Live data from Hacker News

Which Companies Wasted the Most Money on Super Bowl Commercials?

blog.embed.ly

41–45 of 45 posts

Re: Which Companies Wasted the Most Money on Super Bowl Commercials?

#41

I've got a major disconnect with the "facts" at the beginning of this article: Super Bowl ad spots are expensive — ranging from $20M to $135M. ... The cost refers specifically to the Super Bowl ad spot, and not to production of the commercial. But Wikipedia[1] (and countless other links e.g.[2]) claim that a 30 second commercial cost about $4.5 million for the most recent Super Bowl. So how does an ad cost $135 milli…

Wow, bank error in your favor. It looks like we had everything inflated by 10X. Appreciate you pointing this out and surprised no one else caught this including us. We're updating the post to reflect and will throw a mention in there.

Re: Which Companies Wasted the Most Money on Super Bowl Commercials?

#43
post #20

Recalls a SB ad years ago, during the original Internet bubble: E-trade showed a dancing monkey, then the text "Well, we just wasted two million dollars. What are you doing with your money?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnQMq5wtZcg Gotta wonder what that cost them in lost business (you gonna invest with a group that brags about throwing money away?).

Gotta wonder what that won them in new business (you gonna invest with a group that had an add people were talking about more than a decade later?).

I don't invest with E*Trade because of that ad.

I don't buy Belkin products either, for comparable reasons a decade after. (Made routers that would randomly inject ad pages. I still won't so much as buy a cable from them.)

Re: Which Companies Wasted the Most Money on Super Bowl Commercials?

#44
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Gotta wonder what that won them in new business (you gonna invest with a group that had an add people were talking about more than a decade later?).

Kinda amazing they still are producing Super bowl ads. I'm guessing they're not spending too much on production with babys and cats.

Don't they have an 'embrace your inner micromanager' ad campaign now. Isn't that basically the opposite of what you are supposed to do?

Maybe they are targeting dumb money.

Re: Which Companies Wasted the Most Money on Super Bowl Commercials?

#45
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought Coke's commercial was a great response to last year, when there was such a backlash against including a gay couple in their advertising. It's one thing for 4chan to come in and ruin the day, but for an actual company with actual managers and employees to ruin another company's advertising campaign by quoting Hitler? That's crossing a line, unfortunately one that Gawker has crossed many times in the past. Ho…

The commercial last year was the one with 'America The Beautiful' and the backlash was having it sung in other languages besides English. Not really sure where you're pulling the gay thing from.

There was a controversy over America the Beautiful being sung in other languages, but also over the same commercial featuring a gay couple.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/02/03/coke-commercial-gay...

Post reply on HN