Live data from Hacker News

Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

atlassian.com

231–240 of 305 posts

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#231
post #200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry to hear it's been a frustrating experience. I'm a PM for Confluence Cloud and we're always trying to make it better. Would you be willing to share more specifics, such as: - Pages with content X are the slowest - Trying to do A/B/C is annoyingly slow - etc ?

Surely you have metrics?

If your avarage is always 10 seconds, 7 is fast!

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#232
post #207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. this is a jump-the-shark move. I've worked with confluence and jira and they are not as good as other products - but we can put any kind of confidential data in them. Everybody likes sharepoint/google docs/slack way better.

Sharepoint?

ok i take that one back personally, but somehow microsoft stuff keeps getting chosen by the decision makers.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#233
post #222
post #207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. this is a jump-the-shark move. I've worked with confluence and jira and they are not as good as other products - but we can put any kind of confidential data in them. Everybody likes sharepoint/google docs/slack way better.

I feel like SharePoint and Google Docs are fundamentally different products that Confluence. Looking for a Confluence competitor with permissions, version tracking, templates, and search but don't feel like I have found a good alternative.

I don't think we use version tracking, templates are not really used (but they should be!) and search could be better.

We basically use confluence like a wiki, but it's abnormally hard to put info into it.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#234
post #86
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

TFS is the self-hosted predecessor to Azure DevOps and it absolutely sucks compared to JIRA.

>"absolutely sucks compared to JIRA" Congratulations, according to Google you are the first person on the internet ever to use that phrase. Indeed only the second ever to string the last four of those words together.

This quote from Bjarne Stroustroup is very relevant:

> There are two kinds of programming languages: the ones people complain about and the ones nobody uses.

JIRA is the C++ of project management software. It works. It has worked forever. It is easy to shoot yourself in the foot but a savvy operator can't be beat. It's unwieldy at first but gives you all the power to build a really sophisticated and efficient process.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#235

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People are spoiled. JIRA sucks, but it sucks compared to more lightweight tools and the modern aesthetic It outperforms previous tracking tools like bugzilla, trac, or those proprietary piles of crap like the "Rational" tools

Can you give me some examples of tools that are better? Genuinely curious. I've used JIRA at multiple workplaces and really enjoy it. I like Github issues and Trello for my personal task/issue tracking but I don't think they're suitable for more complex projects.

I don't think it's possible to say that one project management project is universally better than anything else. What a team needs out of project management tools varies immensely.

In this thread there's people saying that inability to host on prem is an absolute blocker for them, for others they have zero problems with their data being SaaS-hosted. Some people need deep analytics to measure how their team is doing and they can meet deliverables, and some people could care less. Some people have 10+ workflow stages with tons of rules, some people are fine with Todo / in progress / done.

If you have a small team and dont really care about reporting, Trello is probably a great option for you.

If you want reporting, but are willing to work with a somewhat prescribed workflow / process, across a few teams at most, clubhouse or pivotal tracker are great.

If you need full control and flexibility, and are willing to give up some ease of use and speed, JIRA probably is your best bet.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#236
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How can you be worse than JIRA? Thats almost impressive.

My understanding of Jira is that it by itself does not suck but it bends over backwards for asinine “business processes” so it is difficult to find an implementation in the wild that does not suck.

JIRA is essentially a platform. It is unopinionated and infinitely configurable. This leaves it open to abuse and many orgs will absolutely abuse it. Other products that are popular do very little by comparison. That lets them build a really tight and simple UI but any org with more than vanilla requirements will hit a wall.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#237

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How can you be worse than JIRA? Thats almost impressive.

What's wrong with JIRA? If it is about the usage of it within some orgs, I don't know if it is the tool or culture. I have seen some people fawning over tools like Asana but in my usage I just found it fancier and slower than Jira. Personally, as a developer I find GitHub issues to be good enough.

Man Asana is a real mystery. It has fewer features and worse UX than JIRA. I constantly have trouble clicking on the right thing or having some auto action just do something unexpected. It's coasting on having a nice stylesheet.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#238
I get the benefits of SaaS. I get the benefits of hosting things in your own infra.

Why can’t Atlassian licence their private docker images and allow companies to host things in their private cloud?

Like why isn’t paying for docker images with k8s yaml files that you can host on your own cluster a thing ?

I would pay for that.

Re: Atlassian moving to cloud-only, will stop selling server licenses

#240
post #84
post #23

What are their biggest products?

Jira is amongst the most popular workflow / ticketing systems. Probably number one. Bitbucket is top 3 git hosts. Confluence is one of the best wiki/knowledge base products. They also have some other products I’m less familiar with... but they are pretty big.

I knew the company was big, but I was specifically curious about their most successful / popular products.
Post reply on HN