Live data from Hacker News

Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

businessinsider.com

161–168 of 168 posts

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Somehow we've gone from "Elon cares more about his business than he does about his employees - to the extreme." To: "Would it be OK to be a dick if you're curing cancer?" And when that didn't play, the argument was reframed again as: "You're harming countless strangers unless you're a dick." Twist it anyway you want, if someone wants to be a selfish dick, they should own it, not rationalize it. I'm pretty sure the co…

> If you can't prioritize (what should be) the most important of your personal relationships above what you want to do, it's unlikely that the real reason you working is because you have a surplus of love for the world. Is having a surplus of love for the world a bad thing? I believe a lot of problems would solve themselves if we have more. Also, relationships are also something you want to do, you aren't forced into…

You misread his statement. He is NOT saying that having a surplus of love for the world is bad. He IS saying that, in the scenario he describes, one likely does NOT have a surplus of love for the world. (tl;dr - it means that person is probably just being selfish and/or self-deceiving)

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Somehow we've gone from "Elon cares more about his business than he does about his employees - to the extreme." To: "Would it be OK to be a dick if you're curing cancer?" And when that didn't play, the argument was reframed again as: "You're harming countless strangers unless you're a dick." Twist it anyway you want, if someone wants to be a selfish dick, they should own it, not rationalize it. I'm pretty sure the co…

> If you can't prioritize (what should be) the most important of your personal relationships above what you want to do, it's unlikely that the real reason you working is because you have a surplus of love for the world. Is having a surplus of love for the world a bad thing? I believe a lot of problems would solve themselves if we have more. Also, relationships are also something you want to do, you aren't forced into…

> Also, relationships are also something you want to do, you aren't forced into them at gunpoint.

That's true. For example, people can choose to have a relationship with their kids, they can also abandon them. Happens all the time. :-(

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#163
post #64
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah if you can find a job that is okay with you only working 30 hours a week while paying you for 40, hang on to it and never let go.

You missed the "quality engineering work" disclaimer. Any reasonably good project manager knows that, between meetings, email, and water cooler conversation, you get about 30-32 hours of actual project work from someone each week.

30 hours sounds pretty high to me :-)

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

that diminishes my respect for Elon just a touch You are way more generous than I am.

I mean, it's one incident, at one point in time, with very little context. I'm hardly in a position to judge somebody based on that. Who here hasn't said something insensitive or less than compassionate to somebody else, at some point in time? Does that mean we're all bad people? Nah... Even though I'm totally not religious, I try to adhere somewhat to that old saw about "let ye who be free from sin throw the first s…

You changed my mind in more than one way. Thank you.

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pretty sure the ppl of Nasa/JPL who actually put a man on the moon, worked reasonable hours and almost never missed dinner with family. So, I don't think they're mutually exclusive EDIT: So, everybody was screwed then? I must have mixed anecdotes :)

"The room, the hours that we worked were incredible. I don't think anyone ever worked anything less than 10 to 12 hours each day. Saturday was a normal day of work; in fact, that's the way we felt it should be. We were given this impossible dream by President Kennedy, and we were living it. We were doing the kinds of things that engineers would kill for. And as part of this process, we'd go and open up our pay—we wer…

10 - 12 hours a day is pretty typical in the entertainment business. Most tv shows do 12s for an entire year, movies about the same for less, and VFX workers during crunch time (which is near permanent for some) 12 is usually the minimum. Plus your weekends are gone.

At least the guys in the Space Program were doing for a far more valuable reason.

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Working at Tesla is not a huge privilege. It's a job, maybe even a great one, but it doesn't make you a better person, it doesn't even guarantee that you'll be employable after working there. Having worked for a couple of very popular places, I realized pretty quickly its a job. You know what these places have in common? You're an employee, which means they can and will cut you loose when it suits them. "Reshaping th…

So, don't work there. We're talking about really smart people that can get jobs wherever else if they don't like the culture at Tesla. All the replies on my comment share the same issue that for them seeing the birth of their child is more important than being a part of Tesla. That's fine. Don't work at Tesla. That's why I wouldn't work there either. I wouldn't work in the army either, which has the same setbacks whe…

Except that nobody's arguing that you have to work at Tesla, they're pointing out that Elon Musk is a dick.

Just as people can choose who to work for, people can also choose to share information on which employer is a dick.

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, don't work there. We're talking about really smart people that can get jobs wherever else if they don't like the culture at Tesla. All the replies on my comment share the same issue that for them seeing the birth of their child is more important than being a part of Tesla. That's fine. Don't work at Tesla. That's why I wouldn't work there either. I wouldn't work in the army either, which has the same setbacks whe…

Except that nobody's arguing that you have to work at Tesla, they're pointing out that Elon Musk is a dick. Just as people can choose who to work for, people can also choose to share information on which employer is a dick.

> Just as people can choose who to work for, people can also choose to share information on which employer is a dick.

In fact, being able to the latter is an important part of making the former an informed choice.

Re: Elon Musk email to Tesla employee about missing an event to witness the birth

#168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> A dad isn't in the delivery room just to "witness" the birth, or at least he shouldn't be. But I mean, surely the "witnessing" is important on its own, no?

We went through the Lamaze classes where they tell you all the things you'll be doing to help your wife birth your first child. Then we went to the delivery room where the nurses pointed next to my wife's head and said, "you stand here" while they did all the things I thought I was supposed to do. And, honestly, I didn't mind. It was nice letting the professionals do their jobs and I could sort of be a cheerleader (b…

Dad in the room is very modern development. It seems weird and pointless to me.
Post reply on HN