "Giff" or "Jif"?

#60

I'm only 23 years old, and I hail from the East Coast of Canada. I've never heard anyone pronounce it "Jif", but I had read on reddit that some people have had the opposite experience, never hearing the "Giff" pronunciation.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN