Live data from Hacker News

Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

github.com

361–370 of 390 posts

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#361

Am i the only one that finds System Information: Hardware specs, OS details, architecture Usage Patterns: Active time, session duration, feature usage Performance Metrics: Response times, resource consumption Unique Identifiers: Machine ID, user ID, device fingerprints Workspace Details: Project information, file paths (obfuscated) Not to really bad that obtrusive? Like i don't really see anything there that i'd be o…

Honestly, I found this whole thread kind of strange. There’s nothing here beyond what most connected IDEs — or even basic office software — already collect by default.

It feels like the goal was more about grabbing attention than raising a real issue. But sure, toss “ByteDance” and “data” into a headline and suddenly it’s breaking news. I'm just tired of this kind of "Big News"- it's boring.

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#362
Any proof of them not letting you speak because you mentioned “tracking”? This is weird.

I’m in Trae’s Discord (recently decided to try their Pro) and don’t see any regulation. There are multiple users discussing about privacy mode or tos but didn’t see any pushback.

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#363

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, why do people use products from Microsoft, Apple, Google, Amazon, ...

If we are talking about telemetry…. Seriously all these products are sending telemetry data

And the Snowden revelations happened, which programmers and sysadmins and etc saw, and then... continued as before, in the large majority of cases. It'd be baffling, if it wasn't so easily explained by the usual mixture of self-interest and moral cowardice.

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#364
Telemetry isn't the same thing as spying on user data. You should read below if you are not clear about the differences:

What is telemetry data?

Telemetry is anonymous, aggregated usage data that helps developers understand how a product is being used. It usually includes stuff like: - What features are being used (e.g. “X% of users use the terminal panel daily”) - How often the app crashes, and where - Performance stats (e.g. memory usage, load times) - Environment info (like OS version, screen resolution — not personal files)

It does NOT include your source code, files, passwords, browser content, or any personal identifiers unless explicitly stated. And in most reputable products, it’s either anonymized or pseudonymized by default.

Who uses telemetry? Everyone. - VS Code collects telemetry to improve editor performance and user experience. For products that are vscode fork, they inherit the vscode telemetry switch by default. - Chrome uses telemetry to understand browser performance, crashes, and feature adoption, -Slack, Discord, Postman all rely on telemetry to debug, prioritize features, and improve product quality

Without telemetry, you can’t know which features are working, where users are getting stuck and what’s actually causing bugs.

So when people say “telemetry = privacy breach,” they’re confusing helpful system analytics with data exploitation. The real concern should be around what is collected, how it’s stored, and whether users can opt out — not the mere existence of telemetry data itself. Telemetry data itself doesn’t directly cause high CPU usage. CPU hog could cause by a lot of different reasons.

Sharing here just because some reasonings and arguments in the original post seems off. Don’t want people to get confused

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#365

Telemetry isn't the same thing as spying on user data. You should read below if you are not clear about the differences: What is telemetry data? Telemetry is anonymous, aggregated usage data that helps developers understand how a product is being used. It usually includes stuff like: - What features are being used (e.g. “X% of users use the terminal panel daily”) - How often the app crashes, and where - Performance s…

telemetry is not your source code.

It doesn’t include: - Your code files - What you’re writing - proprietary IP - Passwords, tokens, env vars - Anything personally identifiable

Instead, telemetry usually looks like “User clicked on send button” or “App crashed with error XYZ on macOS 14.1”

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#366

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> (usually anonymized) telemetry data. Anonymization is usually a lie: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20513521 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21428449 Also please stop with security/privacy nihilism, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27897975

It's not nihilism. I still ad block, use an RFID wallet, and don't install any apps on my phone, I rarely use google for anything. But at some point when something is so ridiculously useful and the data they're getting doesn't really mean much of anything I have to stop caring. I use Windows 11 (gross) because it lets me play video games with my friends I can't otherwise. I use Uber because it lets me get across town…

> and don't install any apps on my phone, I rarely use google for anything

And yet you are fine with personalized telemetry from Google on your PC? This is self-contradictory.

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#367

It’s honestly kind of funny — you got timed out by Discord’s automod and now you’re running around calling it “suppression of technical discussion.” lol. Don't be dramatic. There's a wave of crypto spam before, so the automod timeout often catches lots of bots and people. I remember even community mods have been timed out before.

really? I saw him added later today that he was muted by AutoMod. Wondering if the whole “censorship” thing is true

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#368

Is it just me or does the formatting of this feel like ChatGPT (numbered lists, "Key Takeaways", and just the general phrasing of things)? It's not necessarily an issue if you checked over it properly but if you did use it then it might be good to mention that for transparency, because people can tell anyway and it might feel slightly otherwise (or maybe you just have a similar writing style)

who care? its like using a spell checker. why does it matter?

yeah man, next time VSCode crashes and recovers your unsaved work, just remember: it knows way too much about you.

this kind of overreaction is exactly why real privacy concerns get ignored. it misses the point and just ends up misleading devs who actually care about meaningful issues.

Re: Performance and telemetry analysis of Trae IDE, ByteDance's VSCode fork

#369
you updated the GitHub repo multiple times, and from the looks of it, that so-called “official censorship” was actually just an automod mute. tying that to telemetry feels like you’re trying to stitch a story together just to sell a narrative
Post reply on HN