Live data from Hacker News

Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

huffingtonpost.in

21–30 of 203 posts

Re: Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

#21
post #5

Zuckerberg's sly attempt to sneak in free Facebook through Internet.org not gonna work in India.

Oh no! Giving something away for free! The travesty!

This seems a bit naive. The argument is definitely more nuanced than this. For example, Tim Berners Lee has slammed zero-rating as well: http://inform.tmforum.org/news/2015/02/net-neutrality-compro...

Re: Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's important to keep in mind that telco's arguments, that they are losing money or finding it hard to recover their investment costs, have been thoroughly debunked: http://capitalmind.in/2015/04/telecom-companies-are-not-losi...

The original consultation paper also had similar figures. I don't remember correctly but telcos are expected to lose $400 billion from call and SMS decline by 2020. However, they are expected to earn $1.2 trillion from data growth.

Imagine what number would that $1.2 trillion blow up to, if they have it their way of zero-rated apps and differential rating. The TRAI has been clearly unabashedly lobbying on television media for telcos. Isn't the "Telecom Regulatory Authority of India" supposed to act in the benefits of consumer!?

Re: Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

#23
post #12

For everyone interested in tracking the campaign: stats are posted here: https://twitter.com/bulletinbabu

[Offtopic] The campaign provides a bcc address to keep track of the number of emails people actually send. However when I sent a response it bounced for this bcc address, although it was delivered to TRAI.

This happened on the first day of the campaign (the day the AIB video came out) and it is probably fixed now, but this count could be understating things a bit.

Re: Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

#26

Today was phenomenal. The campaign has sent more than 620,000 email to TRAI (Indian equivalent of FCC) who wanted public opinion on whether Internet (or as they say, "Over-the-top services") should be regulated or not. Cleartrip showed courage in being the first one to opt out of Internet.org. A few more soon followed. Tomorrow could be amazing! Edit: Very similar to US, comedians played a pivotal role in popularizin…

Thanks for doing this, guys :)

Re: Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

#28
After limited protest/outrage in communities like /r/india, the news finally hit big when a comedy group AIB decided to make a video explaining what Net Neutrality is: https://youtu.be/mfY1NKrzqi0 and then it finally hit mainstream media. Amid pressure from everywhere, Flipkart finally withdrew from the Airtel Zero deal which would have been a blow to Net Neutrality in India.

Of course, next step was Internet.org and similar initiatives, which on paper sound like a fantastic idea until you look deeper and begin to see the NN violation problem. This is welcome news indeed. Btw, this was Zuckerburg's response when posed this question: https://i.imgur.com/PAwf6e3.png "Some connectivity is better than no connectivity, hence the violation of NN is justified"

Last few days have been a mixture of anxiousness and excitement. :)

Re: Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw

#29

Facebook's internet.org plan to be somewhat hypocritical, given their (correct) stand in favor of net neutrality in the US. internet.org isn't about the internet at all - it's more a proprietary network similar to Compuserve or AOL. It's the same brand of philanthropy that Microsoft practices when it offers discounted Windows and Office to schools.

Yep.
Post reply on HN