Live data from Hacker News

Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

old.reddit.com

151–160 of 181 posts

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#151
post #146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What argument in response to "Moderators absolutely can moderate without the API." are you making here?

Of what purpose would getting into an argument serve? I ask, why would a mod care if someone else posts something illegal to a forum they don't own?

That is a great question, but not what is being discussed in this thread

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#152
post #148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you seriously expect that when June 30th rolls around, basically all major subs are going to be flooded with CP and moderators across the site will be overwhelmed, plunging everything into chaos? That's an amazing prediction - guess we'll see how it plays out.

I wonder whether Reddit C-suite are thinking exactly like this and that's what's causing these misguided decisions.

I mean, if moderating is going to become literally impossible than the moderators should provide more sober, detailed arguments for why this is the case. As far as I'm aware this just hasn't been done. It's just "we have these tools we like and we don't want to lose them", which is a far weaker argument. If there's a serious rationale for why moderating will suddenly require 10x the effort or whatever as before, I'd love to see it.

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#153

I have no clue what moderates really do and I have not seen any difference yet on reddit.

What is so insidious about moderation is you could have a moderator removing posts for whatever reason they like and you will simply never see that content or even be aware it was removed. I’d love dual versions of subs - moderated and unmoderated so these people could be regularly audited.

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#154
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Of what purpose would getting into an argument serve? I ask, why would a mod care if someone else posts something illegal to a forum they don't own?

That is a great question, but not what is being discussed in this thread

It is what is being dicussed in this thread branch, stemming from a statement made closer to the root, contextually identified in earlier supplied quote. You don't have to participate in the topic if is not of interest to you, but given that you have shown interest in that topic by replying multiple times now, let's hear what you've got. Or not. Nobody cares. The comment was never for or about you. If you disappear we'll never notice.

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was banned from /r/police for mentioning Philip Brailsford, a cop and murderer that gets a lifetime disability pension for PTSD from executing someone on their knees in a local hotel’s hallway. I guess they probably hated my speech.

I was banned at r/beer because I critize Bud Light marketing, also the mod told me he did not like my Reddit Avatar.

>ciriticize bud light marketing

Lol Yeah, I'm sure THAT'S what you were banned for. What particular aspect of their marketing did you take issue with? Maybe you let slip some of your obvious-to-everyone prejudice in your "criticism".

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#156
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is a great question, but not what is being discussed in this thread

It is what is being dicussed in this thread branch, stemming from a statement made closer to the root, contextually identified in earlier supplied quote. You don't have to participate in the topic if is not of interest to you, but given that you have shown interest in that topic by replying multiple times now, let's hear what you've got. Or not. Nobody cares. The comment was never for or about you. If you disappear w…

You've lost me pal. The discussion was about whether or not subs can be moderated without API access.

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#157
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps I am missing some nuance, but that still seems like "some laughs" and, more importantly, not done in good faith. I get that they weren't audibly laughing, but it seems they were stroking some kind of emotional pleasure centre, choosing bad faith to feel it.

I can't really speak for the motivations of those people, but I don't consider potential direct financial gain to be "some laughs".

The words we typically use are "malfeasance," "corruption," and "conflict of interest."

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#158
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is what is being dicussed in this thread branch, stemming from a statement made closer to the root, contextually identified in earlier supplied quote. You don't have to participate in the topic if is not of interest to you, but given that you have shown interest in that topic by replying multiple times now, let's hear what you've got. Or not. Nobody cares. The comment was never for or about you. If you disappear w…

You've lost me pal. The discussion was about whether or not subs can be moderated without API access.

What do you hope is gained from this information? The comment was never directed at you, so any difficulty you are having in understanding it is of little consequence.

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#159
post #52
post #5

It's interesting seeing this situation play out across different subreddits. There seems to be 2 kinds of subreddits - the "category" kind (simple, descriptive name) and the "community" kind (have a defined purpose, could exist under a whole range of names) The moderators of all of them see themselves as somehow owning the community, but I think that's less clear to the users. To most users, r/Celebrities is a catego…

reddit has some of the worst mods I’ve ever seen in any capacity. And they’re frequently in control of massive subreddits. I remember when hate speech was just discovered as a reason to ban people, and mods of major subreddits would find ways to use that either out of protest or complete incompetence to ban people. For example, banning users for disagreeing with a controversial decision because “I hate your take, thu…

I was just thinking about this today. This is how we can measure how exceptionally bad spez's handling has been: people are sympathizing with Reddit mods. Reddit mods have been almost universally despised for as long as I can remember.

Re: Removed as moderator of /r/Celebrities after over 14 years

#160
post #52
post #5

It's interesting seeing this situation play out across different subreddits. There seems to be 2 kinds of subreddits - the "category" kind (simple, descriptive name) and the "community" kind (have a defined purpose, could exist under a whole range of names) The moderators of all of them see themselves as somehow owning the community, but I think that's less clear to the users. To most users, r/Celebrities is a catego…

reddit has some of the worst mods I’ve ever seen in any capacity. And they’re frequently in control of massive subreddits. I remember when hate speech was just discovered as a reason to ban people, and mods of major subreddits would find ways to use that either out of protest or complete incompetence to ban people. For example, banning users for disagreeing with a controversial decision because “I hate your take, thu…

I was a mod on a couple of subreddits that have more than a million subscribers. It's a thankless task. Most mods I've interacted with are absolutely fantastic, spending their free time volunteering for the community and genuinely making the community better. Filtering out spam, harassment is a daily, endless task. The only time people talk about the moderators is when something goes wrong.

The main reason I stopped doing it is because it was just too much work and having the community mainly shit on you doesn't make it more enticing to continue. Everyone assumes the worst about you, how you're somehow in it for the wrong reasons, when for 99% of mods I've interacted with that definitely wasn't the case.

Post reply on HN