Live data from Hacker News

SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

spacex.com

31–40 of 132 posts

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#31
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are right next to Hawthorne Airport... that's the only place I can see the track being located. The rest of the surroundings are industrial buildings.

Aren't these meant to be underground?

Nope. Above ground, with solar panels on top.

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

After Elon said "fuck it" and built his own rocket motors after getting screwed by the Russians, I don't see him wasting any time with politics or property development (who I'd argue would be leeches/vultures trying to extract their tax on the project). He's just commission 2-4 TBMs (tunnel boring machines, about ~$20MM/each), drop them in the ground, and have them start digging hyperloop tunnels.

You're off by an order of magnitude on the cost of a TBM.

"The machine is a remarkable and unique piece of equipment. Purpose-built for Crossrail by German firm Herrenknecht – one of a handful of TBM manufacturers in the world – it cost around £10m ($15m), weighs close to 1,000 tonnes, has an external diameter of 7.1 metres (23ft) and from cutting-face-to-end stretches 150m (500ft)."

http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20150602-crossrail-the-monst...

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#35
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Elon Musk doesn't have the time to learn civil engineering, property development, let alone the politics surrounding it.

After Elon said "fuck it" and built his own rocket motors after getting screwed by the Russians, I don't see him wasting any time with politics or property development (who I'd argue would be leeches/vultures trying to extract their tax on the project). He's just commission 2-4 TBMs (tunnel boring machines, about ~$20MM/each), drop them in the ground, and have them start digging hyperloop tunnels.

Hyperloop tubes are elevated, not buried underground.

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#37
post #12
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree SpaceX recusing itself from winning its own competition is the right thing, but the bit I found interesting was just that they were building a pod as well as the track, putting even more skin in the metaphorical game. I've had projects before where I came up with an interesting idea but dismissed it as too costly (in time or money or what have you), but it stuck in my head. So then, well maybe I'll just do a…

Elon Musk doesn't have the time to learn civil engineering, property development, let alone the politics surrounding it.

I am pretty sure you were joking, but just in case ... Elon already sat down and decided to learn enough rocket science to found SpaceX, and enough engineering to found Tesla. He's learned more in his "spare time" than most of us have learned at university, and then has gone on to apply the lever of business to it.

If Elon felt that it were necessary to get his pet project done, I believe he'd make time to master civil engineering and politics to the degree that it were necessary.

Basically, he's the real Tony Stark. ;)

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#38
post #33

> Neither SpaceX nor Elon Musk is affiliated with any Hyperloop companies what does that mean? Didn't they come up with the idea of hyperloop?

For things like this, "affiliated" usually has a very precise legal definition, which means that they don't help each other with research and they're not financially invested. It means they're not cheating by entering their friends (or themselves) in the competition. Compare with the small print on most lotteries and contests, e.g. Google Code Jam:

> You cannot participate in the Contest if... you are a current employee (including intern), contractor, officer, or director, of Google or its affiliates.

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#39
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are right next to Hawthorne Airport... that's the only place I can see the track being located. The rest of the surroundings are industrial buildings.

Aren't these meant to be underground?

The costs of an underground tunnel connecting LA with SF would be prohibitive.

Re: SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition

#40
post #3

I thought this was an interesting tidbit from the linked rules pdf: > In addition to hosting the competition, SpaceX will likely build a pod for demonstration purposes only. This team will not be eligible to win.

I would imagine there are a bunch of nerds at SpaceX who would be might annoyed if they weren't allowed to participate in building something like this. Very cool of the company to make it an official thing, and to realize the issues with having their people win.
Post reply on HN