Live data from Hacker News

Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

reddit.com

171–180 of 632 posts

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#171

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Think it's a coincidence that now the legal case is pretty much over there are suddenly a lot of 'adjustments' being made?

More likely investors are getting restless and want to see some return. In these cases management feels it needs to have things under its control and starts removing power bases from lower down the org chart so that everything stays on message. AMA is Reddit's only viable asset so having it under control of someone who isn't part of the management clique is unthinkable. Usually these attempts fail and the company is…

I agree.

However a counter-point is that its quite possible that they are trying to pivot reddit into a mainstream site, and thus are more than willing to burn most of the current user base.

They don't need/want hard-hitting questions during AMA's, nor do they want freaky fetish subreddits, nor long winded post describing the intricacies of the Federal Reserve.

They want cat pictures, pictures of freshly baked cakes, celebrity soundbites, and lots of comments that go "that cake looks delish!" and "Love you Miley!"

In short, an internet version of "The View".

Regardless, I think it will fail, if thats even the case. However, ideas such as these are the exact type that tone-deaf MBA types think up lots of times.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#172
post #57

Aaand this is how Reddit does. Because this is basically how Digg died and created Reddit. Who out there has a reddit clone ready to take up the torch? Communities are fickle, and if you fuck with them they will abandon you quickly and en masse.

http://voat.co

[deleted]

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#173
wow what's crazy to me is that I was on reddit today, but didn't know about this till I saw this thread.

And even after going back to reddit I couldn't see any information on this until I cilcked /r/all.. looks like reddit censorship scandal is going out of hand :/

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#174
post #69
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Felt I should share this. There are a number of really good established alternatives with great mods and admins for those who wish to branch out and check out something new: www.snapzu.com - Excellent content and friendly community. Has a unique XP/Leveling system and ability to post content into multiple subs. www.empeopled.com - Gives you more influence based on the amount of up-votes you've received. Use influence…

Reddit still has those subs about beating women and lynching black people, right? Get over yourself, voat is better than every single example you listed.

I have yet to even see what Voat looks like because every time there's a Reddit event and someone mentions it, Voat is completely unresponsive.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#175
I have heard a lot of people here and in reddit say, "well we should just make something better and leave!" Maybe a lot of that talk is just anger or discontent coming out right now. The community is up in arms. The moderators are frustrated at both corporate reddit and the website/tools available to them. Users are mortified. But in all seriousness, I want to explore the question, why don't we? What is stopping us from replacing it?

-- Technical challenges? No that doesn't seem right. Many of us build and scale applications far larger than this. The tools and technology are there.

-- Building a community is hard? This seems more in line with reality. Building another community like this is high risk and low reward maybe?

-- Sites like this aren't the solution any more? This could be it. But if this isn't the solution, what is?

I haven't thought of all possibilities. But really, why not just replace it?

*edit: fixed typos, typing on phones is hard.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#176
post #45
post #39

People don't give a shit about 'reddit' as a thing, what they care about is the content people submit and the subreddits that foster the communities. They seem to be going through their own Digg v4 moment here, completely disregarding users because they think they're big enough to survive without them.

Felt I should share this. There are a number of really good established alternatives with great mods and admins for those who wish to branch out and check out something new: www.snapzu.com - Excellent content and friendly community. Has a unique XP/Leveling system and ability to post content into multiple subs. www.empeopled.com - Gives you more influence based on the amount of up-votes you've received. Use influence…

I really like the design on Hubski. I'll have to try that out.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#177
This is the exact reason why we started PushdUp. As a long time reddit user I was getting sick of the drama that was happening and decided to take it upon myself to create something different. We are still in VERY early alpha so there are bound to be some bugs. Come join the revolution. http://www.pushdup.com , feedback is welcome and encouraged.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#178
post #17

What a circus reddit has become. There's probably/hopefully more to this story but still. It will be interesting to see if reddit forces the hands of the biggest subreddits to open again. Which raises an interesting question, who "owns" a subreddit, the mods? the subscribers? reddit? I also wonder if it's a good idea for a community like reddit to have "public facing" administrators Many of the biggest subreddits are…

I'm actually surprised that reddit allows default subreddits to go private or disable themselves in any way. Each community should absolutely be able to moderate themselves, but at the same time being a default subreddit carries extra responsibilities.

This is an edge case that probably nobody thought about until today. I imagine the ability to take a default sub private will not last through tomorrow.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#179
post #145
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

im not sure if it matters what happened in the past per se... its the amount, the type, etc.: once something start to be massively as "bad" and the content is generated by those users seeing it as "bad" it just stops being what it was. It's like saying Firefox or IE aren't good browser. IE is a pretty good browser nowaday, but that's an unpopular opinion. It feels like reddit is going to reach this point now...

For years all it would've taken is a solid competitor with good technology and management and Reddit is gone. Right now Reddit's really the only game in town. If someone were to come along with technology that wouldn't regularly crash and tools to help the moderators moderate and allow the community managers to quickly and effectively respond to problems; and a solid management team to be proactive and keep improving…

Who wants to tackle this with me? Contact info in profile.

Re: Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin

#180

I'm going to offer a wild suggestion - What if reddit is being purposefully dismantled to break up the social hive it represents? Is it possible that current events are he fruition of a purposeful strategy?

If that is what is happening, is that what the owners want? Or is that what leadership wants? The leadership has very little money sunk into reedit, but the owners have a lot more.

I'm sure leadership is willing to gamble that they can disrupt the hive without killing it. But will the owners continue to go down that road?

Post reply on HN