Live data from Hacker News

Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

nytimes.com

321–330 of 350 posts

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#321

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's unfortunate that all of this got politicized, but the fact is that nobody knows for sure where it came from nor does anyone know for sure where it didn't come from. I would say it's not a waste of time to review what labs are doing all over the world since the stakes are so high.

Everything in modern society is scientist-caused if you go deep enough.

Well, until you hit the philosopher layer.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#322
post #75

It’s also possible there is viable smallpox frozen in permafrost which is increasingly thawing recently. It would take an unlikely chain of events for it to reestablish itself from that starting point, but it’s possible.

Is that actually possible? Labs have to prepare biological samples before freezing them. Otherwise, ice crystals will destroy any cells or viruses that they are trying to preserve.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#323
post #250

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't we have vaccines? I mean sure an outbreak would be pretty horrific. But once the pictures start circulating, I suspect vaccine hesitation would evaporate pretty quickly. Yes, yes, we should go far to avoid an outbreak, but would it really be so world ending? Wouldn't we just contain it, vaccinate widely and be done with it?

I'd maybe buy this comment a few years ago. We are barely able to vaccinate against a global pandemic as it is. Our society would honestly probably crumble if you brought in a really deadly virus like smallpox to the fold.

Smallpox is actually dangerous, and the smallpox vaccine is like 200 years old. Not even 1% of people would refuse that vaccine in that scenario.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#324
post #285

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Given the risk of myocarditis and other things against the low risk of my demographic with COVID, I'd rather not take the drug with no long term studies.

Regarding myocarditis from the Moderna vaccine: "For instance, Israel reported So that's a 0.003% and 0.0008% rate, respectively. And you have a 0.15% chance of getting myocarditis from COVID-19 itself. https://www.news-medical.net/news/20211116/Myocarditis-among... https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7035e5.htm

Why do you trust these numbers? There are (in all logical likelihood) far more instances of myocarditis than are reported, as well as far more instances of covid than reported. This immediately makes the death rate of covid go down and the rate of myocarditis go up by some unknown factor that nobody can possibly know. A fit, healthy young male has no reason to be vaccinated in such a situation.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#325
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought that too. But then I use vintage lab glassware labeled Hydrochloric Acid and Potassium Hydroxide for oil & vinegar containers.

Let's hope nobody has a similar sense of humor and replaces the contents with that which it says on the label.

Yeah that would be unfortunate if someone ordered dangerous chemicals, snuck them into your kitchen, and furtively replaced the contents of bottles in your pantry with those chemicals. If only you didn't use those joke labels. What are you even saying?

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#326
post #183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That was the 80’s and 90’s ‘wake up in a cold sweat’ nightmare, when one wasn’t having it about nukes, the Cold War, and MAD anyway. One can hope that anyone with the resources and intelligence to pull that off, would 1) have something better and more useful to do with their lives, and 2) would have someone they care about somewhere and realize it would almost certainly blow back on them too. Definitely not guarantee…

The scarier thought is some kind of gene-targeted virus that avoids the blowback

I don’t think that people understand how relatively practical this is, and it wouldn’t even have to be a dramatically or overtly “bad” virus to have very useful economic effects. Just a virus that dramatically increases the chance of cancer, or screws with nuerons low key causing early onset dementia after years, or whatever.

The incentives that support this type of research will be (or are) too high to ignore.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm having trouble getting good stats on it, but it looks like there were a handful of deaths -- maybe, single or low double digits -- that could be directly attributed to the COVID vaccine. The smallpox vaccine, if we had to vaccinate the whole country, could cause some deaths too. This pretty old paper estimates somewhere ~200, I've seen an estimate elsewhere of around ~500, can't get a good source on the second on…

How many deaths would we expect from the injection of a billion “doses” of injected saline solution? I don’t know that that number is zero.

I'm not sure, actually. I wasn't able to find any information on the safety of a single dose of saline solution. There is apparently a health risk from being on saline solution for a long time (I guess it hurts your kidneys and some other stuff). Stories about this swamped stories about the fundamental safety of a small amount.

These vaccines do of course have some (rare! and way less bad than getting sick!) side effects. So I'd suspect a saline shot to be less dangerous. But that's a guess.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd maybe buy this comment a few years ago. We are barely able to vaccinate against a global pandemic as it is. Our society would honestly probably crumble if you brought in a really deadly virus like smallpox to the fold.

Smallpox is actually dangerous, and the smallpox vaccine is like 200 years old. Not even 1% of people would refuse that vaccine in that scenario.

Once again, two years ago I would have believed it. But considering a sizeable amount of people think that the Covid vaccine "allows governments to track you", "has 5G" or whatever other nonsense has permeated that discourse, I'm not as confident.

Especially if it happened right now with all the controversy around the Covid vaccine, it'd surely be spun as the Covid vaccine in disguise, or the government forcing its way into tracking us all with nanotechnology.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#329

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd maybe buy this comment a few years ago. We are barely able to vaccinate against a global pandemic as it is. Our society would honestly probably crumble if you brought in a really deadly virus like smallpox to the fold.

There are many people who don't make their vaccination decisions out of a mystic adherence to the very concept of a vaccine, but based on what they perceive to be a cost-benefit analysis (with the level of rigor varying wildly, naturally). Unlike covid, there's no large cohort of the population for which smallpox is a fairly negligible personal risk, and smallpox outbreaks provide much more dramatic and visceral evid…

Highly disagree. Most people make their vaccination decisions, like most other decisions, based on highly biased information that they have obtained from others around them. There is little "cost-benefit" analysis being done when you aren't actually comparing the real costs and benefits, but rather an extremely skewed interpretation you hear from the bubble you're in.

Given that, regardless of the actual risk or visceral evidence provided, almost anything can be spun as a positive or negative with enough determination, and on the heels of a major anti-vax campaign with Covid, there would be sure to be major overlap between the two were a smallpox outbreak to occur right now.

The first vaccine hesitancy campaign literally was against the smallpox vaccine in Stockholm, so I don't see how you could say that there would be no hesitancy to it. History has already shown that to not be the case over and over again.

Re: Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania laboratory

#330

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's hope nobody has a similar sense of humor and replaces the contents with that which it says on the label.

Yeah that would be unfortunate if someone ordered dangerous chemicals, snuck them into your kitchen, and furtively replaced the contents of bottles in your pantry with those chemicals. If only you didn't use those joke labels. What are you even saying?

I'm probably saying that you don't have a sense of humor.
Post reply on HN