Live data from Hacker News

Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

gingerlime.com

151–160 of 258 posts

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#151

This is just fraud. "Friendly fraud" is accidental or with the correct intentions – such as the customer not recognising the charge and charging back.

Yes, and Stripe could do much better to prevent it. And doesn't.

They could, but this isn't discussed in the blog post. The post is about literal fraud, which has a very different recourse for the merchant.

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I suspect they were saying something carefully noncommittal and legally compliant to get you to go away If their total dismissal of the problem is itself deception, that's not a particularly big improvement!

The problem is that, as patio11 once described in detail ( https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/optimal-amount-of-fra... ), there are genuine tradeoffs here that people get outraged by the mention of. How many legitimate sales should Stripe block in order to more effectively fight this kind of fraud? Merchants don't want to hear it, and consumers don't either. So financial companies invariably conclude that it's be…

That's a reasonable argument for general money processing, but it's far weaker when you sell an anti-fraud product and try to get every transaction to give you a cut to use it.

And if they had even a little skin in the game they would care about such low-hanging fruit. You don't want a guy that's insulated from the consequences to be in charge of the [anti-]fraud dial.

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stripe did the right thing here. They cannot be arbitrators of every little edge cases that comes up. That's not their role. Also I just wanna throw some praise at Stripe Support. They have an excellent team and go above and beyond to help.

Agree on Stripe support. They're excellent. I don't think Stripe did the right thing here. They can do better to protect their own customers.

stripe serves both sides of the transactions they process, seller and buyer.

if buyers were to perceive stripe as being dificult, they might churn. i certainly do this on paypal pages.

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#154
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've got 13 chargebacks over the last 4 years for my biz. Out of these, 10 came from US based cards. The other 3 came from Australia(my country). Be careful when taking verbatim advice from internet strangers.

+1 almost all from the US. The strongest signal is whether they use an eBank/app that has a one-click button to report transactions as fraudulent. The Apple card(?) seems especially prevalent.

U.S. chargeback rules are different. In other countries, you cannot repudiate credit card transactions that you authorized (and this applies to Mastercard/Visa, too). You need to do something else if you end up in a dispute with the merchant.

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#155

Then what are the better alternatives?

Monero or honestly any crypto. There's no chargebacks and it can be more private.

In fact it can be so private you'll never know who the merchant who didn't send you the product is.

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#157
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, and Stripe could do much better to prevent it. And doesn't.

What would you like them to do? Even in the post you're wishy washy about what you want. They offer a product that does enhanced fraud detection but you don't like that. You correctly call out that there's major risks with taking a merchant's report and using it to flag a user's future transactions.

The article mentions Stripe's product in this space: https://stripe.com/en-us/radar

There are similar offerings from other companies. I don't know if bundling this with payment processing is common.

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#158
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

+1 almost all from the US. The strongest signal is whether they use an eBank/app that has a one-click button to report transactions as fraudulent. The Apple card(?) seems especially prevalent.

I had a friend with the apple card, and there were fraudulent charges on her card before she even used it. I think that caused her to over-scrutinize things. But (years) later I saw her using apple pay. She had charges she didn't recognize and would immediately flag them. Thing is, I couldn't help but think they might have been real charges with weirdly named companies on the transaction.

> She had charges she didn't recognize and would immediately flag them. Thing is, I couldn't help but think they might have been real charges with weirdly named companies on the transaction.

That's completely the companies fault. If you give a transaction a reference that the customer will not recognise, that's on you!

Re: Stripe is friendly to “friendly fraud”

#159
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I'm not going to name those countries outright Why?

I would assume it’s not that relevant to the advice. And people will always argue about the countries if you list them. X isn’t bad. You should include Y. You only added/omitted Z because of $stereotype/$racistView/$otherAllegation. Probably just not worth the hassle.

[flagged]
Post reply on HN