Live data from Hacker News

Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

gpdp.it

151–160 of 614 posts

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is just naive. Government offices/agencies are so tightly coupled with packages like office 365 that forcefully separating them would require home built solutions which would always be terrible, less secure, and more expensive to the tax payer. There’s a lot of good these products can provide, granted they are properly audited and have high security requirements.

ah, the ad hominem , never a good sign for the proceeding argument. there are a number of other office suites that are entirely adequate for bureaucratic organizations to build methodical processes around (which is what bureaucracies do). the capabilities of the underlying tools don’t matter much in this regard. also, audits aren’t meant to prove anything (like security), but instead to shift liability.

> ah, the ad hominem, never a good sign for the proceeding argument.

GP never says that you’re naive, but the comment was.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does your small blog need an "analytics solution" in the first place, if you earn $0?

Because I want to know where my readers come from, which Google terms they searched, etc.? There's a million reasons to want to know stats like this without earning money...

As a user, I don't want to give this info. I'm glad the EU is giving folks an avenue to express this preference.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#153

Good. US citizens should be, at least, disappointed that their government is so bad at protecting their privacy, that US law is so far behind the times. To those companies and people who find these EU decisions baffling or inconvenient: tough. If you had had respect for your users this would not be an issue. You would already not be spying on them. To website visitors: if you see a cookie banner, the site is asking p…

Well I’m not an expert but I think the main issue is that American citizens have protections that non-Americans do not. The government cannot spy on Americans without a court order.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is that not fully legal? Wouldn't the same law prevent Google USA from querying PII data from Google Italia?

Italian laws do not apply to Google USA.

Not generally, but they do apply to Google Italia, who would not legally be allowed to respond to requests from Google USA for European PII.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#155

i’d support any legislation that booted google, fb, ms, adobe, salesforce, and a whole host of other surveillance tech companies from any and all levels of government. it’s literally as important as the separation of church and state. in fact, i’d love to see a constitutional amendment explicitly separating corporate interests from governmental ones, in all facets of civic life (e.g., campaign finance).

How far does "separating corporate interests from governmental ones" go?

Can the government purchase a car? Hire a private corporation to build a road? Hire a consulting company to check the security of their (now-free-and-without-a-support-contract FOSS?) computer setup?

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because I want to know where my readers come from, which Google terms they searched, etc.? There's a million reasons to want to know stats like this without earning money...

As a user, I don't want to give this info. I'm glad the EU is giving folks an avenue to express this preference.

I provide free tutorials and articles like this. If you don't want to provide this info then I don't want to provide you free content.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#157

Good. US citizens should be, at least, disappointed that their government is so bad at protecting their privacy, that US law is so far behind the times. To those companies and people who find these EU decisions baffling or inconvenient: tough. If you had had respect for your users this would not be an issue. You would already not be spying on them. To website visitors: if you see a cookie banner, the site is asking p…

Well I’m not an expert but I think the main issue is that American citizens have protections that non-Americans do not. The government cannot spy on Americans without a court order.

The word "spy" is so loose these days. I'd consider the vast swaths of metadata other companies compile on me "spying" to an extent.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#158
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

America is the LTS branch of Democracy.

If a modern democracy requires an ever-growing government I think I will stick to Democracy Stable.

Here in NH we have a group of people trying to compile their own. I never thought of them as distro hipsters, but it tracks.

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#159

Good. US citizens should be, at least, disappointed that their government is so bad at protecting their privacy, that US law is so far behind the times. To those companies and people who find these EU decisions baffling or inconvenient: tough. If you had had respect for your users this would not be an issue. You would already not be spying on them. To website visitors: if you see a cookie banner, the site is asking p…

> To website visitors: if you see a cookie banner, the site is asking permission to spy on you. Or you know...count how many unique visitors they have and how to make the site more useful. Do you avoid using cookies on this site but still manage to log in?

[deleted]

Re: Italian watchdog bans use of Google Analytics

#160

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That’s a very common implementation of serverside GTM/GA in the EU. If you advertise, you’ll still be sending GCLIDs, though.

If only ad clicks send back tracking parameters (and nothing else) it might actually fall into legitimate interest.

The current issue isn't the lawful basis for the processing, as compliant companies already only use Google Analytics once they have consent. The issue is that without an adequacy decision from the EU to allow data transfers to the US, and with the global reach of US authorities thanks to the CLOUD Act, there's no way to keep personal data safe from US law enforcement.
Post reply on HN