Live data from Hacker News

Chile is introducing free higher education

attn.com

161–170 of 171 posts

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#161
post #47

I lived in Chile for several years. I think this is a bad idea for several reasons. First off, one of the things that makes Chile great is that its education system is independant of the government. It results in chileans who are markedly better at critical thinking than americans. (While there one of the things I did was work with high school and college students and of course got to know a lot of chileans.) Their s…

> First off, one of the things that makes Chile great is that its education system is independant of the government.

Well that would depend on the definition of great. And for me, great is not zero class mobility

> It results in chileans who are markedly better at critical thinking than americans. (While there one of the things I did was work with high school and college students and of course got to know a lot of chileans.)

Could you tell me the names of those Schools? Because in my experience, as a Chilean, that happens not to be the case.

> Their schools are all about education and keeping the people sending their kids there happy-- by educating them.

The good, more expensive schools are > "all about education and keeping the people sending their kids there happy-- by educating them."

>> There is a real effect where the person paying the bills calls the shots. When government is paying the bills, turning out good citizens is the goal. This is why the football players are the heroes of most schools and the computer nerds are beat up. This is why schools are enacting absurd zero tolerance policies. This is why standardized tests and teachers tenure and unions are so bad.

I don't really understand what you're saying here. Are you saying that when I pay for my education in a Chilean School I call the shots and I can decide how the education of my Children should be? Well, if that's the case, even for the ones paying, that's only true in a minority of higher-end private schools in Chile.

> There really is something to the market incentive to provide a better experience at lower cost...

Yeah, we have a lot of choices when it comes to education, and among them, a lot of McDonald's equivalents have appeared. I'm sorry, but get real, yeah, there's an 'opportunity for Cheap High Quality', how is the target audience going to realize what's high-quality or not, if they are already uneducated? That's why in Chile, marketing is king for this crappy private universities, they lure the big mass of uneducated with the promise of a better future. In reality, that future, is just debt.

> The socialists are in power in chile right now but I don't think that will last long, and the reality is the Chilean constitution is pretty well protecting capitalism. Consequently the government runs a surplus does a great job of providing services and mostly stays out of peoples way... and Chile is the south american economic miracle as a result.

Dicator Augusto Pinochet and their team designed the current constitution of Chile, who has so many issues that are now collapsing our society. We definitely need improvements, a lot of the Chile that you see now, with a lot of capable professionals etc, is people who got formed pre-dictatorship.

tdlr, it seems that you only just know an epsilon of Chile. Next time you're here, try to see the big picture.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#162
post #30

The Internet introduced free higher education a long time ago. ;)

Yeah, and quite a bit of opium for the uneducated mass.

You need to either be very smart or lucky to come from an uneducated background and probably also have a family that shows virtually no support to 'educate yourself' using the internet.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#163
post #140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's incredibly bad. ~40% after first semester. 60%+ will fail the first year. That first year is basically a post high-school buffer. Netherlands have a one year gap for kids to cool off and find what motivates them. France should really adopt that.

"Netherlands have a one year gap for kids to cool off and find what motivates them." What? No we don't.

He's probably confusing what he said with students taking a gap year between high school and college.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#164
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't really make sense to forbid profit in education (at least the way the Chilean government does it). The best universities in the world make a lot of money (e.g. Harvard, MIT, Stanford). Opening the educational market should create competition and drive quality up. Of course the market should be regulated, but forbidding profit is not really the way to go.

You are not very smart sir. Stanford, MIT, they re-invest their utilities in their infrastructure. And that, is allowed in Chile. You can have a private Universtiy, but to be a real Universtiy, the money should be re-invested in the institution. (That's the ideal)

Not sure how me not being smart is relevant to the discussion. I would say you are not very polite, however that still doesn't add to the discussion here.

The important thing is that even though universities are allowed to invest in infrastructure, they are not allowed to re-invest any of their donations (donations law: http://www.cned.cl/public/secciones/seccionsnac/normativa/Le...).

Top (and rich) universities, like Harvard, MIT, etc, have an endowment which invests donations (and pretty much most of their money), in companies and funds, which would not be allowed under Chilean law.

Additionally, I would argue the idea is not to re-invest in the institution, but to invest the university money in a way that is financially sustainable and in line with the university goals. Spending all the money on infrastructure might not be the best way to achieve that.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, there are several private universities in Argentina. While some of them have a very good level, some are pretty much just a means to buy a diploma. That, and especially the fact that they are much older, is why some of the public ones are much more respected (UBA - Universidad de Buenos Aires, UTN - Universidad Tecnologica Nacional - Universidad Nacional de Cordoba) than the private ones. The main problem with p…

Depends on the degree though: Medicine at UBA is a disaster, and other subjects like Accounting and Law don't have much prestige(maybe because it doesn't matter to those degrees). UBA has its own problems with budget managing, building decay and internal governability issues. Not to mention that is not only free for Argentinians, but free for anyone, which presents extra strains on its budget. Im all up for free coll…

Medicine@UBA a disaster? Are you talking seriously? Do you have arguments to say that?

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#166

"Education is a human right" No, no it isn't. Internet isn't a human right. Human Rights to not require any transaction or service. Human Rights are inherent in personhood, they are observed and respected not provided for. I have the Human Right to speak my mind, it costs you nothing. I have the Human Right to defend myself, it costs you nothing. I have the Human Right to own property, it costs you nothing. http://ww…

the UN declaration you link to reads, in part:

>Article 26.

