Live data from Hacker News

The Old Pirate Bay

oldpiratebay.org

71–80 of 105 posts

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey Adnan, might not be a good idea to tie your porn habbits quite so publicly with all your linkedIn and social media info so clearly visible. Just a heads up from a fellow developer who's done plenty of dumb shit :-)

Are you suggesting that there's anything wrong with an adult viewing filmed consensual sex acts between other adults?

There is... when you're supposed to be in prison for the murder of Hae Min Lee!!

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I do wonder why a more decentralised approach hasn't taken off. In a way, it has! Compared to what it was when it launched 10 years ago, or even what its predecessors (e.g. Napster, Limewire) were, the current TPB is almost completely decentralized, with only one exception. It stopped running its own tracker years ago, relying on other trackers that don't allow for searching (thus absolving themselves of some of th…

Reputation? For my use case, I evaluate a torrent based on the number of seeders. You mentioned that anybody can post a magnet link on any forum. Yes. But where do they get that magnet link from in the first place? I mean, obviously the person who creates the torrent has it. Is that the only way? You mention DHT. My torrent client does that. Hm, is there a client that I can use to "search" DHT? Failing that, is there…

http://www.tribler.org/

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I do wonder why a more decentralised approach hasn't taken off. In a way, it has! Compared to what it was when it launched 10 years ago, or even what its predecessors (e.g. Napster, Limewire) were, the current TPB is almost completely decentralized, with only one exception. It stopped running its own tracker years ago, relying on other trackers that don't allow for searching (thus absolving themselves of some of th…

Reputation? For my use case, I evaluate a torrent based on the number of seeders. You mentioned that anybody can post a magnet link on any forum. Yes. But where do they get that magnet link from in the first place? I mean, obviously the person who creates the torrent has it. Is that the only way? You mention DHT. My torrent client does that. Hm, is there a client that I can use to "search" DHT? Failing that, is there…

You could create a DHT with all known torrents. Kademila was built basically with that in mind. The Kad network works pretty well, but it does face some problems with spam; just sorting by seeders doesn't cut it since a spammer can fake as many seeders as he'd like.

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#74
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Decentralized with quality control would be a hard but interesting problem. You could do upvotes/downvotes using cryptographic signatures use a little web-based authority to let people know whose signatures are reputable.

Maybe a vote weighting that gradually gets heavier, the more honest your account is measured - you are observed upvoting good content, and flagging spam or viruses (imagine if the top HN commenters votes counted more than regular commenters...)? And rapid banning for those who upvote spam. Maybe you unlock additional feaures (like HNs downvote ability as you level up with karma). It might create a "race to the top" i…

By whom? Remember, we're talking decentralized. In Gnutella and the like there is no authority.

So if you want to take the Pirate Bay approach of providing a small authoritative list of "trusted moderators" through the web and have all the users use that filter, you have to keep it simple so that it can be easily replicated if the web-component gets taken down.

Complicating the web/authority component means mirroring it and resurrecting it becomes hard.

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#75
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Almost all the money went towards purchasing equipment and legal fees. I don't think anyone in particular (except maybe the lawyers) got rich off the site.

Keep believing the sob stories. One of the most frequently visited websites is "barely paying for the servers", yeah right. Wish Wikileaks would publish real numbers and profit they make.

It's not like they needed an exorbitant amount of servers either, they host magnet links.

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#76
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Decentralized with quality control would be a hard but interesting problem. You could do upvotes/downvotes using cryptographic signatures use a little web-based authority to let people know whose signatures are reputable.

It's not entirely implausible that authorities might attack the certificate provider. It's a single point of failure... the MPAA decides to fuck with it, gets them shut down, and suddenly no one can filter comments anymore?

Point, but that's a much smaller system to mirror. It can be static. You could bundle a cert list into the client, even.

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#77
post #21

Ok I searched a few porn movies to verify whether they have it completely or not. Glad to tell you that it's really the 'Pirate Bay'

Some functionality is missing. E.g. no users, thus no way to see what else that user has uploaded. On PB some uploaders maintained rather interesting personal collections.

They are using ASP Classic and MsAccess so give them a break

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#78
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Decentralized with quality control would be a hard but interesting problem. You could do upvotes/downvotes using cryptographic signatures use a little web-based authority to let people know whose signatures are reputable.

Maybe a vote weighting that gradually gets heavier, the more honest your account is measured - you are observed upvoting good content, and flagging spam or viruses (imagine if the top HN commenters votes counted more than regular commenters...)? And rapid banning for those who upvote spam. Maybe you unlock additional feaures (like HNs downvote ability as you level up with karma). It might create a "race to the top" i…

The problem with those is always going to be sybil attacks: anyone can create tons of accounts and upvote themselves. Even cross-verification can be defeated: you just make a small network that upvotes each other in some obfuscated manner.

I think there are only two long term solutions:

- Introducing some kind of proof of work -- e.g. you do work to downvote/upvote;

- Some very "localized" reputation -- e.g. you trust the friends of your friends more.

Those ideas are behind the Bitcoin protocol and the Web of Trust, respectively.

In this case each would have it's problems: proof of work is inefficient by design and needs a good hash function not to be exploited; local reputation by design makes it hard to find new/unrelated content.

Re: The Old Pirate Bay

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey Adnan, might not be a good idea to tie your porn habbits quite so publicly with all your linkedIn and social media info so clearly visible. Just a heads up from a fellow developer who's done plenty of dumb shit :-)

Are you suggesting that there's anything wrong with an adult viewing filmed consensual sex acts between other adults?

recently, people have been fired from their jobs when their political affiliations/donations have been made public

i wouldn't put it past someone somewhere out there in the politically correct machine to fire/not hire someone because they admit that they watch porn

Post reply on HN