>(1) Everyone has the right to education. Education shall be free, at least in the elementary and fundamental stages.

Rights can be whatever society agrees to

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#167
post #163
post #140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Netherlands have a one year gap for kids to cool off and find what motivates them." What? No we don't.

He's probably confusing what he said with students taking a gap year between high school and college.

But that too is a small minority. To be exact, in 2013, 9% of all first year students in tertiary education took a gap year. About 1/3rd of them traveled during that time, most of the rest had a job. And although the data doesn't explicitly say, it does seem like that includes those work for a few months between the end of the school year of high school (in May/June) and the start of the year at university, in September/October or in January, depending on the specifics. I'm not claiming they included everyone with a summer job, just that what is claimed to be a 'gap year' isn't really in many cases, but more a 'I have a few months time and I need to pay for my studies, let's make some money'. A far cry from the GP's suggestion that there is some formal structure to go soul searching or whatever.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends on the degree though: Medicine at UBA is a disaster, and other subjects like Accounting and Law don't have much prestige(maybe because it doesn't matter to those degrees). UBA has its own problems with budget managing, building decay and internal governability issues. Not to mention that is not only free for Argentinians, but free for anyone, which presents extra strains on its budget. Im all up for free coll…

Medicine@UBA a disaster? Are you talking seriously? Do you have arguments to say that?

Many, I took a random class there and had friends there.

1) Decay is tremendous in Medicine: there are pests and cockroaches everywhere. Bathrooms are used very indecently and its not even safe. Girls dont dare go alone to several bathrooms in the building.

2) Under-budgeted: labs are unequipped and classes have an inordinate amount of people for the number of teachers they have.

3) Kafkesque paperwork and Draconian teachers : there are so many people going to medicine in UBA that students get no attention or assistance. The emotional health of med students is disastrous there, people break down a lot.

A few private med schools actually are pretty prestigious and when you study there, you can actually focus on studying medicine and not just surviving an ordeal.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#169
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I live in Peru, next door (give or take a few thousand miles), and completely agree with you w.r.t. Chile being very start-up and generally business-friendly, which does indeed involve government staying out of wealth creators' way, and setting up a couple of programs like Startup Chile. Setting up a new company in Chile can be done in a couple of days now, and much of it online. Peru is following in Chile's footstep…

That radical reform in the 1990s - was it down to Fujimori? I thought he was corrupt. Would be interested to hear your opinion.

Hello das2, sorry for the late reply. Yes, it was down to Fujimori.

It's true that Fujimori is in jail right now, but not for corruption. He's in jail for his overzealous approach to the antiterrorist campaigns that took place in the early 90s.

When the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path, a Maoist terrorist group that nearly managed to overthrow the state in the late 80s/early 90s) were at their peak, Fujimori came to power. Very shortly thereafter, the SL hijacked the Japanese embassy on a night when they had a big event on, kidnapping everyone from the Japanese ambassador to the directors of large Japanese corporations (Toyota, Sony, etc.).

Fujimori ordered a replica of the embassy to be built in the desert, and special forces trained there for weeks in preparation to storm the embassy. The operation was a great success, the kidnappers were killed, only one soldier died, none of the hostages died.

High on this amazing success, Fujimori ordered more campaigns against SL, and managed to pretty much eradicate them from the country. Two campaigns, however, did not go as planned. One at a university called La Cantuta, one in a poor district of Lima called Barrios Altos. Innocent people died in these campaigns, which had received his direct, personal go-ahead. That is what he went to trial for, and the reason he's in jail now.

Fujimori took over when the state itself was a failed state: hyperinflation of both the old Sol and the new Inti, had all but destroyed everyone's savings, political processes were sclerotic, there was enormous bureaucracy, no foreign investment, etc. Fujishock, as it has come to be called, was the process of undoing all this. Fujimori created the new Sol currency which has been a very stable currency ever since. Parliament was closed and replaced with one single congress and a super-simple process of election that elects both the percentage of parliamentary representatives and the president. Bureaucrats were sent home and the machinery of government simplified a great deal.

A lot of investment went into infrastructure, too: where it used to take more than a day for a farmer to take his produce to the nearest city, it can now take just 3 or 4 hours, which means they don't just go once a year but once every month, which puts them more in touch with the market and more responsive to price signals. Many things that would take forever to start (companies, brand registrations, etc.) can now be done online in a couple of days. The country has seen between 6 and 9% annual growth ever since the mid-90s, reducing poverty from over 50% to around 20% today.

Re: Chile is introducing free higher education

#170
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That radical reform in the 1990s - was it down to Fujimori? I thought he was corrupt. Would be interested to hear your opinion.

Hello das2, sorry for the late reply. Yes, it was down to Fujimori. It's true that Fujimori is in jail right now, but not for corruption. He's in jail for his overzealous approach to the antiterrorist campaigns that took place in the early 90s. When the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path, a Maoist terrorist group that nearly managed to overthrow the state in the late 80s/early 90s) were at their peak, Fujimori came to po…

Some corrections about the "embassy" crisis... It wasn't SL, it was Tupac Amaru. It wasn't an embassy, it was an official residence. 1 hostage and 2 soldiers died... It's all on wikipedia.
Post reply on HN